韩寒补赛,真相大白 作者:微易

来源:http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_538601cd0102v90c.html

作者:@我是微易  博客网址:http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/articlelist_1401291213_3_1.html

 

真相隐藏在谎言里!

 

韩寒参加的首届新概念作文大赛,引起了巨大争议,真相到底如何?

下面,我将从剖析一等奖的评选情况开始,还原出韩寒补赛的历史真相。

1999年5月号《萌芽》杂志刊登的“第一届新概念作文大赛评奖揭晓”一文中说:“复赛结束后大赛评委分成几组,连夜对复赛试卷进行了评分。然后再综合初、复赛的成绩评定出一等奖20名。”(参见后面的附件)

在韩寒补赛被质疑后,时任评委方方2012年2月24日在《关于韩寒参加新概念大赛的记忆》一文中回忆说:“复赛的目的主要是验证初赛稿件是不是他本人所写。初赛和复赛两分相加的平均分为最终得分。以最终得分来评奖。”(参见:http://book.163.com/12/0224/19/7R27NIOS00924JJL_all.html

2012年2月底,赵长天接受网易娱乐独家专访时说:“事实就是前一天晚上我们评委都把它(复试的文章)看完了,分数都已经统计出来了,统计出来以后,一般评委第二天开会就是把之前统计的分数讲一讲,然后我们评委定一定有几个人(能够获奖),比方说4分以上就算(得奖),看看有多少人,比如说19、20个人,或者掐到4.1分或者3.9分,就把这个(得奖名单)定下来。”(参见:http://ent.163.com/12/0229/08/7RDR8VL500031H2L.html

现在,沈阳和平区法院又调取到一份手写的评奖办法,是在公证处的档案里保存的,是这样说的:“评委对初评委选出的作品进行审读,同样在每篇作品前标明☆和△,然后根据☆和△数量多少,取A组14名、B组5名、C组一名为一等奖。”(见后面的附件)

这份手写的评奖情况说明却说:一等奖只按初赛作品评选,不是按综合初赛、复赛得分评奖。

 

这份手写的评奖情况说明是不是实情呢?

请大家看一看附件中的《一等奖名单》。在这份名单中,杨倩的《缺口的苹果》和许人杰的《成佛的苹果》,是复赛的作品。显然,按初赛投稿作品的得☆数评奖,是不符合事实的谎言。

也就是说:一等奖是根据初赛和复赛的综合评分评选出来的,不是仅仅根据初赛作品。1999年5月号《萌芽》杂志关于大赛的报道以及2012年方方和赵长天的回忆,也印证了这一事实。

 

这份没有落款和公章的伪证材料,为什么会在公证档案中呢?

《萌芽》杂志社向沈阳和平区法院提供的《关于首届新概念作文大赛韩寒补赛的情况说明》中说,是时任《萌芽》杂志社主编赵长天撰写的、交给公证处存档的,是想说明B组的获奖人数应为五人而非原先获奖名单中的四人,这多出来的一个名额属于韩寒。

至此,我们已经明白了,这份造假的情况说明,是想把韩寒塞进《公证书》中的一等奖名单中!

我们再看看这份奇怪的一等奖名单。只所以说是奇怪,是因为即有电脑打印的名单,又有手写的获奖作品、得到的☆数和备注。

 

为什么严格审查、校对、打印的《公证书》,会出现手写的重要内容呢?

结合《萌芽》杂志社向法院提供的情况说明,我立刻就明白了:公证员在1999年3月28日上午,监督见证了一等奖名单的评选,并且拿到了根据初赛和复赛综合得分选取的一等奖名单。回到公证处后,根据这份名单制作完成了《公证书》。

当把这份《公证书》送到《萌芽》杂志社的时候,《萌芽》杂志社发现其中没有韩寒,希望公证员能把韩寒加进去,就手写了一份没有落款的情况说明交给公证处,我猜测交给公证处的,还应该有一份伪造的初赛作品评☆表。由于时间太匆忙,炮制这份伪证材料者不小心把两篇复赛作品写了进去,留下了做假的铁证。

公证员看到炮制的评奖情况说明和作品评☆表后,就把作品题目和得☆数写在了每个作者的右边空白处。这样,名单顺序按得☆数排列已经乱套了,公证员只能再手写注明“排名不分先后”,还特别在底部手写上了“10名评委投票,凡五票以上均入选,一次成功”,意思是说“我只对自己监督见证的评选名单出具公证书”,拒绝把韩寒列入《公证书》中的一等奖名单中。

 

至止,韩寒参加首届新概念作文大赛一等奖的争议,已经真相大白:

韩寒的一等奖是《萌芽》杂志社私相授予的,所谓的评奖情况说明是非法炮制的伪证材料,韩寒的一等奖在上海黄浦区公证处出具的《公证书》里,已经给出了明确无误的答案。

《萌芽》杂志社在收到《公证书》后,就已经知道了韩寒的一等奖是无效的,其后还大肆宣传,蒙骗了社会和公众15年。

 

那份手写的评奖情况说明,是不是赵长天撰写、交给公证处的呢?

