丧失了真相,就丧失了自由 -- 许锡良 2012/2/19

丧失了真相,就丧失了自由

作者: 许锡良 2012/2/19

http://blog.ifeng.com/article/16387498.html


1、一切社会的罪恶皆因为掩盖真相而产生。就人的天然良知来说,如果面对真相,他们会有一个基本的人性的判断,不至于太荒唐,太无耻。但是,在真相被掩盖的时候,则情况常常会大不相同。当年“红太阳的升起”,是因为太多的真相被掩盖了,因此,无限崇拜的狂热才得以在中华大地上肆虐漫延。赫鲁晓夫揭露了斯大林的真相之后,这个偶像在苏联就倒塌了。不需要什么定性,大家面对那些血淋淋的恐怖事实,自然会得到相应的结论。真相一出,不打自倒。中国的“红太阳”至今仍然有很多人崇拜在他脚下,活在他的幽灵里,其实仍然是因为不知道真相。

2、民主法治的制度与自由的社会,都是以追求真相为前提的,保证真相大白于天下的制度就是民主法治的制度,保证追求真相不被阻挠的社会,就是自由社会。追求自由不可能用假相来达到。因为真相与自由,手段与目的必须是合一的。权力造假的目的常常是为了专制,还政于民,天下为公,则不必造假,只需要诚实,而且必须诚实,才可以有尊严地活下去。

3、韩寒这个事件要不要有真相?能不能够质疑与批评?这是毫无疑问的。不能够因为有人在利用公权造假,就可以宽容非公权的公众人物造假。

4、在中国,“文革”时非常流行的做法,就是目的是一切,手段可以不择。为了革命的崇高理想,可以不拘小节,因此撒谎,欺骗,枉杀无枉,都可以视为革命动机高尚,而给予原谅。

5、这种思维至今却悄然转移到了这样的方式:只要你谈民主自由,只要你敢骂社会腐败,那么,你就是社会崇拜的偶像,而偶像的真假却可以不闻问。

6、著名作家、社会时评家陈行之先生在韩寒涉嫌“人造”时,认同一个叫“三风”的短文(《我宁可要一万个代笔的韩寒,也不要1个僵尸派》)这样评论道:“我宁可要一万个代笔的韩寒,也不要1个僵尸派。我宁可要一万个代笔的胡适和韩寒,我也不要一个垃圾5毛党或者僵尸派,前者不管几个人写,那也都是人性和良知,不管有几个笔名那也是为民为国在呐喊;而那帮无耻的5毛和僵尸派,就算它们牌坊立的再高,装的再纯洁,也是连妓女都不如的胆小乞骨的奴才而已。”

7、这段话暴露了一个很可怕的问题:一上来就给他喜欢的韩寒与不喜欢的人都贴了标签。然后还不经胡适先生同意,就把胡适与韩寒捆绑在一起。如果胡适先生当年都是包装出来的,都是靠人代笔写文章,著书立说,那么,今天胡适还值得人们纪念吗?后人还会那样把胡适作为开一代风气的宗师来尊敬他吗?你可以批评胡适当年的文章写得可能深度不够,但是,没有人质疑胡适是假的新文化先驱者,他的文章竟然是别人代笔的。胡适先生也是主张大胆质疑的,他曾经提倡美国实用主义的思想方法,即“大胆地假设,小心地求证”。并且把这种思维方式看成改造中国人治学方式的有效方法。

即使一万个代笔的韩寒,也可以接受,而且也值得赞美。殊不知,如果是代笔的韩寒,那么,就不存在什么作家的韩寒、公知的韩寒了,因为他只是一个稻草人韩寒而已,一个社会假如可以允许这样公然造假,只要自己喜欢,就是假的也可以。那么,韩寒们为什么又要极力为自己辩护?这说明即使在代笔韩寒那里,这个假的也是难以认同的。因为一旦承认代笔,偶像与神话就结束了。而人们追求的真相其实也就是这个而已。

