质疑尹建莉对韩寒的看法 作者:好个秋Educ

尹建莉在《好妈妈胜过好老师》的第65页谈及韩寒的一些内容(以下引号内的三段文字便是原文)。尹建莉为了说明喜欢阅读(尤其是课外阅读)对学生学习的重要性,引用了韩寒这一极端的个案,说成绩差的韩寒就是因为喜欢阅读所以聪慧所以有成就。 

“当然也有偏科偏向语文的,语文学得很好,作文写得漂亮,数理化学得很差。比如少年作家韩寒。阅读对他们的考试成绩似乎并没有成全。  

这个问题要这样理解:造成他不喜欢数理科目的原因很多,教师、家庭、天赋、同学等都可能成为影响因素。阅读当然不能强大到解决所有的问题、补救所有的不足。但有一点是肯定的,他数学成绩差,绝不是阅读造成的。这样的孩子,所幸他们喜欢阅读,无论上不上大学,他们都是聪慧的,都可以取得相应的成就。这样看,阅读于他们仍然是件幸运的事。  

而那些从不读课外书或很少读课外书、数理科目学得较差、人文科目只是相对学得较好的学生,他们的情况不叫“偏科”,事实上他们的人文科目也并不出色。谁能见到一个几乎不读课外书的人在文史考试中取得了优异的成绩?这些孩子和韩寒这类孩子的情况又有很大差异。”

当时(2011年)一翻而过没什么特别留意。等到2012年方舟子等人质疑韩寒,开始关注韩寒的代笔事件。去年(2014年)记起该书中有过提及韩寒的段落。

虽然我从此书中受益良多,但当确认韩寒代笔后,尤其是自己分析出韩寒对其女儿的不妥教育后(《这里会长出一朵花 中 韩寒的苛责和欺骗》:http://t.cn/RZlhDYf),觉得有必要说说这部被誉为经典教育作品的失实之处。

最近在网上找到尹建莉于2012年2月16日在其搜狐微博和腾讯微博(可能新浪微博也发布过)发布了一段话:“如果方舟子近日能向韩寒或公众说:对不起,这一次我下结论太快太草率,打错人了,抱歉——那么他将得到更多的尊敬。公众将不仅敬佩他以前打假的勇气,更敬佩他做人的真诚和坦率。他也为社会、尤其是青少年树立了一个真正的勇敢者的形象。他此时的“坚持打假”其实已经很假,只让人看到人性的脆弱和怯懦。”现在看来,她把自己的观点先入为主了。

其实在@尹建莉的微博 里多数涉及到韩寒的微博评论中许多读者都对作者对韩寒的态度提出了异议和合理的原因。比如几位读者这么说(省去帐号名,有截图保留):

1:“凡是正常的家长都不会让自己的孩子以韩寒为榜样,不读书反对学习,这样的人也就在大陆才有市场,从盖兹到老乔哪个不是经过10000个小时训练出来的,天才都是训练出来的,投机取巧想都不要想,钱钟书的书没有看明白就可以引用自如?代笔了,作家的草稿有那末干净的嘛,兼听则明。

2:“尹老师关注现在教学方法对孩子的伤害,我一直觉得非常有价值;但有许多证据证明可能以造假起家的韩某,尽管揭露了教育体制乃至很多方面的弊病,但若造假属实,就不能作为孩子们的榜样,否则孩子们的价值观会更加混乱。您觉得呢?”

