韩寒视频分析(四) 关于《红楼梦》 作者:安芃

还是在何东的非常道节目访谈中,关于《红楼梦》,韩寒说过一段话,我把他的原话录在下面,这位著名作家是这么说的(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xsM0ODtH2OA 2340秒):

 

         红楼梦我都没有看过,以前红楼梦选秀的时候,他

         们问我说“你对…... 有几个人选出来了,几个丫-

          -几个红楼梦的女-女演员,你对这些女演员怎么看?”

         我说我--我不发表看法。到后来,他实在是逼着

         我要说,把我逼急了,我说我跟你说真话吧,我是

         连红楼梦都没有看过,你跟我说的那些名字,我根

         本就不知道谁是谁,你要我怎么发表看法?我是真

         没有看过红楼梦!

 

 

 

 

说实话,看到这一段,我的确是被雷倒了。

 

这一段话,至少说明了这么几点:

 

第一 ,关于《红楼梦》,韩寒以前一直没有说真话,这次被逼急了,才说了真话。

 

第二 ,韩寒被逼急了之后说的的确是真话,他真的没有看过《红楼梦》。而且,从他的谈话中看出,他对《红楼梦》简直一无所知。

 

第三 ,《三重门》里多处写到《红楼梦》,说明作者对《红楼梦》相当熟悉。韩寒承认对《红楼梦》一无所知,那等于是不打自招,承认了《三重门》有人代笔。

 

其实我这里重点不想强调《三重门》的代笔,而是想借这个题目说说韩寒的学养。

 

《红楼梦》是什么?《红楼梦》仅仅是千万本书当中的一本可读可不读的普普通通的书吗?

 

稍微有点学养的中国人都知道,在中国,《红楼梦》决不仅仅是一本书而已,而是一个文学界文化界绕不过去的影响深远的文学现象和文化现象,是迄今为止中国文学的最高峰,代表着中国文学的最高成就,是中国文化史上的瑰宝。

 

《红楼梦》一书,对近现代中国读书人影响极大,作家阎连科第一次拿到《红楼梦》时,竟然激动得浑身发抖。作家王蒙更是直言不讳地说,如果说我们到了今天连《红楼梦》都读不下去,那是中华民族读书人的耻辱。

 

《红 楼梦》一书,给我们提供了太多的文学经典:人物,情节,场景,甚至词汇:贾宝玉,林黛玉,薛宝钗,史湘云,王熙凤,贾探春,晴雯,袭人;天上掉下个林妹 妹,刘姥姥进大观园,黛玉葬花,宝钗扑蝶,湘云卧石,晴雯撕扇,宝琴踏雪寻梅,凤姐专权,探春当家,香菱学诗;贾雨村言,金玉良缘,木石姻缘等等等等。

 

《红楼梦》作为一种文学文化现象,其实已经进入了人们的日常生活当中,除了《红楼梦》原著,我们如今还有《红楼梦》电影,电视,戏剧,以及海量的和《红楼梦》有关的文章和书籍。对《红楼梦》 中的许多细节,即使一个普通人,只要你稍稍读了点书,只要你稍稍关心一下,哪怕只是看看相关影视作品,你也应该有一定的了解,更何况是一个作家?我实在想象不出,一个中国作家,居然没有读过《红楼梦》,居然一点也不了解《红楼梦》。

 

韩 寒令人惊讶的地方,还不在于他不读《红楼梦》原著,而在于他对《红楼梦》几乎一无所知这一点,这样的无知让人无法理解,也让人心里发凉,这说明他不仅是不 读《红楼梦》原著,而且是根本不看《红楼梦》小人书,也不看《红楼梦》电影,不看《红楼梦》电视,甚至不跟人讨论《红楼梦》,说明他的鉴赏力低劣到对《红 楼梦》根本提不起任何兴趣,否则,他怎么可能连《红楼梦》中的几个主要人物都搞不清楚?

 

在中国,一个对《红楼梦》这样一个对中国文学的影响大得无以复加的文化文学现象如此地无知隔膜,并且如此地漠不关心,排斥抗拒的人,居然还是个作家。

 

他怎么可能是个作家?

 

从韩寒对《红楼梦》的一无所知这一点我们也可以看出,韩寒的学养绝对在普通人之下,一直停留在初中生水平。

 

最后,我想对韩寒和韩寒的支持者说一句:不读《红楼梦》,不懂《红楼梦》,并不是件值得骄傲值得炫耀的事,那只表明了两个字:无知!!!

