盲点与疑点 方韩之争随感之三 -- 戴建业 2012/2/4

盲点与疑点

——方韩之争随感之三

作者:戴建业 2012/2/4

http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_740128650100xgph.html


方韩之争中最大的盲点是:韩寒所谓当一个作家被质疑抄袭或代笔的时候,作家本人根本无法自证清白;方韩之争中最大的疑点是:韩寒的代表作和成名作《三重门》及得奖作品《求医》、《书店》、《杯中窥人》,是否有人代笔及由谁代笔?我的这篇随感想要谈的基本观点是:“盲点”其实是个“亮点”,韩寒所说的这个问题是个伪命题;“疑点”也并非完全不可解开的“死结”,韩寒有很多办法解开读者心中的疑团。

历史上和现实中的抄袭之争相对容易解决,将两个版本进行比勘就大致能得出结论,在电脑上进行文字比勘比从前更加方便。当然,断定是否抄袭有时也比较复杂,比如历史上戴震与赵一清的《水经注》版本校勘之争,就让胡适先生花了近二十年时间,写了近二百万字来澄清事实。但这是个抄袭之争中的最难解的特例,通常的抄袭之争通过文字比勘就能断案。

历史上父子和朋友之间的代笔之争,大多至今没有定论,因为代笔者和被代者都已经作古,双方都是“死无对证”,如汉代班彪与班固父子《汉书》的代笔疑云,虽然有人指责班固“全无学术,专事剽窃”,从古至今便无从释疑,因为班彪既没有留下“汉书”的手稿,我们又没有办法验证班固是否真的“全无学术”。今天方舟子等人质疑的韩寒“代笔门”,比起历史上那些代笔之争要容易解决得多。方舟子等人表面是质疑韩寒十几年前的作品由人代笔,它的本质还是怀疑韩寒既没有学识,也没有才华。韩寒的青少年经历和他的青少年成就不合常理。韩寒争辩说你自己办不到的事情,没有理由怀疑别人也办不到;韩寒粉丝也认为天才本身就不合常理,符合常理就不是超常的天才。即使署名韩寒的那些早期作品是由他父亲代笔,韩寒的父亲肯定也不会站出来“大义灭亲”。这好像成了“信者恒信”而“疑者恒疑”的死结——韩寒不可能自证清白,质疑者也无从坐实质疑。

其实,韩寒本人完全可以自证。质疑者表面上是质疑他的“过去”——以常理来看,在他那个年龄,在他那种水平,写不出《书店》、《求医》、《杯中窥人》这样的文章,更写不出这样的《三重门》长篇小说,除非韩寒真是超绝凡人的天才。韩寒和九泉之下的班固不同,他可以站出来以自己的笔墨写出妙文,以自己的口舌讲出妙语,用自己的文章,用自己的机智,用自己的才华,像他曾经在自己小说后记和文章中说过的那样,明白无误的向世人展示:“我是金子”,“我是天才”。如果他真的能露几手给大家见识见识,而不是像现在这样骂人、赌咒、悬赏、告奖,所有质疑者都会闭嘴,所有围观者都会点头,所有泼在他身上的脏水都能洗刷干净,所有人们心中的疑云都将驱散。

可惜,韩寒选择“自证清白”的方法,反而越来越让人觉得他并不“清白”;他抖出那些手稿和书信的释疑,反而越来越让人生疑;他那些意气用事的回应文章,不是满嘴骂人的脏话,就是了无才气的废话;他接受电视采访的视频,反而让人看出他了无学识,他甚至荒唐到将姚文元穿越到延安整风运动。

韩寒可能没有意识到,他遇上的对手方舟子可不是个混混,他不是以体育特长生才能进入高中的学习“差生”,更不是高中一年级因七门功课不及格而退学的青年,他是一个以优异成绩考进中国科技大学的才子,一个考理科而语文成绩是福建第一的状元,是一个在美国比较好大学受过正规学术训练的理科博士,是一个头脑冷静思致严谨的“冷血动物”,更要命的他还是一个专给名人找茬的“怪种”,是一头“与人斗,其乐无穷”的“猛兽”,而不是一个听说起诉就缩手的“孬种”。

显然,韩寒低估了对手,韩寒遇到了麻烦。

悬赏解决不了问题,诅咒解决不了问题,发誓解决不了问题,“收笔”更解决不了问题,起诉尤其解决不了问题——难道一个法官说韩寒没有代笔,读者就认可韩寒没有代笔了?难道法官说韩寒是天才,人们就相信韩寒是天才了?