3: “韩寒言论前后矛盾实在太多,早年写文章学钱钟书引经据典,后来参加访谈多次说不读书以为那是装*。HH门中探索事实的人,有态度严谨逻辑缜密的,如果您有兴趣,我推荐彭晓芸女士和方舟子先生本人的微博或博客,都凭事实说话,您也许会吃惊地看到一个不同的韩寒。”

她的这些微博下方的普遍评论多,而点赞极少,正说明了尹建莉观点中存在的问题。

尹建莉在写书稿时很可能没有仔细通读过署名韩寒的早年作品(尤其是《三重门》),仅凭新闻报道确信了他爱好阅读并在极强写作能力的传闻(《杯中窥人》这篇估计看过,赞叹过),而韩寒的成绩之差恰好入她所考虑的偏科主题视角,作为一个极端特例编入书稿,以说明阅读对学生重要性。

这其实是她作为一名毕业于北师大教育硕士的失误。我曾试图分析过造成韩寒叛逆性格原因中其父亲的因素 (《矛盾的韩仁均和受其影响的韩寒》: http://t.cn/RPgFAwQ),结果很明显:韩仁均对韩寒造成了很大的影响。

尹建莉如果能够运用她所学的教育学和心理学理论和知识对材料做分析(尤其是韩仁均写的《儿子韩寒》),也能得出同样结论,而且很可能比我做得更好,更何况她相信家庭比学校对学生的能够产生更大更深远的影响,不然为何叫《好妈妈胜过好老师》? 

尹建莉这次失误不但对读者产生一定程度的误导,且因为《好妈妈胜过好老师》连续畅销5年,总销售量已超过500万册,远销韩国、越南和台湾地区,所以影响面特别广。虽不可否认它是书市上一本难得的家庭教育好书。但有社会争议的话也要做及时研究分析,如果认识到错误也要及时地更正。

《好孩子:三分天注定,七分靠教育》是尹建莉主编,洪兰供稿的一本通俗描写脑神经科学与孩子的学习和生活之间存在的密切关联性的教育类读物。尹建莉试图通过该书对《好妈妈胜过好老师》中一些孩子的学习和生活问题从脑神经科学角度做的一些补充解释,来印证其观点的正确性。

洪兰(Daisy L. Hung,1947年5月29日-),祖籍福建省同安,生于台北市,现任国立中央大学认知神经科学研究所教授兼所长,知名台湾科学家。她多年来致力于脑科学的研究,以及相关知识在教育的应用和推广。为了提升华人对于生命科学的知识,已翻译四十多本科普英文书籍,其中最著名者包括美国心理学家Steven Pinker的The Language Instinct(语言本能)以及2002年诺贝尔经济学奖得主丹尼尔·卡内曼所著Thinking, Fast and Slow (中文书名《快思慢想 》)。【来自维基百科】

这里介绍《好孩子:三分天注定,七分靠教育 》和洪兰博士是要说明两人虽然都研究家庭教育,但是专业不同,尹建莉主要通过教育学和心理学结合自身育女实际做分析,而洪兰是通过科学。也就是说,尹建莉对学习科学的了解不深刻,而对技术细节鉴别能力也不强,主要做思想和现象上的分析。

因为在《好孩子:三分天注定,七分靠教育 》的序中尹建莉写道:“教育学是一门边界模糊的学问,心理学是一门尚且幼稚的科学,它们研究的层面主要在“思想”和“现象”上;所以在对一些现实问题的解释上,有时会力不从心。”因此,希望尹建莉(@尹建莉的微博) 面对事实,研究问题,看清韩寒。    

 

分类: 

参与评分: 

平均评分: 5 (6个评价)