8、如果一个人打着良知、真话的旗号,就可以公然以造假的方式树立起一个公知、作家的形象,然后牟取暴利,那么,当年喊着“共产主义”美好口号,剥夺别人的私人财产,甚至要革资产阶级的命为什么就不可以?相对于那些赤裸着的丑恶,用“良知”与“真话”包装起来的虚假公正与正义更为令人不齿。因为,前者毕竟长久不了,人们不会喜欢公然的丑恶,但是,人们常常会被包装的丑陋蒙骗。如果,今天允许用代笔的方式制造出假公知、假作家、假天才,那么,明天为什么不同可以用同样的方法制造假繁荣、假强大、假美好?代笔的韩寒可以,当年“大跃进”时的亩产三十万斤的卫星为什么就不可以放?那也不过是把其他粮田的粮食用“代笔”的方式移植到这一亩田里而已啊。但是,那样做的后果我们其实已经看到了,饿死数千万人。今天韩寒代笔嫌疑,也许不会产生如此恶劣的后果,但是,对一个社会的思想文化市场的破坏,对教育的错误引导,对社会诚信的破坏,以及形成的恶性竞争却是不可低估的。利用欺骗的手法制造神童、天才与青春偶像,激发起人们的崇拜狂热,然后趁机牟取暴利,这样的事情如果公然允许,那么,这个社会其他的假就为什么不能够允许?贪污受贿、骄奢淫逸的腐败生活,也不过是一种通过掩人耳目的伎俩而得以实现的。贪污受贿不也只是要通过造假而得逞的?

9、对于一个民族文化来说,求真是一切文化建设的基础。因为一切的制度建设,一切理想追求,都不能够将梦想建立在虚假的基础上。如果一个民族没有求真的能力,那么,就不要指望这个民族会有什么健全的制度,也不要指望这个民族能够真正消除大灾大难。真,是善与美的基础。求真也是一种能力,是一种精神。西方的哲学,追求真相的智慧是其核心智慧。为了求真,西方圣哲在怎样才会有有效思维方面,撰写了无数的专著。比如,亚里斯多德写有《工具论》、培根有《新工具》、洛克有《人类理解论》、莱布尼茨有《人类理智新论》、笛卡尔有《探求真理的指导原则》与《谈谈方法》、彭加勒有《科学与方法》、《科学与假设》、波普尔的《猜想与反驳》等等,最终形成了一门专门探求怎样求得真相与真知识的学问——科学哲学。相比而言,中国的文化与教育,在这些方面几乎就是空白。自己严重不足,却又不虚心学习。

陈行之先生这样夸奖有代笔嫌疑的韩寒:“有本事像韩寒那样骂贪官去,你们敢么?有本事像韩寒那样骂社会问题去,你们敢么?有本事像韩寒那样实实在在的讨论三篇革命民主自由去,你们敢么?有本事为几千万被活活饿死的生活在最底层的农民发帖呐喊去,你们敢么?”说实在的在中国骂贪官污吏的人还会少吗?谈社会问题的也会少吗?那又有什么用呢?如果贪官污吏靠骂就可以解决,社会问题靠骂就可以解决,那么,骂岂不成为了社会治理的灵丹妙药?那么政治学、法学、社会学、经济学与教育学这些学问岂不是也是多余的?事实上,中国的贪官污吏多,社会问题层出不穷,制度难以变革,在风调雨顺的年月公然饿死数千万人,靠的正是欺骗大众。求真的勇气,比单纯的骂的勇气更为难能可贵。骂有时候,还可以小骂大帮忙,就像那年前韩寒的疑作“韩三篇”那样。而且骂根本就不能够解决问题。骂,是无论任何一个没有文化的泼妇就可以做到的,但是,求真却要有过硬的科学素养,要懂得逻辑推理方法,要学会寻找证据并且用证据证明,要善于透过假相去寻找真相。这必须有严格的学术训练与思维训练、拥有真正的科学精神才有可能的。

10、对于中国的教育与学术界来说,韩寒事件是一件非常大的公共事件。这意味着要去重新探究中国的教育问题究竟出在哪里?真话是否可以用假相来包装?还有中国的学术诚信问题必须提到日程上来。这后面的蕴藏的社会意义是非常大的。在没有获得真相,没有得到当事人站出来解释清楚那些公众疑问,以及用实力证明自己的公知学识与见识和作家水平之前,那个质疑是不能停止的。

