公平正义的道路很遥远 ---- 作者:欧阳贝丹

——关于肖鹰教授《贺卫方与方舟子定律》的文章,及贺卫方教授的微博和回应谈一点看法,以此向各位求教

2012-04-16 13:24:30 肖鹰教授在凤凰网发出《贺卫方与方舟子定律》一文。肖鹰教授的文章中提到了@贺卫方 三次或明或隐的谈韩寒:

第一次:“@贺卫方: 心理医生不必看,只听公知老鹤言:苦不苦,想想富士康里打工族;冤不冤,看看舟子如何攻韩寒。2月7日22:36,来自新浪微博。

这则微博的核心是说韩寒很“冤”,法学教授既然说“冤”,肯定以为是错案冤案了。只是,教授的文字太短,看不出是经过严谨的证据论证,从法学角度定的“冤”,还是完全从感情的角度帮忙“喊冤”,又或者真的是陷在肖鹰教授所谓的“方舟子定律”里面发出这样的“冤嚎”。我倾向于最后一种,即肖鹰教授的观点。贺卫方教授在后面的回复中会体现出这一点。他甚至都不愿意提到方舟子的名字,以“某”替代,可见从心底里是有些芥蒂的。

第二次:贺卫方:【理解艺术文学】有人把艺术文学的创造当做一种经验活,必须有经历,才能出作品。其实,没经历,未必不能通过其他途径获得知识。况且文艺创作离不开想象力,甚至虚构出那种比真实世界还典型的文学天地。贝多芬晚年感叹他的境界只当得八岁的莫扎特;吴承恩无需与妖魔鬼怪同吃同住才写西游记。 2月7日 23:16,来自新浪微博。

这则谈文学创作的经验和想象力。道理初看没有错。文学是要想象的。但是忽视了一个非常重要的问题,一个人的基本年龄和生活经验。想象不会凭空而来,一定要先有一些经验、知识、见闻等。韩寒当时“创作”长篇小说《三重门》时才十五六岁,那以前,按照韩寒之父韩仁均先生的说法,韩寒基本在读《少年文艺》,生活空间基本固定在一所学校里。无论从知识和经验都是相当不足的。

贺卫方教授肯定没有读过《三重门》,“三重门”引人极度疑惑的重点还不是想象力——想象力部分其实欠缺,而是里面过多的“知识点”。如果说,故事情节和人物都是可以想象虚构的,那么知识点则绝对无法靠想象虚构完成。一个不读过《红楼梦》的人不可能引用《红楼梦》里面的知识点,何况,《三重门》引用的书籍七八十种,名人数十种,甚至涉及多种语言、文学流派、宗教、文化、政治、教育等。大量的人物活动背景又放在大学文学社。里面甚至有“古诗词”,韩寒自己说,是一次性成稿,包括两首词《苏幕遮》和《少年游》,从出版的手稿看出,一个字都未经修改。对一个十五六岁的少年要一次定稿完成20万字的长篇小说,太不可思议了。

贺卫方教授在微博上展示过自己的一页手稿,就那么一篇文字,那手稿也有很多修改。不知道韩寒如何做到一部长篇只有错别字的修改涂抹,任何情节、人物、故事都一次成型?这种奇迹,贺卫方教授打心底相信吗?

道理就这样简单。如果贺卫方教授没有读过《三重门》,也一样不可能讲出并引用里面的任何知识点。而质疑者将那本成名作作为核心分析对象,大部分代笔的证据就是从里面发现的,加上韩寒自己的“呈堂证供”,各类采访视屏作为验证。基本构成了一个完整的代笔“证据链”。但是,贺卫方教授不去看那些内容,也来断案了。并用吴承恩与西游记的关系来佐证。关于《西游记》,现在疑点不少,只是有一点,按照常识做推测,里面的那些虚构和想象,能否由十五六岁的吴承恩完成?