评论

magnificent. air max the nike

wty123的头像

magnificent. air max the nike outlet boy air jordan shoes fell ray ban outlet to nike huaraches his nike tn requin knees, cheap jerseys crying fake rolex up. air max 90 he polo ralph thanked adidas shoes God ray ban that giuseppe shoes he san antonio spurs believed michael kors outlet online sale his coach outlet online destiny, air jordan retro so michael kors bags that ralph lauren black friday one cleveland cavaliers jerseys day cheap oakley sunglasses he pandora met mont blanc pens a ray ban wayfarer sage, barbour women jackets a hermes bags crystal oakley prescription shop cheap jerseys owner, designer handbags an rayban Englishman, burberry handbags and adidas.se an houston rockets alchemist, nfl chargers especially the nfl bills desert barbour women jackets met nike free shoes a burberry outlet online woman, burberry online shop this hollister clothing store woman longchamp made oakley sunglasses cheap him adidas.de understand adidas sneakers that givenchy bags outlet love michael kors black friday never nfl eagles let bcbg max azria a ralph lauren shirts person true religion away longchamp from their north face jackets destiny. nfl browns experienced many jerseys from china centuries mia jersey of christian louboutin Egyptian soccer outlet online pyramid louboutin outlet have.Thank michael kors handbags you, nfl raiders little longchamp outlet horse!If gsw jerseys you, like mizuno running shoes a deep mcm outlet and tory burch sale passionate jerseys from china feelings, nfl 49ers I minnesota timberwolves can omega watches not barbour mens jackets understand. nike.dk A dallas mavericks jersey person in such longchamp handbags warm new balance years, nfl patriots is milwaukee bucks a clothing websites gift woolrich outlet online given nfl jerseys to michael kors purses me converse outlet the cheap true religion best michael kors gift.That nfl rams sentence ralph lauren at nfl dolphins the ray ban outlet beginning toms outlet of russell westbrook jersey a year ago, nike roshe looks new balance shoes like nba jerseys you ralph lauren tracksuits said. air jordans A dsquared2 shoes few ray ban sunglasses days nike air ago, celine black friday you rolex asked michael kors bags me which north face pas cher one converse chucks you cheap nike shoes belong ferragamo to, bottega veneta you should cheap oakley know michael kors handbags it cheap michael kors now. shop coach factory If coach black friday you coach black friday do ralph lauren polo not asics know, asics gel I air max 95 tell gafas oakley you, "small ralph lauren outlet horse, babyliss a nfl cowboys warm michaelkors.com man burberry in beats audio my nike.de life." nfl titans Such prada outlet an prada handbags encounter nets jersey very instyler ionic styler grateful, coach outlet because you burberry handbags have adidas superstar such swarovski an barbour outlet experience michael kors bags and ray bans alerted nba jerseys the michael kors handbags world replica watches to nfl vikings have versace shoes outlet a mcm handbags feeling roshe run like roshe run that. nfl redskins If michael kors you swarovski can coach factory outlet online not tommy hilfiger outlet stores appreciate coach factory outlet online such hogan a nike air warm tommy hilfiger and marc jacobs handbags happy ralph lauren uk and nfl giants happy replica watches for hilfiger my polo ralph lauren outlet people, sac jerseys warm thomas sabo the the north face Love hollister and washington wizards make louboutin shoes life tory burch sandals more chi hair of kobe bryant jersey a coach purses gorgeous michael kors purses color. womens hoodies Is memphis grizzlies set ray ban to mcm bags have, northface it nike free shoes is timberland outlet perfect.Accompanied hermes birkin by jordans for sale two salvatore ferragamo decades oakley black friday later, ecco women shoes you beats by dre are burberry bags outlet perfectly ray ban zonnebril done, nfl steelers I replica watches am oakley sunglasses very shoes on sale happy, supra footwear thank toms shoes you!So, nfl bears you nfl lions are roshes happy!2013.3.20"Six" tommy hilfiger of timberland homme time nike free run and space hugo boss outlet - puma outlet store a nfl falcons visionary.Surging north face backpacks crowd, michael kors outlet online and jordan release dates from jordan shoes intensive, wholesale handbags only fantasy ua stephen curry and watches lost, burberry outlet there utah jazz is ferragamo shoes no celine handbags reason, huaraches no nop jerseys signs, nfl saints but baseball jerseys also relojes especiales intimate katespade outlet with, nike air max to vans outlet hug kevin durant shoeskobe bryant shoes and oakley sunglasses outlet smile.Time oakley sunglasses outlet mob toronto raptors can ray ban sunglasses not air max shoes be free run shared, ralph lauren online because levis outlet store only the north face this timberland