今天方舟子质疑韩寒“过去”的作品“代笔”,本质是看出“现在”的韩寒“不行”,只要“现在”的韩寒表现“优异卓越”,就能证明“过去”的韩寒“质地优良”。如果韩寒当众展露“现在”的才华,读者和观众自然就明白“过去”的韩寒优异,方舟子所有的质疑不攻自破,哪用得着对簿公堂?所以,韩寒只有通过“现在”的卓越才能,来证明自己“过去”的非凡才气:1、通过高水平文章与质疑者辨论;2、通过公开与质疑者进行激烈的口头交锋;3、通过与作家、学者、文学爱好者交流创作心得并一一回答听众问题。这样,是骡子是良马一目了然。

不知此时此刻的韩寒想过没有,不是他想收笔就能收笔的,下面是信海光先生看了我博客文章后的评论:“@信海光: 又出来一位重量级拳师加入韩黑阵营。作为所谓骑墙派,很想多转些方黑阵营的文章,但至今为止,还少有精彩之论,憾。”信海光先生可能有点误会,我并不是一个“韩黑阵营”的拳师,和信海光先生一样,我只是一个比较赞同质疑行为的“骑墙派”。我和信海光先生一样,遗憾至今没有见到韩寒一篇精彩的辩论文章,他辜负了我们这些读者对他的期待——不是想看到热闹,而是想看到真相。

韩寒前天在《二月零三日》博文中宣布:“我就此事,现在收笔。”正需要韩寒用自己锋利的笔与质疑者唇枪舌剑的时候,这位文学天才却宣布“现在收笔”;正需要他用嘴为自己辩护的时候,他却回避与质疑者方舟子进行公开辩论,这很容易使人觉得他是在落荒而逃。

如果他对自己的才华有底气,如果他对“人造韩寒”质疑毫不在乎,一开始就没有必要赌咒、发誓、悬赏,如果他在乎对他的质疑,而且还要诉诸法庭,那他就不应“现在收笔”。他在《看着手稿真欢乐》的博文中说,“我还是很佩服我自己的”,现在的关键是他不能只让自己佩服自己,他要用过硬的文章和机智的辩论让我们也“很佩服”他。

如果韩寒不能用精彩之笔和机智之言来证明自己,如果韩寒拒绝与读者交流创作经验,如果韩寒躲避与质疑者方舟子进行公开辩论,就会引起越来越多读者对他的质疑,他越想“收笔”,他越是躲避,读者可能会越觉得他是个“水货”。现在正是韩寒用能力证明自己的时候。

除了用笔自证清白外,韩寒还应用口自证清白。他应该勇敢地与方舟子对质辩论,在唇枪舌剑中观众和听众会作出自己的判断。每一个在大学教书的教师,每一个从事学术研究的学者,每一个从事文学创作的作家,与一个同行面对面一交流,与一个对手当面进行辩论,马上就能让人看出他是天才还是蠢材,当面讨论没有办法作假,而且没有办法准备,只需要硬碰硬的才华,只需要硬碰硬的学识,哪怕你不善言谈也很容易见出真假与高低,历史上和现实中我们有很多结结巴巴的文学天才和学术牛人。只要你真的很“牛”,不会讲话照样“牛气”冲天。

学术交流,大会发言,学术演讲,都要留一点时间与听从交流,回答听众的质询和提问。高水平的提问,高水平的回答,都能代表一个人的专业水平。没有水平的人提问很臭,没有水平的人回答更臭。质疑者方舟子多次声称与韩寒进行电视公开辩论,这等于向韩寒下了战书,而韩寒至今没有接招。在电视上公开进行辩论,到底谁是好汉谁是孬种,亿万观众都会心中有数。韩寒回避与方舟子进行公开辩论,等于放弃了他“自证”才华的大好机会。

除了与方舟子公开辩论以自证才华外,他还可以通过与读者开座谈会为自己洗清别人泼在他身上的脏水。作家通常都喜欢谈自己的创作经验,讲起自己创作的人物形象总是眉飞色舞,讲起自己的优美诗句总是唾沫四溅,杜甫称“新诗改罢自长吟”,当代诗人臧克家有不可一本《甘苦寸心知》的书,专门讲自己几十年前创作某某诗的经过和心境。俄国、英国、法国那些小说家讲起自己如何塑造人物形象,比谈论自己的情人还要来劲。作家对自己得意的作品终生难忘,就像每一个人对自己的初恋终生难忘一样。可“天才韩寒”是所有作家中的“另类”,他几次说忘记了《三重门》书名的由来,而《三重门》是他的成名作和代表作。一个青年作家忘记了自己成名作书名是如何来的,这在古今中外大概非常少见,至少对常人来说难以想象。同时,他还经常回避谈论自己的创作过程和创作经验,这对常人来说也很难想象,当然对于天才可能就另当别论了。

韩寒可以洗刷名声的方法很多,可以自证清白的手段很多,可惜,他只选择了谩骂、赌咒、悬赏和起诉。让“盲点”最后变成了他自己身上的“污点”,让“疑点”最后成了别人心头的“死结”。

韩寒,你自己一个大活人都不能证明自己的“现在”,你那一堆死手稿还能证明你自己的“过去”吗?