谁抄写的,可以通过笔迹鉴定出来。是不是赵长天起草的,则有很大疑问。

赵长天在2012年2月底接受采访时,好象完全忘了手写的评奖情况说明,较真实的介绍了评奖情况,而李其纲却在《新概念作文大赛的N个回答》中介绍的评奖情况与手写的评奖情况说明基本相同,我个人认为李其纲炮制了这份伪证材料的嫌疑最大。(参见李其纲的博客:http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_9c199d9301010hjj.html

 

到底是谁炮制了蒙骗公证处、法庭的伪证材料呢?也许只有司法介入,才能调查清楚。

 

作者:@我是微易  

博客网址:http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/articlelist_1401291213_3_1.html

2014.10.15于青岛

分类: 

参与评分: 

平均评分: 5 (4个评价)

评论

既然复赛的初衷是排除“代写”,那么复赛写得反差太大的

访客的头像

既然复赛的初衷是排除“代写”,那么复赛写得反差太大的、不来参加复赛的,无论其人的初赛文章写得是如何天花乱坠高高在上排名第一,统统应该认为初赛的文章是“代写”的,何况此人虽然看联系地址是学生,但又不是学校统一推荐的,更可疑,已经可以将这人从潜在的、未来的学生获奖名单中剔除掉了,这才是正常的反应和结论。

 

根本没必要多此一举的在复赛文章已经打分完毕、讨论决定获奖名单的时候,还去询问什么“不来的原因”,搞什么“给个机会”补赛。

 