11、的确,中国还有很多公共事件没有获得真相大白,比如与此同时发生的重庆王立军事件,至今也仍然是“雾都茫茫”,但是,这并不是构成放弃追问韩寒代笔嫌疑真相的理由,他们只是分别处于不同的领域而已,不存在谁轻谁重的问题,更不是韩寒事件就可以没有真相的理由。那种因为喜欢假相韩寒,就可以允许他可以有人捉刀代笔,甚至一万个代笔韩寒也没有关系的看法是完全不能够接受的。因为真相与自由并不对立,恰恰相反,追求真相的过程,就是追求自由的过程。哪里没有真相,哪里的自由人权就遭受到践踏,即使是呐喊自由人权的人,也必须是一个真实的人。中国社会不要偶像,但是不能够没有了真相。

2012年2月19日星期日

分类: 

参与评分: 

还没有评价

评论

miami dolphins jerseys

zzzzz的头像

miami dolphins jerseys

 

nike trainers

 

nike soccer shoes

 

true religion outlet

 

ed hardy uk

 

san antonio spurs

 

michael kors outlet

 

boston celtics jersey

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

browns jerseys

 

tods outlet

 

cheap nhl jerseys

 

nike tn pas cher

 

hermes belt

 

moncler jackets

 

polo ralph lauren

 

philadelphia eagles jerseys

 

true religion jeans

 

washington redskins jerseys

 

nike shoes

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

canada goose

 

cheap nfl jerseys

 

falcons jersey

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

coach outlet

 

new york jets jerseys

 

bengals jersey

 

coach factory outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

vikings jerseys

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

packers jerseys

 

nike tn

 

oakley sunglasses

 

tennessee titans jersey

 

michael kors handbags

 

arizona cardinals jerseys

 

nike outlet

 

eagles jerseys

 

ecco sandals

 

carolina jerseys

 

nike store

 

jets jersey

 

patriots jerseys

 

adidas yeezy

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

coach outlet

 

michael kors handbags

 

broncos jerseys

 

detroit lions jerseys

 

green bay packers jerseys

 

seahawks jersey

 

ray ban sunglasses outlet

 

cheap nike shoes

 

cheap ray bans

 

kate spade handbags

 

red bottom shoes

 

texans jerseys

 

michael kors handbags sale

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

oakley sunglasses

 

fitflops sale

 

nike outlet

 

cheap ray bans

 

pandora outlet

 

air max 90

 

louboutin shoes

 

true religion outlet

 

new england patriots jerseys

 

nike outlet

 

nba jerseys

 

nike outlet

 

san diego chargers jerseys

 

nike trainers

 

clippers jersey for sale

 

nike shoes

 

atlanta falcons jerseys

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

hugo boss outlet

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

ralph lauren polo

 

converse shoes

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

true religion outlet store

 

moncler outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

cowboys jerseys

 

coach outlet online

 

fitflops shoes

 

nike air huarache

 

new york giants jerseys

 

oakley sunglasses

 

polo ralph lauren

 

denver broncos jerseys

 

tods shoes

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

nike shoes

 

michael kors handbags

 

cheap basketball shoes

 

coach outlet

 

nike roshe

 

nike shoes

 

coach outlet store online

 

coach factory outlet

 

tory burch outlet

 

coach outlet

 

clippers jersey

 

coach outlet online

 

bottega veneta

 

cheap nba jerseys

 

nike huarache

 

ray ban sunglasses outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses outlet

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet online

 

oklahoma city thunder

 

prada outlet

 

air jordan 8

 

lacoste polo

 

coach outlet

 

ed hardy clothing

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

yeezy shoes

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

air jordan 4

 

nike outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

golden state warriors jerseys

 

mbt shoes

 

oakley sunglasses

 

nike blazer

 

coach outlet online

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

ralph lauren uk

 

reebok outlet

 

cheap jordan shoes

 

mlb jerseys

 

ecco shoes

 

michael kors outlet

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

cheap jordans

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

superdry clothing

 

mbt shoes outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

jordan 8

 

air jordan uk

 

cleveland cavaliers

 

bills jerseys

 

canada goose sale

 

nike air max 90

 

louboutin shoes

 

coach outlet

 

michael kors uk

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

true religion outlet store

 

nike factory store

 

ferragamo outlet

 

michael kors handbags

 

new orleans saints jerseys

 

christian louboutin uk

 

cincinnati bengals jerseys

 

jimmy choo outlet

 

cheap jordans

 

steelers jerseys

 

coach handbags

 

chargers jerseys

 

san antonio spurs jerseys

 

cheap jordan shoes

 

nike air jordan

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

basketball shoes

 

coach outlet

 