boots time coach factory outlet online in nfl jaguars their air max 2015 own nike online and rayban sunglasses in rolex replica the burberry uk same pandora time. mbt shoes outlet The nfl panthers witness is nfl texans not longchamp outlet being juicy couture pulled mcm bags out vibram shoes of nike outlet the north face outlet eyes replica rolex of ralph lauren outlet others.If roche run you ralph lauren factory store gratitude, michael kors bags is nike air max 2015 set marc jacobs outlet to have pandora bracelets such iphone 4s cases a tommy hilfiger online shop definition, converse shoes and polo ralph lauren outlet online bravery toms shoes outlet persisted air max forward.Only coach outlet I, swarovski jewelry at flat iron this nike.com time valentino shoes outlet there. kate spade outlet online Wander rayban alone, ralph lauren with cheap michael kors lonely burberry outlet online and nike.se isolated bos jersey I nike store think hilfiger outlet particularly oakley sunglasses emotional, cheap true religion hang calvin klein some dsquared2 jeans old, cheap jerseys still michael kors outlet online young.There jimmy choo shoes is michael kors outlet online sale such swarovski australia a, new balance you must philipp plein clothes adhere ralph lauren to ray-ban sunglasses the juicy couture clothings harvest, tory burch shoes freedom air max 2014 and montre pas cher lonely reebok days.There baseball bats is michael kors outlet such toms.com a, longchamp taschen fantasy, philadelphia 76ers jersey continuing toms outlet the toms outlet search vans schuhe for cheap eyeglasses and zapatillas nike proud christian louboutin shoes of the replica handbags time.Dawn is chrome hearts jewelry beautiful, adidas the hollister online shop deutschland only pandora time wedding dresses uk in prada outlet the new balance store rotation nfl azcardinals of free running their polo outlet online own, hollister there is the north face outlet narcissistic coach outlet and indifferent cheap ray ban to jerseys from china pull designer handbags off.Sunset true religion outlet in ray ban sunglasses outlet good, if north face woke swarovski up, oakley everything jimmy choo changed, nike air max we orlando magic can charlotte hornets jersey return armani clothing to nike air force the lunette ray ban pas cher original oakley dream.Sit nba jerseys on cheap glasses the los angeles clippers 11th floor nfl buccaneers of knicks jerseys the barbour mens jackets balcony, tory burch shoes the michael kors sun shines nike air max in new balance a hermes outlet good michael kors v?skor smell taste, coach outlet warm, with nike roshe shares nfl bengals irresistible fendi outlet online breath, polo ralph lauren and scarpe hogan slowly soccer shoes spread dre beats in ray ban sunglasses the nike free 5.0 air.Named michael kors bags to air jordan a bottega cup ray ban of polo ralph lauren outlet "Love michael kors in ray ban sunglasses the prada time", bcbg dresses but oakley outlet online is true religion jeans outlet against ralph lauren outlet online the lunette oakley pas cher strawberry burberry outlet online and abercrombie juice cheap oakley out kate spade pretty nfl chiefs pink, louboutin in burberry sale a glass, chicago bulls but a nfl packers kind portland trail blazers of the north face fragmented polo ralph lauren feeling.Walking burberry handbags time, intermittent cheap oakley sunglasses time, vans shoes every nike air max day cheap basketball shoes walking, burberry handbags I nike mercurial vapor walk softball bats every red bottoms day cheap oakley sunglasses more uhren and nfl jets more salomon schuhe long hollister co time. beats by dre Some denver nuggets stubborn nfl broncos factor ed hardy clothing within coach outlet online the mcm backpack outlet body, hollister kids try longchamp black friday to long champ be indiana pacers brave is coach handbags outlet becoming ralph lauren uk increasingly iphone 5 cases apparent.This swarovski crystal time, true religion jeans women the coach factory online window nfl seahawks of adidas shoes outlet the polo ralph lauren King, michael kors outlet online is nfl colts a michael kors green, nike huarache because nike air max 2014 under plein outlet the timberland shoes rain's pandora jewellery sake. michael kors outlet Branches ray ban black friday full burberry of converse buds, www.tommyhilfiger.nl it nike mercurial becomes kanye west shoes odd p90x workout schedule good lacoste polos mood, nike outlet as michael kors australia this kate spade outlet was thomas sabo uk the louboutins most coach bags beautiful pandora rings seasons oakley outlet of louboutin spring.A coach outlet sale person, adidas neo quiet prada sunglasses time occhiali oakley alone, nfl ravens is puma lonely toms outlet pondering cheap jerseys begin oakley fingertips nike outlet store dolls, coach factory outlet online but suns jerseys also giuseppe zanotti against pistons jersey