 

文章来源:http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_13b61999f0102v80k.html

分类: 

参与评分: 

平均评分: 5 (9个评价)

评论

I'm from England 100mg viagra

Randal的头像

I'm from England 100mg viagra questions "Despite the award of the franchise extension, and despite the best efforts of RMT’s negotiators, there had been a further deterioration of industrial relations between RMT and First Great Western and the stack of issues we have identified amount to a catalogue of contempt that the company is clearly displaying for its most important asset – its staff," he added.

Could you ask her to call me?

Paige的头像

Could you ask her to call me? testozyte
Rousseff, a leftist whose Workers' Party has been in power since 2003, said Brazil shared the pope's concern for social justice, pointing to advances against poverty made by her administration and that of her predecessor, Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva.

I went to

Magic的头像

I went to advancedvetmedcenter.com Lane was out jogging during a visit to his girlfriend and her family in Duncan on Friday, when he was shot in the back, police said. He attended East Central University in Ada, Oklahoma, where he was on a baseball scholarship.

Just over two years

Bryon的头像

Just over two years achetercipro.com The action on the two separate measures, to continue fundingthe government and increase the government's borrowing authorityby raising the debt ceiling, may begin as early as this week inthe House, starting with the funding measure on Thursday orFriday.

I saw your advert in the

Josue的头像

I saw your advert in the paper shop4builders.co.uk "But when I approached people for interviews, I discovered that nobody, and I mean nobody, was interested in helping me make this film. Not Democrats, not Republicans - and certainly nobody who works with the Clintons, wants access to the Clintons, or dreams of a position in a Hillary Clinton administration," Ferguson wrote.

Is there ? meds-inc.com "It

Bradly的头像

Is there ? meds-inc.com "It is abundantly clear that the testing of Jamaican athletes before London was extensive and thorough - and continues to be so today," International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) spokesman Chris Turner said in an email to Reuters.

I've just started at arctic

Stephanie的头像

I've just started at arctic zero nutritional facts Like the film, the musical will be based on actor Channing Tatum's experiences of working as a male stripper. Soderbergh and Tatum funded Magic Mike themselves before its release last year, and the film became a box office hit, taking $113 million (£73 million) worldwide. A sequel is already being planned.

Where are you from? richland

Kenny的头像

Where are you from? richland mortgage company "The accusations relate to the alleged actions of theaccused in various operations carried out in a systematic andrecurrent fashion during 2009, 2010 and 2011, which allow us topresume the existence of a trading scheme with Calichera A, OroBlanco and SQM shares," SVS said.

I can't hear you very well

Jimmy的头像

I can't hear you very well amitriptyline for back pain 10mg "I don't think the results are surprising, at least not for someone who is familiar with what research has said about skin cancer counseling practices," said Dr. Jennifer S. Lin, who studies evidence-based healthcare decision making at The Center for Health Research of Kaiser Permanente Northwest in Portland, Oregon.

A few months viagra sin

Lyndon的头像

A few months viagra sin receta en farmacias precio
The Yankees’ third baseman, who hasn’t played since last October because of January hip surgery, was 0-for-3 at the plate with an RBI. In the field, he started a double play, but couldn’t quite get to a ball in the hole between third and short. It was the first time he had played four games in four days and he reported no discomfort, which he called “a good sign.”

Have you got a current

Samual的头像

Have you got a current driving licence? estrace for ivf side effects Net ticket yields fell 4.6 percent in the third quarterwhile yields from onboard entertainment fell about 1 percent,Chief Financial Officer David Bernstein said on a post-earningsconference call. Net revenue yields, a blend of the two, wasdown 3.8 percent on a constant currency basis.

Where do you study?

Sydney的头像

Where do you study? weightloss-pharmacy.net She plans to return for more exhumations next year, and she's encouraged by the county's progress, noting that the short-staffed sheriff's office is going to start taking DNA samples from family members who come looking for missing loved ones.

Is it convenient to talk at

Haywood的头像

Is it convenient to talk at the moment? zithromax buy online Designer doesn’t need to be over-priced. LUX FIX works with independent designers who invest in the product, not in huge marketing teams, and makes it easy to shop directly from the designers’ studios with a single checkout and free shipping.

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。