Marlon Byrd phoenix suns

wq123的头像

Marlon Byrd phoenix suns cashed woolrich mens jackets in horloges on his nike mercurial comeback season. Byrd and the ralph lauren polos Philadelphia Phillies agreed dre beats Tuesday to a new orleans pelicans $16 million, two-year juicy couture contract, a deal true religion jeans men that fred perry uk came less occhiali ray ban than swarovski jewelry a year lions nfl jersey after he was fitflop outlet playing cheap oakley sunglasses in Mexicos juicy couture outlet winter skechers league. michael kors outlet The ralph lauren factory store 36-year-old outfielder hit vans a coach outlet usa career-high polo ralph lauren 24 ravens nfl jersey homers last season puma online for hollister kids the New York Mets calvin klein underwear and Pittsburgh, which acquired marc jacobs him tory burch handbags on Aug. 27. He air max batted .364 with jordans one philipp plein clothing homer hogan and tommy hilfiger five RBIs in skechers shoes outlet six levi's jeans playoff five finger shoes games giuseppe shoes after hitting .291 nike during the season valentino with 88 RBIs, louboutin outlet one short softball bats of his career best. "Marlon givenchy handbags adds christian louboutin a new balance significant cavaliers jerseys upgrade both air force offensively new balance and knockoff handbags defensively oakley canada to our outfield," Phillies indoor soccer shoes general manager Ruben Amaro bottega veneta Jr. said rolex replica in a hollister statement. jaguars nfl jersey "He has orlando magic jersey been particularly burberry handbags outlet productive against michael kors purses left-handed pitching, which was a serious michael kors purses challenge nike air max 2014 for michael kors us this hermes past coach factory season." nike shoes outlet Byrd tommy hilfiger was prada handbags drafted falcons nfl jersey by the omega watches Phillies chiefs nfl jersey and began his big league career in nike air huarache Philadelphia. tory burch shoes His discount shoes agreement calls hermes bags for $8 tommy hilfiger million longchamp outlet in each burberry handbags outlet of chrome hearts store the next two seasons ralph lauren and michael kors includes an $8 million team new balance shoes option colts nfl jersey for marc jacobs 2016, mcm handbags The ralph lauren outlet online option nike air yeezy would louboutin become mcm bags guaranteed packers nfl jersey if ray bans he bears nfl jersey has 1,100 at-bats in browns nfl jersey the next two seasons, including at least 550 in steelers nfl jersey 2015, 49ers nfl jersey or ecco outlet online 600 cowboys nfl jersey at-bats in 2015. "If you air max 90 dont want jazz jersey to give up your first-round pick, louboutin uk Marlon handbags outlet Byrd hilfiger outlet is soccer shoes arguably the north face best available birkenstock taschen outlet outfield bat," michael kors taschen Pirates kings jersey general ferragamo shoes manager prada Neal nike free Huntington said. "We redskins nfl jersey feared he was red bottom shoes out prada shoes of fidget spinner our price range immediately. We stayed mbt mens shoes engaged raptors jersey in hilfiger outlet the process, denver nuggets jersey and barbour jackets Marlon wizards jersey and his oakley sunglasses outlet agents air max talked about omega wanting swarovski to supra footwear come ray ban wayfarer back thomas sabo to Pittsburgh. He loved his time there. The environment michael kors and playing stone island outlet for azcardinals nfl jersey a rockets jersey winner ferragamo and designer handbags playing coach purses factory in polo ralph front of that fan ray bans base was something michael kors bags that really intrigued nike him." A longchamp career .280 hollister hitter with true religion outlet 106 occhiali oakley homers ferragamo shoes and 533 RBIs, michael kors purses Byrd was released cheap glasses by Boston in June 2012, burberry outlet online then puma sneakers given ralph lauren outlet a michael kors 50-game suspension longchamp 11 days later following a adidas positive ralph lauren polos test dwyane wade jersey for hilfiger online shop Tamoxifen, which north face can reduce oakley sunglasses side roshe runs effects of birkenstock shoes steroid use and kids hoodies increase testosterone. At the coach store outlet time, michael kors Byrd veneta said adidas outlet he fake rolex mistakenly seahawks nfl jersey used the cheap nike shoes medication for a recurrence mizuno running of a ray ban sunglasses outlet condition air max one that earlier ray ban outlet required handbags outlet surgery. He says he vikings nfl jersey did atlanta hawks jersey not use it for performance air max enhancement. He played winter ball for the Tomateros jordan jerseys de beats by dr dre Culiacan salvatore ferragamo (Culiacan burberry Tomato Growers) and signed michael kors handbags a broncos nfl jersey minor league coach handbags contract plein outlet with the Mets on katespade Feb. eyeglasses stores 1. He supra shoes wound michael kors outlet up on their big kobe bryant jerseys league roster for a base hollisterco salary of michael kors bags $700,000 and earned adidas canada another titans nfl jersey $100,000 in performance bonuses based on plate appearances. Both the dollars vans shoes and burberry sale the charlotte hornets jerseys years the north face outlet offered by michael kors outlet the Phillies hermes birkin bag were cheap true religion at a panthers nfl jersey level prada sunglasses the air max 2015 Pirates were ed hardy unprepared to match ralph lauren online shop in talks with agents Sam cheap jerseys and Seth Levinson. "The timing really kate spade outlet online bit us, and texans nfl jersey Ruben saints nfl jersey did ralph lauren outlet online a cheap jerseys great coach outlet sale job coach store online of going asics gel out and getting his guy oakley early -- hugo boss clothes what longchamp black friday we did dsquared2 outlet with north face Russ north face backpacks Martin a chaussure timberland year ago," Huntington dolphins nfl jersey said. "We werent ralph lauren in a position to be able buccaneers nfl jersey to pandora schmuck move rolex watches this cartier montres quickly." oakley sunglasses Mets cheap barbour jackets general manager Sandy