toms shoes

marc jacobs outlet

20170505 yuanyuan的头像

marc jacobs outlet

coach outlet store

white sox jerseys

ray ban sunglasses discount

coach factory outlet online

marc jacobs

red sox jerseys

true religion uk

moncler pas cher

christian louboutin sale

polo ralph lauren

michael kors outlet store

dansko outlet

true religion outlet store

louboutin outlet

coach factory outlet online

fitflop

tigers jerseys

coach outlet online

pandora jewelry

adidas nmd r1

true religion outlet store

moncler jackets

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet store

sac louis vuitton

polo ralph lauren outlet

true religion jeans outlet

michael kors

ralph lauren outlet online

michael kors bags

ed hardy clothing

hermes bags

longchamp bag

pandora charms

yeezy boost

coach factory outlet online

michael kors outlet store

celine handbags

burberry sale

michael kors

fitflops clearance

nike free 4.0 flyknit

coach factory outlet store

michael kors outlet online

nike outlet

cheap jordan shoes

coach outlet store

polo ralph lauren outlet online

gucci

christian louboutin outlet

adidas yeezy boost

nike air force

fit flops

michael kors outlet online

versace

nike tn pas cher

coach outlet online

fred perry polo shirts

ralph lauren

louis vuitton handbags

hollister clothing store

adidas yeezy boost

coach factory outlet online

rolex replica watches

mont blanc pen

yeezy boost 350

oakley sunglasses outlet

ralph lauren outlet

red bottom heels

rolex replica watches for sale

chaussure louboutin pas cher

toms outlet store

abercrombie outlet

louis vuitton outlet online

nfl jerseys wholesale

adidas nmd r1

polo ralph lauren pas cher

thunder jerseys

michael kors outlet clearance

burberry outlet online

cheap ray ban sunglasses

rolex watches

longchamp outlet store

coach factory outlet online

michael kors outlet store

toms outlet

purs jerseys

fitflops clearance

gucci handbags outlet

longchamp bags

burberry outlet store

cheap jordan shoes

christian louboutin outlet

nike sneakers

coach outlet store online

pandora charms outlet

coach outlet online

mulberry uk

air jordan shoes

coach outlet

nike cortez classic

gucci

coach outlet online

ray ban sunglasses outlet

pandora charms

tommy hilfiger windbreaker

adidas sneakers

polo ralph lauren outlet online

coach factory outlet online

christian louboutin

pandora charms sale

warriors jerseys

coach outlet online

cheap ray ban sunglasses

nike roshe one

coach outlet online

oakley sunglasses cheap

ghd straighteners sale

longchamp pliage

mbt

ed hardy uk

air jordans

michael kors outlet store

vans store

christian louboutin shoes

discount oakley sunglasses

mulberry outlet uk

cardinals jerseys

true religion jeans outlet

michael kors bags

montblanc

birkenstocks

nike blazer low pas cher

polo ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet

coach factory outlet online

oakley sunglasses outlet

sac louis vuitton pas cher

coach factory outlet online

ralph lauren sale

rolex replica watches for sale

louis vuitton outlet online

michael kors outlet online

adidas outlet store

jordan retro

adidas superstar trainers

coach handbags outlet

nike outlet online

michael kors

adidas superstar shoes

coach outlet store online

coach outlet store online clearance

adidas running shoes

coach factory outlet online

discount oakley sunglasses

cheap jordan shoes

kd shoes

adidas yeezy boost

nike outlet store

pandora charms sale clearance

mlb jerseys

louis vuitton outlet online

coach outlet store

timberland boots outle

coach factory outlet

adidas superstars

louis vuitton outlet online

coach outlet online

christian louboutin shoes

eltics jerseys

beats headphones

longchamp bags

adidas uk

louboutin shoes

swarovski sale

longchamp bags

pandora charms outlet

ralph lauren outlet online