这就是常识的力量。我虽然敬重贺卫方老师,但是也相信,假定他没有读过《罗马法》,也是不可能引用其中篇章的。他十五六岁的时候,应该也无法凭想象力就将整个中国社会的司法现状全部想象出来。

第三次:“@贺卫方:【莫须有与想当然】陈之藩读小学,某次作文自己甚是得意,居然排名末位。他问国文老师,老师说:你一个小学生,绝不可能做出那样的作文,一定是从杂志上抄袭而来。陈说绝无此事。老师答:你如果说你不是抄的,拿出证明来。证明自然是拿不出了的。他既委屈,又无奈……http://t.cn/zOp9gSm 4月15日 10:57 来自新浪微博。”

这则故事很厉害,讲了三个重点,一是暗讽老师“莫须有和想当然”,二是所谓“自证”,三是“韩寒委屈了”(这是暗讲)。事实是否如此呢?

质疑者的所有质疑都以韩寒公开“发表”的作品和视频采访为依据。并没有所谓“莫须有和想当然”的问题。贺教授之所以还是这样认为,与前一点同样的原因:就是从来不去看质疑者的疑点所在,也不看韩寒提供的文本。

也就是说:不看证据。而这一点,对一个律师也好,对一个法学家也好,都是致命伤。

韩寒自己说:他所写的一切都可以成为“呈堂证供”。韩寒自己说自己不读书,自己说自己没有看过《红楼梦》,自己说文章中的那些那些不是自己写的……贺卫方教授是相信什么呢?

如果相信韩寒,那么韩寒的这些话就是在否定自己。起码制造了无数相反的口供,在这种情况下如何判断?何况,那些回答都是韩寒在自愿接受采访,心情愉快的情况下说的,时间跨度长达13年。也没有所谓刑讯逼供,也没有谁堵在韩寒家门口强迫回答。

质疑者进行细致的文本分析,相当于分析案情,发现太多矛盾,作为法学教授的贺卫方先生又会如何决断呢?如果看过分析,经驳斥站不住脚,那好。是严谨态度。如果从来不看,就是一句“推断”,你们那些质疑是推断的。这就糟糕了。

可惜,我们看到贺卫方教授处理这件事很简单,就是相信韩寒是冤枉的,至于别的,不想加入论争。

他也抱持了作家不能自证的“观点”。这个观点事实上是有问题的。

作家完全可以用自己的能力自证。但是韩寒现在体现出来的能力恰恰证明了他不具备写作那些小说的能力。

肖鹰教授可能没有发现,实际上,贺卫方教授还有一次暗讽了质疑者。3212:11微博贴出了一页【雷锋日记】手稿,他写了如下文字:“这手稿,通篇没有一处修改,一看就知道是假的嘛。”

结合当时质疑者正在分析韩寒手稿的语境,就清楚了。好玩的是,接下来教授贴出了自己的一页手稿,则是有很多修改的。这就让读者弄不懂,教授到底想说什么了。

网友@Fare-Well  将肖鹰教授的文章艾特给@贺卫方 先生,说:“贺老师你对肖鹰教授文章《肖鹰:贺卫方是“方舟子定律”的牺牲者》 http://t.cn/zO07PBC怎么看? ”

@贺卫方 先生回复说:【谢谢肖鹰教授】拜读大作,感谢批评。不过,所谓某某定律牺牲者之说,还是稍嫌过甚其辞了。某对我的攻击,向来都是娱乐价值大于批评,于我而言不过浮云。至于我的微博,写的不过是自己对文学的看法,例如最近引用陈之藩的一篇,乃三年前的读书笔记,压根没想介入什么争论。牺牲云乎哉!

这里没有用方舟子先生的名字,其实,从心理学的角度,已经陷进肖鹰教授所说的“方舟子定律”,这不提名字就是有意想回避、不愿意、不屑、懒得……无论什么感情,这个不提已经将态度表达出来了。所以,有理由推断,贺卫方教授为韩寒喊冤,在某种程度上只是因为心底里“不喜欢”方舟子。应该不属于真正的学术角度上的喊冤。

@贺卫方  教授说自己只是谈对文学的看法。明明已经指名道姓在为韩寒喊“冤”了,还将三年前的读书笔记都拿出来作为理据了,怎么又一句浮云就否定了?难道在如此的真假是非面前,法学家也是故意装糊涂,还是有另外的原因呢?