nike factory outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

mulberry handbags

 

seattle seahawks jerseys

 

new york knicks

 

boston celtics

 

polo ralph lauren

 

coach factory outlet

 

nike huarache

 

canada goose jackets

 

chicago bulls jersey

 

jordan shoes

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

jordan 4

 

jimmy choo shoes

 

golden state warriors

 

jordan shoes

 

oklahoma city thunder jerseys

 

cheap mlb jerseys

 

oakley sunglasses

 

coach outlet

 

nike outlet store

 

cardinals jersey

 

carolina panthers jersey

 

fitflops

 

kate spade sale

 

oakland raiders jerseys

 

los angeles lakers

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

hugo boss sale

 

nike air huarache

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

polo ralph lauren

 

coach outlet

 

jordan shoes

 

dolphins jerseys

 

nike trainers

 

ray ban sunglasses outlet

 

coach factory outlet

 

49ers jersey

 

lions jerseys

 

kate spade outlet

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

cheap ray bans

 

michael kors uk

 

nhl jerseys

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

coach outlet store online

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

coach outlet

 

true religion outlet

 

los angeles lakers jerseys

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

polo ralph lauren

 

polo ralph lauren

 

true religion jeans

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

colts jerseys

 

soccer shoes

 

jacksonville jaguars jersey

 

coach outlet

 

minnesota vikings jerseys

 

kate spade outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

polo ralph lauren

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

san francisco 49ers jerseys

 

baltimore ravens jerseys

 

nike huarache

 

chiefs jersey

 

ravens jerseys

 

canada goose outlet

 

nike air huarache

 

longchamp handbags

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

cleveland browns jerseys

 

nike blazer pas cher

 

chicago bears jerseys

 

coach outlet

 

christian louboutin sale

 

nike outlet

 

giuseppe zanotti outlet

 

oakley sunglasses

 

snapbacks wholesale

 

houston texans jerseys

 

polo ralph lauren

 

adidas superstar

 

cleveland cavaliers jerseys

 

air huarache

 

ray ban sunglasses outlet

 

nike roshe run

 

bears jerseys

 

michael kors outlet

 

coach outlet

 

supreme clothing

 

nike huarache

 

kansas city chiefs jerseys

 

supreme clothing

 

miami heat jersey

 

dallas cowboys jerseys

 

kate spade outlet

 

cheap ray bans

 

true religion jeans

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

reebok shoes

 

salomon boots

 

kate spade sale

 

asics shoes

 

indianapolis colts jerseys

 

valentino shoes

 

chicago bulls

 

jordan shoes

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

jaguars jersey

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

louboutin shoes

 

converse trainers

 

nike factory outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

fitflops sale

 

raiders jerseys

 

nike outlet store

 

skechers outlet

 

new york knicks jersey

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

cheap snapbacks

 

redskins jerseys

 

longchamp outlet

 

coach factory outlet

 

nike shoes

 

coach outlet online

 

saints jerseys

 

nfl jerseys wholesale

 

ferragamo shoes

 

oakley sunglasses

 

miami heat

 

hermes belts

 

cheap ray bans

 

buffalo bills jerseys

 

titans jersey

 

supreme clothing

 

oakley sunglasses

 

prada shoes

 

skechers shoes

 

pittsburgh steelers jersey

 

red bottom shoes

 

salomon shoes

 

cheap ray bans

 

true religion outlet

 

discount oakley sunglasses

 

giants jersey

 

chrome hearts

 

kate spade outlet

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

polo ralph lauren

 

coach outlet

 