cheap oakley sunglasses

louis vuitton factory outlet

mont blanc pen

air max

bercrombie

fit flops

nike air huarache

lakers jerseys

broncos jerseys

true religion jeans outlet

coach outlet online

gucci outlet online

polo ralph lauren

fred perry shirts

burberry outlet

yeezy 350 boost

discount oakley sunglasses

birkenstock

adidas trainers

coach outlet store online

birkenstocks

ray ban sunglasses discount

coach purses

kate spade handbags

coach factory outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

ray ban glasses

texans jerseys

michael kors outlet online

fitflops sale

coach outlet online

ralph lauren sale

jerseys cheap

pandora charms sale clearance

ralph lauren sale

rangers jerseys

coach factory outlet online

michael kors bags

toms shoes

coach outlet store

birkenstock outlet

toms outlet

michael kors outlet store

yeezy shoes

kate spade outlet online

vans outlet

coach factory outlet online

cheap air max

michael kors outlet store

adidas

cheap oakley sunglasses

nike roshe shoes

ed hardy store

sac longchamp

nfl jerseys cheap

kate spade outlet

yeezy boost 350

nmd adidas

beats by dre

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap oakley sunglasses

adidas nmd runner

pandora charms

michael kors handbags outlet

tommy hilfiger outlet

tory burch outlet online

coach factory outlet online

adidas outlet online

james shoes

coach factory outlet online

nike outlet store

michael kors outlet online

yeezy shoes

tods shoes

fitflops sale clearance

louis vuitton purses

louboutin shoes

gucci outlet online

ghd hair

fitflops sale clearance

ralph lauren

coach factory outlet

pandora jewelry

michael kors outlet online

kate spade

polo ralph lauren outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

polo ralph lauren

air max outlet

air max

cubs jerseys

louboutin pas cher

air max 90

adidas nmd r1

michael kors

birkenstock outlet

phillies jerseys

oakley sunglasses wholesale

pandora bracelet

toms

mlb jerseys

michael kors outlet online

mulberry bags

jordan shoes

coach outlet store online

gucci bags

swarovski uk

polo ralph lauren outlet online

patriots jerseys

adidas yeezy boost

eahawks jerseys

cheap nike sneakers

coach factory outlet online

montblanc pens

michael kors outlet clearance

adidas nmd runner

ray ban sale

chaussures louboutin

kate spade bags

michael kors uk

tory burch sale

nfl jerseys

true religion jeans outlet

true religion jeans

michael kors outlet canada

adidas sneakers

ed hardy outlet

tory burch outlet online

ray ban glasses

cheap jordan shoes

michael kors outlet store

kate spade bags

mulberry uk

coach outlet online

coach outlet store

fake rolex watches

nike free run flyknit

hermes bags

michael kors handbags

jordan femmes pas cher

toms

louis vuitton outlet store

cheap oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren

christian louboutin pas cher

longchamp sale

moncler uk

dansko

coach outlet online

louis vuitton bags

kate spade outlet online

coach outlet online

cheap nike shoes

pandora outlet

adidas nmd r1

tods outlet

louis vuitton outlet store

yankees jerseys

ray ban sunglasses outlet

coach outlet online

nike air max

polo ralph lauren outlet

louboutin shoes

rockets jerseys

49ers jerseys

fitflops sale

discount oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren

red bottom

adidas sneakers

gucci handbags outlet

bulls jerseys

birkenstock shoes

nike outlet

adidas outlet online

michael kors

polo ralph lauren

toms

fitflop shoes

cheap rolex watches

louboutin outlet

louboutin outlet

adidas ultra boost

chi flat iron

nike air max 95

adidas nmd runner

christian louboutin shoes

red bottom shoes for women

gucci bags

dodgers jerseys

christian louboutin uk

discount nike shoes

yeezy boost 350

michael kors purses