另一个网友@穆铎之 在评论中说: 作为贺卫方教授的关注者,我发现,除韩寒事,贺教授至今仍保持着法学家的理性和正气……然而,在韩寒事件中贺教授……却非常机智而鲜明地与野蛮为友,而背离罗马法精神的常识了。

对此,@贺卫方 教授回复:“穆先生,只要质疑者没有拿出直接而非传言证据,我们只能推定韩作出自本人之手,这正是法律的标准。”

这句话的问题又来了,将质疑者所有的文本研究放在一边不看,来一句“传言证据”,将一切研究成果否定了。文本分析中的疑点是传言吗?韩寒那么多的视频采访是传言吗?韩寒自己的各种语言口供是传言吗?萌芽杂志社那么多不能解决的疑点全部基于当时的大赛公开资料,是传言吗?

我不知道贺教授所谓的直接证据是指什么?

面对上百个疑点,作为法学家的贺教授不研究疑点,却靠“推定”在为韩寒辩护。那么,推定的依据又是什么呢?

有一部外国电影,叫做《魔鬼代言人》,讲的是律师,如何帮助罪犯开脱罪责。当然,律师的职责之一就是帮助嫌疑人维护自己的权利,但是,不能无视所有的指控和疑点,大咧咧的只说一句话:反正我认为他就是冤枉的。

作为一个广受尊敬的学者,贺卫方教授如果真的拿不准韩寒事件,或者不想加入论战,当然是可以的,那就对这件事不发言,也就行了。可是偏偏他发言了,而且好多次。如果发言,就应该研究一下韩寒自己的“呈堂证供”和质疑者的各种研究发现,也就是研究疑点。

如果觉得这些疑点站不住脚,教授应该写详细一点,从法理的角度破解,那就彻底帮了韩寒了。

如果仅仅采取无视资料,又要肯定表态,又要帮忙喊冤的态度,就不能算严谨了。

可见,中国知识分子,即便如此客观理性的人,也难免受到情感的影响而背离了专业精神和品质。明明有那么多的疑点呈堂了,还是可以不看,就帮忙喊冤。只是,这样的喊冤未免太没有力量,反而影响了自己的形象。

真假,这么简单的问题都还让多少名流把持不住自己的节操,谈公平与正义,道路势必更坎坷,更远。

随便谈点看法,请教贺卫方教授。

                                     2012.4.17  于日本

分类: 

参与评分: 