nike trainers shoes

zzzzz

cheap mlb jerseys

访客的头像

cheap mlb jerseys

nfl jerseys

giuseppe zanotti sneakers

coach outlet online

polo ralph lauren

coach factory outlet

canada goose jackets

adidas yeezy shoes

moncler outlet

canada goose jackets

polo outlet

michael kors outlet online

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet store

pandora charms sale clearance

uggs outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

mont blanc pens

kate spade

polo outlet

ralph lauren outlet

kate spade handbags

coach factory outlet

pandora charms outlet

coach outlet store online

coach outlet online

coach outlet

coach outlet store online

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

pandora jewelry

michael kors outlet online

pandora charms sale clearance

vintage nhl jerseys

true religion jeans

moncler outlet

coach factory outlet

pandora charms

nike outlet

adidas yeezy shoes

nike factory outlet

canada goose jackets

pandora jewelry

cheap nfl jerseys

pandora outlet

michael kors

coach outlet

canada goose

uggs outlet

michael kors uk

ugg outlet

pandora

canada goose outlet online

michael kors outlet clearance

coach outlet

adidas outlet

yeezy boost 350

polo ralph lauren shirts

pandora jewelry

puma outlet

birkenstock sandals

longchamp handbags

uggs outlet

supreme hoodie

ralph lauren outlet

polo shirts men

mulberry handbags

true religion outlet

cheap mlb jerseys

kate spade outlet

rolex replica

ralph lauren outlet

mbt shoes

kate spade outlet

nike shoes

ralph lauren sale

coach factory outlet

ugg boots

coach outlet store online

christian louboutin shoes

fitflops sale clearance

polo ralph lauren

michael kors handbags

coach outlet online

coach outlet store online

canada goose outlet

true religion outlet

nfl jerseys

canada goose

true religion outlet online

mlb jerseys wholesale

canada goose

coach outlet store online

ralph lauren polo

christian louboutin

canada goose uk

michael kors outlet clearance

pandora bracelet

fred perry outlet

christian louboutin outlet

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet

uggs outlet

polo shirts

pandora jewelry

michael kors outlet

ed hardy outlet

ray ban wayfarer

prada outlet online

canada goose jackets

coach outlet

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet online

polo outlet

polo ralph lauren

michael kors outlet online

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

polo ralph lauren

christian louboutin uk

fitflops sale clearance

canada goose jackets

michael kors outlet

gucci outlet online

christian louboutin

ugg outlet

fred perry clothing

rolex watches

clarks shoes

coach factory outlet

christian louboutin outlet

air jordan shoes

ray ban sunglasses outlet

ugg boots clearance

true religion outlet

pandora charms

polo ralph lauren

pandora charms outlet

canada goose outlet

pandora outlet

canada goose outlet store

coach factory outlet

moncler coats

ralph lauren

adidas nmd r2

cheap snapbacks

pandora rings

michael kors outlet online

oakley sunglasses

canada goose outlet store

pandora outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

kate spade bags

true religion jeans

michael kors outlet

cheap jerseys wholesale

canada goose outlet store

nike outlet

ray ban sunglasse

louis vuitton handbags

ray ban pas cher

uggs outlet

canada goose outlet

uggs canada

yeezy boost

oakley sunglasses wholesale

ralph lauren

michael kors handbags

pandora charms

yeezy boost 350

coach outlet store online

christian louboutin outlet

ralph lauren uk

mbt shoes

canada goose jackets

polo ralph lauren

michael kors outlet store

coach factory outlet

hermes outlet

pandora jewelry

adidas outlet online

cheap oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet store

nfl jerseys wholesale

michael kors outlet clearance

coach outlet online

pandora outlet

polo outlet

longchamp outlet

canada goose jackets

mcm bag

canada goose outlet store

lebron shoes

coach outlet online store

yaoxuemei20180423

true religion jeans

shenyuhang的头像

true religion jeans

ralph lauren shirts

ralph lauren shirts

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

canada goose jackets

canada goose uk

nfl jerseys wholesale

nike shoes

ray ban sunglasses outlet

true religion

moncler outlet online

ugg boots

uggs outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

ugg outlet

ralph lauren outlet

ralph lauren uk

adidas outlet store

pandora jewelry

uggs outlet

adidas yeezy shoes

pandora jewelry

polo outlet

pandora charms

pandora jewelry outlet

polo ralph lauren

canada goose jackets

canada goose outlet

canada goose outlet online

coach outlet

pandora charms

polo ralph lauren outlet

ray ban outlet

coach outlet online

ultra boost

lacoste polo