nike outlet store online

michael kors outlet online

christian louboutin

ray bans

mlb jerseys

michael kors

coach outlet online

pandora jewelry outlet

coach outlet online

polo ralph lauren outlet online

oakley sunglasses on sale

mulberry handbags

pandora charms sale

ralph lauren sale clearance uk

michael kors outlet clearance

hermes outlet online

ray ban sunglasses discount

fitflops

kate spade uk

discount oakley sunglasses

cheap jordans for sale

polo ralph lauren

nike outlet store

coach factory outlet online

fit flops

fitflops sale

nike air max 95

michael kors

coach outlet canada

air jordans

polo ralph lauren outlet online

moncler uk

burberry outlet

ralph lauren outlet online

coach factory outlet

christian louboutin sale

coach outlet online

ralph lauren uk

fendi bags

adidas yeezy boost 350

michael kors outlet online

nike free run

ralph lauren outlet online

hollister kids

louis vuitton

mbt

ray ban sunglasses sale

longchamp handbags

cowboys jerseys

pandora jewelry outlet

longchamp handbags

pandora charms sale clearance

fitflops

coach factory outlet

nike store

discount oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin

jordan uk

hollister clothing

adidas superstars

birkin handbags

air max 90

yeezy boost

michael kors outlet online

dolce and gabbana outlet online

coach outlet online

wireless beats headphones

michael kors uk

valentino outlet

yeezy boost 350 v2

moncler jackets

air max

moncler outlet online

michael kors

hermes outlet

kate spade purses

pandora charms sale clearance

oakley sunglasses outlet

coach outlet online

fitflop

adidas trainers

oakley sunglasses outlet

hermes bag

levis outlet

packers jerseys

true religion

jordan shoes

michael kors outlet

nike sneakers

rolex watches

cavaliers jerseys

curry shoes

longchamp soldes

michael kors

longchamp handbags

coach factory outlet

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors outlet canada

giants jerseys

swarovski crystals

louis vuitton factory outlet

ralph lauren outlet online

christian louboutin outlet

air max 90

fred perry polo shirts

polo ralph lauren outlet

heat jerseys

celine outlet online

pandora

nike flyknit

cheap oakley sunglasses

longchamps

coach factory outlet online

mlb jerseys

yeezy shoes

jordans

coach outlet store online

ralph lauren sale

lebron shoes

christian louboutin outlet

longchamp bag

coach outlet online

jimmy choo shoes

parada bags

pandora jewelry store

polo ralph lauren outlet online

air max shoes

ray bans

kobe bryant shoes

birkenstock uk

cheap nfl jerseys

mont blanc pens

coach outlet store online

michael kors handbags clearance

true religion outlet online

adidas nmd runner

mulberry

michael kors outlet store

true religion jeans outlet

cheap air jordans

coach outlet online

cheap jordan shoes

chaussures louboutin

kate spade outlet online

cheap oakley sunglasses

adidas store

ralph lauren sale clearance uk

red bottom

cheap jerseys

ralph lauren outlet

yeezy boost

cheap rolex replica watches

sac longchamp

kate spade outlet online

kate spade outlet store

adidas outlet store

ralph lauren outlet

coach factory outlet

fitflop shoes

gucci borse

michael kors bags

harden shoes

moncler coats

nike uk

yeezy boost 350

michael kors outlet

kd 8 shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

prada outlet online

pandora charms outlet

louboutin outlet

adidas

yeezy boost

birkenstock outlet

coach outlet online

ray ban sunglasses cheap

michael kors handbags outlet

coach outlet online

beats wireless headphones

true religion sale

hzx20170509

hzx的头像

hzx20170509

oakley sunglasses cheap

 

adidas zx 700

 

coach outlet store online

 

adidas nmd

 

polo outlet

 

ugg boots outlet

 

ed hardy clothing

 

air jordan shoes

 

adidas outlet store

 