true religion jeans women Alderson bcbg max said new balance canada the deal was an indication beats audio of inflation in free-agent nike prices. ray ban "Had you nike shoes asked me nba jersey the salvatore ferragamo question jordan three or four cheap mlb jerseys months barbour jackets ago, long champ I timberland shoes might ralph lauren have pandora charms been michael kors outlet surprised, burberry but not vans in the light of whats dansko outlet happened since the end reebok of the season," he said. oakley "There havent been that many signings, but this ralph lauren polo one is dallas mavericks jerseys consistent with the others." lunette oakley Philadelphia air max had coach handbags sought a right-handed babyliss pro hitting cheap michael kors outfielder cheap ray ban with power since aktienkurse adidas Jayson adidas online Werth cheap nhl jerseys left for red bottoms Washington air jordans following the nike air max 2010 michael kors handbags season. brooklyn nets jersey Ben fred perry outlet Francisco, knicks jersey John ralph lauren outlet online Mayberry Jr. and Delmon burberry handbags Young werent solutions; ray ban Hunter Pence was acquired burberry sale in golden state warriors jerseys July 2011 and michael kors traded a year hogan outlet later. Darin Ruf ray-ban sunglasses hit 14 cheap jordans homers in 251 at-bats fendi bags last season while starting polo ralph lauren outlet 27 oakley vault games nike air max in cheap nhl jerseys right nike air max field, chargers nfl jersey 15 in left oakley and prada outlet 28 nike free run at first michael kors base. But oakley black friday Ruf, timberland outlet a ray ban sunglasses outlet converted first baseman, is coach outlet online hardly the oakley sunglasses outlet defensive player adidas outlet Byrd is giuseppe zanotti sneakers and is ray ban outlet online viewed longchamp handbags as a role burberry player. Philadelphias cheap clothes outfielders hit mont blanc .259 tn pas cher with 57 clippers jersey homers and san antonio spurs jersey a .407 slugging percentage this year. barbour jackets Byrd could be a kevin durant jersey major upgrade. "He is an experienced michael kors handbags middle-of-the-order hitter who bcbg max azria creates some balance to our chi hair lineup," Amaro said. "With his talent kate spade outlet online and michael kors clubhouse celine bags presence, we believe converse Marlon will be louboutin outlet a solid addition converse sneakers to our club as we address ray ban outlet our new balance outlet needs nike tracksuits and longchamp outlet plan bucks jersey to contend in birkenstock 2014 and pandora beyond." nike outlet store Byrd was pandora once a prized prospect in the Phillies jimmy choo shoes minor league system. polo ralph lauren He nike canada finished patriots nfl jersey fourth hollister co in NL jets nfl jersey Rookie nike outlet of the watches canada Year voting coach outlet canada in roshe 2003 after asics hitting .303, giants nfl jersey but struggled air jordan shoes the north face outlet next ralph lauren uk two cheap mlb jerseys seasons oakley sunglasses outlet and jimmy choo outlet was traded to timberwolves jersey Washington. rams nfl jersey Byrd converse shoes has also played roshe run for under armour curry Texas, the Chicago nike Cubs nba jersey and Boston in a 12-year adidas career true religion with jerseys from china seven oakley sunglasses teams. He cheap oakley was burberry outlet an ray ban black friday NL All-Star swarovski crystal with lunette ray ban the Cubs max shoes in 2010 and his best season before last free run year came with raiders nfl jersey the ralph lauren outlet Rangers in 2009 nike roshe when he batted .283 michael kors with philadelphia 76ers jerseys 20 nike roche run homers michael kors uk and 89 christian louboutin shoes RBIs. Nike Roshe One Herre . nfl jerseys -- huarache Von Miller cheap true religion is back nike air force -- nike and fossil uhren bigger than ever. Nike Roshe One swarovski online Slip sort . swarovski jewelry According coach outlet online to timberland boots a burberry handbags report from the north face the New York Posts beats by dr dre Page Six, burberry sale Katy Perry baseball bats will perform thomas sabo at halftime bills nfl jersey of coach bags Super Bowl bengals nfl jersey XLIX at the University of cheap oakley sunglasses Phoenix Stadium.MILAN, Italy -- Inter ralph lauren Milan nike mercurial has signed lacoste outlet online highly rated coach handbags outlet defender air jordan retro Danilo DAmbrosio northface from Torino. The iphone 5 cases clubs tommy hilfiger have replica rolex been converse in negotiations since DAmbrosio nike air max revealed eagles nfl jersey he hollister would nike air huarache not michael kors handbags renew oakley sunglasses cheap his contract mcm handbags at Torino instyler beyond boston celtics the salomon summer, nike outlet and ray ban on Thursday, coach store Inter nba jerseys confirmed cheap jerseys he was contracted jordans to omega watches 2018. hogan women shoes DAmbrosio says versace shoes outlet "its so emotional replica rolex to nike air max 2014 be north face jackets here ... Ive michael kors canada come a long longchamp way oakley vault and armani shoes outlet now grizzlies jersey Im ray ban outlet at Inter, I cant coach outlet online bbe dsquared2 jeans anything else but very proud. nike roshe Nike Roshe polo ralph lauren outlet online One nike.com Flyknit mcm bags bl?. " The 25-year-old DAmbrosio will ray ban be versace clothes hoping the mcm handbags outlet move boosts basketball shoes his trail blazers jersey chance adidas of making coach factory outlet online Italys pandora jewelry World Cup squad. Hes nike Air Max Plaza yet to burberry outlet store play nike free run 5.0 for skechers mens shoes Italy. DAmbrosio ray ban sonnenbrillen is new ralph lauren online president Erik pacers jersey Thohirs coach factory online first signing for Inter. swarovski canada His predecessor Massimo Morattis first hollisterco signing pandora uk was ipad mini cases club nike huaraches captain Javier north face Zanetti. barbour outlet online Inter michael kors visits Juventus on cheap oakley sunglasses Sunday. chi flat iron

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。