分类: 

参与评分: 

还没有评价

评论

Air Max 90 femme Nike Air Max

Get the best collections

Darlene Goodwin的头像

Get the best collections regarding Yeezy Boost 550 boot to your young daughter. At this irritated grow older she is at risk of bacterial contamination, and so shield her gentle ft from your problems of climatic conditions along with disorders. Shoes and boots really should be consequently chosen Adidas Yeezy 750 Boost how they need to assist the girl the objective of protection and also at one time highlight Adidas Yeezy Boost the particular innocence of the woman's era. Populate the girl private boot display using exceptionally lovely and comfy shoes or boots. You http://www.yeezyboost750shoes950.com/ will discover shoes or boots for each sort of instances, so maintain a series to match your objective.They need to display trendy sneakers which go Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 zebra great together with the occasion, year and naturally the dress they will put on. Choose Yeezy 750 Boost brands that layout footwear by keeping in mind this anatomy connected with kid ladies foot. The printed solutions Adidas Yeezy Boost always work so that you can form the actual standing good posture inside the adolescence on the woman baby. With a correct shoe collection it is possible to ensure your child gets the help to face appropriately. The reason Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 why cease your current small angel from playing on smaller messes during the boisterous season? Why end these individuals by basking in sunlight through Yeezy 350 v2 the summer months? Exactly why stop these individuals through hanging out along with tinkering with snowballs in the chilly winter? Could it Yeezy Boost 350 v2 cream be since their sneakers are not able to guard these via these kinds of actions? Next get rid of absent all those makes. Pull in Adidas Yeezy Boost 550 stylish brands designed to use synthetic leather engineering in a way Yeezy Boost 350 v2 kids so that they can become the perfect gal kid's friend from your really sore age group.During summer time or perhaps damp year you need to choose Adidas Yeezy 350 Boost dried up match footwear for the girl young child. This can hold your ex feet Yeezy Boost 350 v2 white coming from getting tacky. The information presented found in choices such that that they speedily soaks up the wetness or maybe drinking water and helps prevent creating a thin coating among the woman skin as well as the Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 white sneaker, that may perform like a epoxy to make your youngster hate the very idea of putting on footwear.Relaxed fashion is Adidas Yeezy Boost 750 extremely happening using todays technology. Why would this specific design possibly Yeezy Boost 950 be limited to young people? Bring it household for the small woman. Perhaps the woman would need to appear and feel relaxed. The casual look and style Yeezy Boost 350 v2 black might be maintained perfectly by simply the girl and also out of this era she had produce an awareness with regards to sneakers picks.Always look into the examiner with the shoes or boots Yeezy Boost 750 that you purchase for her, they ought http://www.yeezyboost350v2zebras.com/ to be mild making sure that she could pick up the woman's legs having energy source. A leather top is nice because it's stronger in addition to allows the scope connected with style. Most of Yeezy 350 Boost us look for a rounded design and style being used for your portion masking her foot. Yeezy Boost 350 v2 zebra Certainly it looks great in it however these days a lot more designs just like entrance open up styles usually are approaching. So you may make use of them as well. For the babies Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 cream please don't accept certainly not the very best.