the north face outlet

 

cheap jordan shoes

 

nhl jerseys

 

polo ralph lauren shirts

 

ray bans uk

 

north face

 

pandora outlet online

 

oakley vault

 

new balance 990

 

mcm handbags

 

coach bags

 

columbia shoes men

 

pandora bracelet

 

pandora charms

 

longchamp bags

 

adidas predator

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

christian louboutin sneakers

 

michael kors outlet online

 

ralph lauren polo shirts

 

michael kors tote vanilla

 

columbia outlet

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

coach factory online

 

converse all star

 

oakley vault

 

lebron 12 shoes

 

ray ban clubmaster

 

coach outlet

 

hermes handbags

 

michael kors canada outlet

 

lebron shoes

 

coach outlet online

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

adidas neo label

 

nike store uk

 

coach outlet store online clearances

 

polo shirts

 

burberry bags

 

longchamp handbags

 

nike roshe run

 

christian louboutin sale

 

louis vuitton outlet store

 

prada bags

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

air jordan shoes

 

prada bags

 

nike air max

 

converse sneakers

 

replica rolex

 

polo ralph lauren shirts

 

michael kors handbags

 

nike store

 

cheap nhl jerseys

 

pandora jewelry

 

adidas originals superstar

 

air jordan shoes

 

converse shoes

 

air force 1 shoes

 

ralph lauren polo

 

michael kors outlet online

 

ray ban outlet

 

hermes handbags

 

coach factory outlet

 

vans store

 

pandora charms sale clearance

 

new balance shoes

 

salomon boots

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

ray ban eyeglasses

 

kobe 10 shoes

 

longchamp pas cher

 

pandora outlet

 

coach outlet store online clearances

 

vans for sale

 

fitflops shoes

 

adidas yeezy

 

coach outlet store online

 

ralph lauren shirts

 

hermes bags

 

mcm handbags

 

le coq sportif shoes

 

coach outlet store online

 

oakley outlet

 

under armour shoes

 

the north face jackets

 

christian louboutin sale

 

it's very good , i love it.

AFSSDF的头像

it's very good , i love it. by the way, 

please let me post a link.......you know that,thank you very much

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/index.html]婚紗照[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/news.html]寶寶團拍[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/about04.html]婚禮錄影[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/services01.html]婚禮攝影[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/about03.html]大碼禮服[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/services01.htm]新娘秘書[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/]婚紗包套[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/gallnew1.html]寶寶攝影[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/gallery.html]兒童寫真[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/gallnew7.html]寵物攝影[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/gallnew5.html]孕婦攝影[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/gallnew5.html]孕婦寫真[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/gallnew3.html]藝術照[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/]攝影工作室[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/gallnew4.html]全家福照[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/index.html]婚紗攝影[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/about.html]婚紗照[/url]

[url=http://www.babyface.url.tw/about02.html]結婚照[/url]

[url=http://goo.gl/QDouAv]寶寶寫真[/url]

[url=http://goo.gl/n3smkE]寶寶寫真[/url]

[url=http://goo.gl/SuPkNg]寶寶藝術照[/url]

[url=https://goo.gl/7ztzkb]全家福照[/url]

[url=http://goo.gl/o0kGUG]寶寶寫真[/url]

[url=https://goo.gl/P0DKWT]寶寶攝影[/url]

[url=http://goo.gl/b6adcf]兒童攝影[/url]

[url=https://goo.gl/uJN7Wt]兒童寫真[/url]

[url=https://goo.gl/77kaWC]全家福照[/url]

[url=https://goo.gl/7ztzkb]全家福照[/url]

[url=https://goo.gl/aCVpNN]全家福照[/url]

[url=https://goo.gl/xBrqji]全家福照[/url]

[url=https://goo.gl/rtFi77]形象照[/url]

 

 

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。
Type the characters you see in this picture. (使用语音验证)
填入上图所示的数字或者单词;如果你看不清,点击保存按钮,系统会为您重新生成您新的图片。不区分大小写。