oakley sunglasses

pandora charms

canada goose outlet

kate spade outlet

giuseppe zanotti outlet

fitflops sale

ugg outlet store

christian louboutin shoes

louboutin shoes

coach outlet

ray ban sunglasse

nike trainers

michael kors outlet clearance

pandora charms outlet

polo ralph lauren

michael kors outlet online

polo ralph lauren sale

michael kors outlet online

canada goose

michael kors outlet clearance

true religion outlet store

cheap jordans

giuseppe zanotti sneakers

pandora outlet

pandora charms sale clearance

yeezy boost

air max 90

michael kors outlet clearance

coach outlet

coach outlet

michael kors handbags

canada goose

canada goose outlet

pandora charms

polo ralph lauren

canada goose jackets

nike outlet

prada outlet online

canada goose jackets

coach outlet store online

mulberry bags

kate spade outlet

prada outlet store

coach factory outlet

ugg boots

canada goose

coach outlet online

mont blanc

mcm handbags

oakley sunglasses wholesale

cheap nike shoes

hermes outlet

mulberry handbags

ralph lauren

pandora jewelry

birkenstock outlet

michael kors outlet

coach outlet

adidas outlet online

fred perry

pandora charms sale clearance

kate spade handbags

michael kors outlet online

puma outlet

shenyuhang20180502

cialis without a doctor

Kepancak的头像

cialis without a doctor prescription preis cialis 25mg cialis tablets australia cialis et avc cialis cialis prices effet cialis homme
mexico cialis over the counter cialis 30 day sample best results cialis use vendita cialis naturale we recommend bio cialis herbal cialis generic
buy cialis in denver calais cost levitra cialis cialis prezzo di mercato comprar female cialis 100
cialis synonyms calais vente cialis 100mg cialis buy cheap view more cialis deutschland ohne rezept Cialis Online
how safe is cialis online here i found it comprar cialis online net visit our site sales cialis foro compra cialis online
http://kaivanrosendaal.com/

Sildenafil 100mg cialis

LolseCon的头像

Sildenafil 100mg cialis super activ cialis without a doctor prescription cialis yahoo compra de cialis generica click now buy generic cialis
cialis generico argentina cialis canada price of cialis in dubai wow look it cialis equivalent cialis shops in singapore Buy Sildenafil 50 mg
we use it cheep cialis uk tadalafil generic cheap cialis on line in uk pr precio caja cialis 100mg cialis ordonnance ou non
prix officiel cialis pharmacie online pharmacy cialis i where get cialis canadian drugstore cialis generika cialis cavert Buy Sildenafil 20 mg
1 cialis 50 cialis 20mg prix en pharmacie us pharmacy cialis cialis comprar barato cialis ordonnance ou non
click now phizer cialis cialis online sales i where get cialis buy cialis online aramex cialis e farmaci simil
http://asianteaarts.com

Buy Sildenafil 50 mg cialis

LolseCon的头像

Buy Sildenafil 50 mg cialis buy in uk online cialis cialis und alkohol cheap generic cialis sales uk we recommend bio cialis herbal
similar to cialis example here cheapest pfizer brand cialis buy cialis online women amazon cialis Buy Sildenafil 20 mg
obtaining cialis online cialis 30 day sample cialis 50 forum cialis efficacy the best place cialis buy now
wow buy generic cialis cialis canada cost of cialis australia cialis funciona verdad generic cialis buy pharma Sildenafil Citrate 100mg
where can i buy cialis boots cialis for daily use cialis e paroxetin cialis compra onlin cialis et ses mefaits
cialis costs in mexico as an example just try cialis cialis online cialis us sales original cialis
http://asianteaarts.com

cialis without prescription

Yrheocak的头像

cialis without prescription comprar cialis navarr 5 mg cialis pharmacie en ligne
deutschland cialis online cialis 5 effetti collaterali
brand cialis generic cialis tadalafil online Cialis Online
cialis 5 mg schweiz venta cialis en espaa
generic cialis 20mg uk cialis venta a domicilio cialis without a doctor's prescription
only now cialis for sale in us we like it cialis soft gel
canadian drugs generic cialis cialis soft tabs for sale
http://shandatea.com/

Sildenafil Citrate buy cialis

rewancak的头像

Sildenafil Citrate buy cialis vegas cialis online pharmacy how do you buy cialis buy sublingual cialis acheter vrai cialis en ligne
link for you us made cialis cialis for daily use get best results cialis cialis fedex overnight wow look it mexico cialis Buy Sildenafil Citrate 100mg
black ant cialis australia resources cialis 88 keys lyrics kamagra cialis jelly uk cialis use tips
online chemist cialis cialis sale coupon code for generic cialis cialis en belgique dove comprare cialis o cialis Sildenafil 100mg
achat de cialis pri cialis 20mg price at cvs 50mg cialis paypal uk cialis en lnea suisse order cheap cialis deals
http://chinateacraft.com

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。