Vans Outlet Store Pandora

Pandora Jewelry Christian

true religion jeans

chenyingying的头像

true religion jeans

light up shoes

nike trainers

hermes bags

north face outlet

pandora charms

coach handbags

moncler jacka

oakley sunglasses

uggs

michael kors

canada goose uk

canada goose outlet

jordan shoes

jordan shoes

jordan 3

jordan 5

ugg outlet

wholesale snapback hats

fitflops

coach factory outlet

van cleef & arpels jewelry

polo ralph lauren

nike air max

ralph lauren outlet

mlb jerseys

moncler jackets

jordan shoes

longchamp

ralph lauren

michael kors

michael kors outlet online

dolce and gabbana

canada goose outlet

longchamp outlet

nike blazer

nike mercurial

moncler

christian louboutin

nike air max 2018

flip flops

ugg outlet store

kate spade outlet

nike huarache shoes

oakley sunglasses

mishka clothing

nike lunarglide

nfl jerseys

hermes belt

prada outlet

ralph lauren

wedding shoes

christian louboutin

cheap ray ban sunglasses

coach factory outlet

the north face

nike air max

marc jacobs

converse outlet

nike air max 97

nike air max 270

air jordan

miu miu handbags

red bottom shoes

adidas football boots

nike sb

cheap jerseys

ralph lauren outlet

polo ralph

coach outlet

soccer jerseys

goedkope uggs

kate spade handbags

ugg boots

bvlgari jewelry

nike air max 95

ralph lauren

burberry scarves

nike air max

herve leger dresses

ugg boots

barcelona jersey

ray ban

canada goose outlet

vibram fivefingers

ugg outlet

louboutin

jordan 8

ray ban sunglasses

rolex watches

replica watches

ugg

michael kors outlet

dansko

moncler

jordan 1

flops

nike air

mlb jerseys

coach outlet online

chenyingying20180313

Ralph Lauren Outlet

ray ban sunglasses

访客的头像

ray ban sunglasses

kate spade outlet store

tory burch shoes

polo outlet

pandora charms

mcm bags

polo ralph lauren

ralph lauren polo shirts

cheap jordan shoes

ed hardy

fred perry polo shirts

coach outlet

oakley sunglasses

fred perry shirts

canada goose outlet

pandora charms sale clearance

pandora charms outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach factory outlet

canada goose outlet store

polo outlet

ugg boots

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

kate spade outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet online

pandora outlet

nfl jerseys wholesale

prada outlet

michael kors outlet

pandora charms sale clearance

ugg outlet

true religion outlet

kate spade outlet online

canada goose outlet store

puma shoes

moncler sale

michael kors handbags

ugg boots clearance

yeezy boost

ugg boots on sale

nike shoes

true religion jeans

mont blanc outlet

christian louboutin shoes

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren

mcm outlet

oakley sunglasses

mulberry handbags

longchamp handbags

ugg outlet

ugg,uggs,uggs canada

pandora charms

ralph lauren outlet

kate spade handbags

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet online

tory burch outlet online

christian louboutin shoes

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

pandora outlet

gucci outlet

hermes belts outlet

air jordan retro

canada goose outlet online

valentino outlet store

louboutin shoes

pandora jewelry outlet

ray ban outlet

cheap nfl jerseys

canada goose outlet

canada goose

coach outlet

michael kors outlet online

michael kors outlet

coach factory outlet

pandora outlet

supreme outlet

cheap ugg boots

michael kors outlet clearance

coach outlet

nike outlet online

kate spade bags

coach outlet

pandora charms sale clearance

ugg boots

canada goose outlet store

rolex replica

gucci outlet online

polo outlet

polo ralph lauren

nike air jordan 4

pandora bracelet

michael kors outlet

ferragamo shoes sale

coach outlet

pandora jewelry

ray ban

ray ban sunglasses

pandora jewelry

cheap nhl jerseys

pandora jewelry

supreme clothing

canada goose jackets

true religion outlet

michael kors outlet

ralph lauren outlet

pandora charms sale clearance

pandora jewelry

prada outlet store

adidas superstar shoes

polo ralph lauren outlet

kate spade outlet

fitflops outlet

christian louboutin outlet

coach factory outlet

fred perry polo shirts

michael kors outlet clearance

pandora jewelry outlet

ray ban outlet

ray ban sunglasses outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet online

coach outlet

fitflops sandals

polo ralph lauren

ralph lauren uk

mlb jerseys

ray ban outlet

coach outlet

pandora jewelry

longchamp outlet online

michael kors outlet online

coach factory outlet

mbt shoes

christian louboutin outlet

kate spade outlet store

asics outlet

ed hardy clothing

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

nfl jerseys

coach outlet online

coach outlet online

lunette ray ban

oakley sunglasses

coach factory outlet

uggs outlet

cheap nfl jerseys

air max 2017

giuseppe zanotti outlet

ralph lauren outlet

air jordan 4 retro

polo ralph lauren outlet

kate spade outlet store

michael kors outlet

pandora jewelry

canada goose outlet

mont blanc

coach factory outlet

nike outlet store

coach outlet online

coach outlet

polo ralph lauren

canada goose outlet

cheap jordans for sale

cheap ugg boots

mont blanc pens

pandora jewelry

michael kors outlet online

true religion outlet store

kate spade outlet online

coach outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

ugg canada

adidas yeezy shoes

pandora outlet

pandora charms

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet

true religion jeans

canada goose outlet store

lacoste shirts

gucci outlet store

oakley sunglasses wholesale

christian louboutin shoes

louboutin outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

adidas outlet online

yeezy boost 350

canada goose outlet

ralph lauren outlet

mbt outlet

kate spade outlet store

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet clearance

kate spade outlet

pandora outlet

yaoxuemei20180423

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。