还没有评价

评论

访客的头像

贺老师该在研究一下证据学理论了。谈太多的XXX在这件事上没有。最新的微薄画蛇添足。除非我们都是傻子。这种3岁小孩的倔强不要也罢。
石河子凉皮。

20180201lck

liuchunkai的头像

20180201lck

michael kors outlet online

air max 90

canada goose coats

ugg outlet

cheap ray ban sunglasses

uggs outlet online

oakley sunglasses

moncler coats

michael kors outlet clearance

ugg canada

uggs outlet

canada goose jackets

canada goose coats

ralph lauren

longchamp solde

polo ralph lauren outlet

moncler jackets

cheap ray ban sunglasses

uggs outlet online

converse shoes sale

coach outlet store online

rayban sunglasses

cheap oakley sunglasses

kevin durant shoes

kate spade outlet

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet online

broncos jersey

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren shirts

mulberry handbags

chrome hearts online store

canada goose outlet store

polo ralph lauren

fitflops sale

coach outlet online

ralph lauren outlet

swarovski outlet

christian louboutin outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

ralph lauren polo

fitflops sale clearance

oakley sunglasses

swarovski uk

cheap nba jerseys

salomon shoes

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ralph lauren polo shirts

ugg outlet

polo outlet

prada sunglasses

nfl jerseys

adidas wings

canada goose jackets

canada goose jackets outlet

coach outlet

polo ralph lauren

ralph lauren outlet

nike store uk

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet online

true religion jeans

cheap snapbacks

asics running shoe

lacoste pas cher

air max 90

lacoste polo shirts

kate spade outlet

michael kors outlet

nike air max

oakley sunglasses wholesale

coach outlet

ray-ban sunglasses

ecco outlet

cartier watches

longchamp pas cher

ferragamo outlet

nike outlet online

tory burch outlet online

fitflops shoes

ugg boots on sale

ray ban sunglasses outlet

cheap jordans

true religion outlet store

michael kors handbags outlet

ugg outlet

ferragamo shoes

nike outlet store

ferragamo shoes

nfl jerseys

polo ralph lauren outlet

tory burch outlet online

michael kors outlet

longchamp pas cher

tory burch outlet

nike shoes outlet

football shirts

canada goose

true religion jeans

birkenstock shoes

ugg outlet online

canada goose jackets

polo ralph lauren shirts

swarovski outlet store

ugg boots

christian louboutin outlet

oakley sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet

canada goose coats

ugg outlet

nfl jerseys wholesale

montblanc pens

coach outlet online

oakley sunglasses wholesale

football shirts

nike roshe one

canada goose jackets outlet

nike factory outlet

coach canada

polo outlet online store

soccer shoes

longchamp outlet

links of london

true religion uk

ferragamo outlet

canada goose jackets

coach outlet store online

cheap nfl jerseys

longchamp pliage

moncler outlet

polo ralph lauren

burberry outlet

air max uk

canada goose jackets men

cheap ugg boots

nfl jersey wholesale

air max 90

michael kors outlet stores

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach outlet store online

moncler outlet

christian louboutin outlet

mulberry handbags

michael kors handbags

fitflops sale clearance

uggs outlet

canada goose

coach factory outlet

coach outlet online

supreme clothing

canada goose outlet

polo ralph lauren

pandora charms

swarovski jewelry

denver broncos jersey

adidas uk

michael kors outlet

true religion jeans

moncler outlet online

fitflops sale clearance

tods outlet

true religion outlet

ralph lauren outlet

chrome hearts

oakley sunglasses wholesale

ray ban sunglasses

christian louboutin outlet

coach outlet online

adidas outlet store

cheap oakley sunglasses

cheap ray ban sunglasses

puma outlet

canada goose jackets

coach outlet

pandora charms

canada goose outlet store

giuseppe zanotti shoes

pandora outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

tory burch outlet

uggs outletonline

oakley sunglasses wholesale

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

ugg outlet

uggs outlet

nba jerseys

coach outlet store

canada goose outlet store

michael kors outlet online

coach outlet online

ugg outlet

nhl jerseys

canada goose jackets

ugg boots clearance

christian louboutin shoes

moncler coats

true religion outlet

coach outlet online

oakley sunglasses wholesale

supreme clothing

hermes birkin

true religion jeans

jerseys wholesale

burberry outlet stores

ugg boots

coach outlet online

coach outlet online

ralph lauren outlet

kate spade sale

mulberry bags

ugg outlet online

michael kors outlet clearance

ugg outlet

christian louboutin

polo ralph lauren

ugg boots clearance

ugg outlet

swarovski jewelry

los angeles lakers jerseys

coach handbags on sale

michael kors outlet clearance

oakley sunglasses

mulberry handbags

mulberry handbags

ralph lauren polo shirts

oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin shoes

canada goose jackets

polo ralph lauren

mulberry handbags

nike roshe

polo ralph lauren

polo outlet

fitflops

adidas nmd

christian louboutin shoes

uggs on sale

uggs outlet

uggs outlet

canada goose outlet store

adidas nmd r1

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet store

louboutin shoes

tory burch outlet online

mbt shoes outlet

polo outlet

michael kors outlet online

coach outlet

new balance shoes

oakley sunglasses

burberry outlet sale online

uggs outlet

cheap ugg boots

ugg boots on sale

nike foamposite

air max trainers

michael kors outlet

coach factory store

polo ralph lauren

ed hardy outlet

christian louboutin sale

longchamp handbags

pandora charms

adidas nmd runner

prada bags

fitflops sale clearance

uggs outlet

coach factory outlet

nike shoes

ugg boots clearance

dansko shoes

christian louboutin shoes

michael kors handbags

michael kors outlet

true religion jeans

converse shoes

nike outlet store

mulberry bags

canada goose

pandora outlet

oakley sunglasses

oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet

fitflops

cheap mlb jerseys

canada goose outlet store

nike blazer pas cher

ugg boots clearance

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ugg boots on sale

nike air huarache

oakley sunglasses sale

christian louboutin

canada goose uk

valentino outlet

adidas outlet

ugg outlet store

hermes belts

reebok outlet store

ray ban sunglasses outlet

coach factory outlet

moncler outlet

michael kors outlet

oakley sunglasses

ferragamo shoes

air huarache

coach factory outlet

longchamp handbags

yeezy boost

polo outlet

nfl jersey wholesale

polo pas cher

longchamp outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

ray ban sunglasses

canada goose jackets

christian louboutin sale

mont blanc outlet

canada goose outlet online

christian louboutin outlet

coach outlet online

air max 90

coach outlet store online

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

christian louboutin shoes

cheap football shirts

tory burch sandals

tory burch outlet store

mlb jerseys

michael kors outlet clearance

nike shoes

cazal sunglasses

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet

coach outlet

coach factory outlet

swarovski outlet

canada goose outlet

ugg boots on sale

ray ban sunglasses on sale

air max shoes

burberry outlet

true religion outlet

coach outlet store

ralph lauren uk

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren shirts

tory burch outlet

true religion jeans

oakley sunglasses

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet online

oakley sunglasses

cheap jordans

fitflops sale clearance

jordan shoes

michael kors

polo ralph lauren

barbour outlet

true religion jeans

oakley sunglasses

canada goose

ray ban sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

ugg outlet

canada goose jackets

nike store uk

ugg boots on sale

nfl jerseys

canada goose jackets

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet online

nike shoes

cheap jerseys wholesale

canada goose outlet

canada goose jackets

prada shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

polo ralph lauren

ray ban sunglasses outlet

hermes online

canada goose outlet store

canada goose outlet store

chicago blackhawks jerseys

ralph lauren shirts

canada goose jackets clearance

ugg boots clearance

mulberry sale

canada goose jackets

canada goose

canada goose outlet

coach outlet online

vans shoes

ferragamo shoes

cheap jordans free shipping

cheap oakley sunglasses

adidas nmd

air max 2015

uggs outlet

canada goose jackets

ray ban sunglasses

ugg outlet

michael kors wallets for women

cheap oakley sunglasses

air max 90

polo shirts

lacoste polo

coach factory outlet

ray ban sunglasses

uggs outlet

canada goose jackets

michael kors outlet online

ray ban sunglasses

polo ralph lauren

oakley sunglasses

true religion jeans

nba jerseys

michael kors wallets

true religion outlet

true religion outlet

nike air max 90

ferragamo outlet

cheap jordans

air max uk

oakley sunglasses

nike outlet

ray ban sunglasses

nike trainers

ralph lauren polo

mulberry handbags

hermes outlet

michael kors outlet

canada goose outlet

ugg boots clearance

canada goose outlet

basketball shoes

longchamp pliage

tory burch outlet

nfl jerseys wholesale

pandora outlet

ugg boots

canada goose outlet store

coach outlet online

true religion jeans

true religion jeans sale

snapback hats

uggs outlet

uggs canada

canada goose jackets

swarovski crystal

coach factory outlet

cheap nfl jerseys

cheap oakley sunglasses

canada goose jackets

lacoste outlet

canada goose jackets outlet

coach outlet online

canada goose jackets sale

michael kors outlet clearance

mont blanc pens

snapbacks wholesale

oakley sunglasses uk

canada goose outlet

canada goose jackets outlet

michael kors handbags clearance

jordan shoes

canada goose

tory burch outlet online

ray ban sunglasses

mlb jerseys wholesale

nike uk store

oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren

prada handbags

uggs outlet

polo outlet

hermes outlet

ugg boots

nike air max 1

valentino shoes

canada goose jackets

uggs outlet

ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet online

uggs outlet

polo outlet

ugg outlets

oakley sunglasses

kd shoes

nfl jerseys

ugg outlet stores

coach handbags

oakley sunglasses

canada goose outlet store

oakley sunglasses

mulberry bags

michael kors uk

tory burch outlet

coach outlet

true religion outlet

soccer jerseys

michael kors uk

michael?kors?handbags

max 1

canada goose uk

cheap uggs

mcm backpacks

oakley sunglasses

canada goose

uggs outlet

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet store

burberry outlet store

canada goose jackets sale

christian louboutin shoes

michael kors outlet

birkenstock outlet

mlb jerseys

coach handbags online outlet

polo outlet online

coach factory outlet

canada goose outlet store

michael kors factory outlet

ugg black friday

ralph lauren outlet

adidas shoes

polo ralph lauren

michael kors outlet online

ralph lauren polo

polo ralph lauren

nike trainers

mac makeup

true religion canada

tory burch handbags

reebok shoes

mont blanc pens

nike trainers

oakley sunglasses wholesale

polo ralph lauren

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach outlet online

coach outlet

new balance outlet

canada goose outlet online

supra shoes

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet

polo outlet

michael kors outlet online

michael kors outlet

ugg outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

mac cosmetics

longchamp solde

uggs outlet

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

kate spade outlet online

michael kors outlet

coach outlet

nike air huarache

canada goose outlet store

uggs outlet

michael kors outlet online

ray ban sunglasses outlet

canada goose outlet

tory burch outlet online

coach outlet

canada goose jackets sale

jordan shoes

tory burch outlet online

ralph lauren polo

nike shoes

michael kors uk

cheap oakley sunglasses

canada goose outlet store

ray-ban sunglasses

cheap oakley sunglasses

marc jacobs outlet

longchamp bags

nike store

uggs outlet

oakley sunglasses

fitflops outlet

mulberry outlet

canada goose jackets

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach outlet

pandora charms

air jordan shoes

ugg boots

ray ban sunglasses outlet

cheap ray bans

cheap mlb jerseys

coach outlet

fitflops

true religion outlet

ugg outlet store

denver broncos jersey

air force 1 shoes

coach outlet online

nike shoes

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

michael kors bags

canada goose jackets

pandora charms

nfl jerseys

cheap ray ban sunglasses

canada goose parka

canada goose jackets

nike free 5

nike shoes on sale

coach factory outlet

denver broncos jerseys

coach outlet

ugg boots

oakley sunglasses

canada goose outlet store

canada goose jackets

oakley sunglasses sale

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ralph lauren polo

christian louboutin outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

pandora charms sale clearance

coach outlet

burberry canada

polo ralph lauren outlet

ugg boots

mbt shoes

coach factory outlet

ray ban sunglasses sale

ralph lauren factory store

michael kors outlet

longchamp outlet

michael kors handbags

oakley sunglasses wholesale

kobe bryants shoes

cheap soccer jerseys

herve leger dresses

nhl jerseys wholesale

coach outlet

reebok trainers

oakley sunglasses wholesale

uggs outlet

true religion outlet store

louboutin shoes

polo outlet

cheap jordans

coach factory outlet

michael kors handbags

michael kors outlet clearance

canada goose jackets

coach outlet online

yeezy boost 350

mulberry handbags sale

fred perry polo

coach outlet

longchamp bags

coach outlet

fitflops

cheap oakley sunglasses

polo outlet stores

jordan shoes

mac outlet

jordan shoes

pandora jewelry

ugg boots

puma shoes

cheap oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet online

cheap nhl jerseys

michael kors canada

ugg boots

coach outlet

canada goose outlet

coach outlet store online

coach handbags outlet

coach outlet store online

coach outlet online

ray bans

camisetas futbol baratas

links of london jewellery

swarovski outlet

michael?kors?outlet?online

longchamp solde

uggs on clearance

ugg boots clearance

true religion outlet

michael kors outlet

nike free running

air huarache

michael kors outlet clearance

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

pandora outlet

tory burch outlet

coach canada

ugg outlet

ecco shoes

lacoste shirts

polo ralph lauren

christian louboutin shoes

ugg outlet

coach outlet

michael kors outlet online

nba jerseys wholesale

coach outlet online

coach factory outlet

ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet online

marc jacobs sale

ray ban sunglasses outlet

burberry outlet

longchamp outlet online

coach outlet

ferragamo outlet

pandora charms

canada goose outlet

coach outlet

longchamp handbags

coach outlet canada

ugg outlet

coach outlet store online

ralph lauren shirts

canada goose jackets

moncler coats

ugg outlet

prada shoes for men

canada goose outlet

jordan 4

tory burch outlet

true religion outlet store

michael kors handbags

michael kors bags

michael kors online

bottega veneta outlet online

nike outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

ugg outlet

christian louboutin outlet

michael kors outlet online

moncler jackets

canada goose jackets for women

ugg boots clearance

moncler outlet

giuseppe zanotti outlet

christian louboutin sale

pandora charms outlet

air max 1

canada goose outlet store

ralph lauren outlet

polo outlet

ugg boots

swarovski outlet

ferragamo shoes

coach outlet store online

ugg boots

canada goose jackets sale

longchamp handbags

oakley sunglasses wholesale

prada outlet online

foamposite shoes

polo ralph lauren

ray ban sunglasses

canada goose jackets

max 90

polo ralph lauren outlet

christian louboutin outlet

canada goose outlet

coach factory outlet

hermes birkin bag

pandora outlet

ugg boots

nhl jerseys

ferragamo shoes

soccer jerseys

canada goose coats

cheap jordans for sale

uggs outlet

canada goose outlet store

coach outlet

ferragamo shoes sale

michael kors outlet online

air max shoes

michael kors outlet

hermes belt

ugg boots clearance

reebok shoes

uggs clearance

canada goose parka

coach factory outlet

longchamp outlet store

polo outlet

michael kors outlet

christian louboutin

uggs outletonline

canada goose outlet online

herve leger outlet

thomas sabo charms

ugg boots clearance

ugg outlet store

cheap ray ban sunglasses

adidas trainers

nike air max 2015

nike air max 90

fitflops uk

ray ban sunglasses

longchamp pas cher

canada goose outlet store

coach outlet

fitflops uk

pandora charms

canada goose outlet

nike air force 1

cheap nba jerseys

true religion outlet

coach outlet clearance

canada goose outlet store

vans outlet

mont blanc pens

pandora charms

uggs outlet

coach outlet

michael kors factory outlet

coach outlet

air max trainers

michael kors handbags

true religion outlet

broncos jerseys

cheap ray ban sunglasses

oakley sunglasses wholesale

longchamp solde

michael kors

cleveland cavaliers jersey

polo ralph lauren outlet

uggs outlet online

ugg boots on sale

swarovski outlet store

ralph lauren

coach outlet

kobe bryant shoes

polo ralph lauren

canada goose jackets

pandora charms sale clearance

coach outlet online

denver broncos jerseys

michael kors outlet clearance

prada sunglasses for women

ralph lauren

cheap uggs

fitflops

michael kors outlet clearance

pandora jewelry

christian louboutin outlet

ugg boots clearance

polo ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet store online

michael kors handbags

broncos jerseys

rayban sunglasses

michael kors outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

mbt outlet

mulberry uk

ugg outlet

coach outlet store

cheap jerseys

mcm outlet

ugg boots outlet

uggs outlet

nike shoes

true religion jeans

michael kors outlet online

ray ban sunglasses

nike air max 90

bottega veneta outlet

ralph lauren outlet

jordan shoes

coach outlet store online

polo ralph lauren

cartier outlet

ugg outlet

moncler jackets

uggs on sale

polo ralph lauren

polo ralph lauren

ralph lauren shirts

canada goose outlet store

nike roshe run

michael kors outlet

ralph lauren polo

chrome hearts outlet

ugg outlet store

ralph lauren polo

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap oakley sunglasses

yeezy boost 350

moncler jackets

fitflops sale clearance

uggs outlet

nhl jerseys for sale

kobe 9

cheap snapbacks

michael kors outlet

coach outlet

kate spade outlet online

cheap ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet online

coach handbags

canada goose coats

ugg outlet online clearance

canada goose outlet

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet

fred perry polo shirts

coach outlet online

canada goose jackets

coach outlet store

polo ralph lauren

true religion jeans

cheap jordan shoes

nike shoes outlet

ugg outlet

cheap ray ban sunglasses

lacoste soldes

ugg cyber monday

ray ban sunglasses outlet

cheap ugg boots

ugg boots outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

mont blanc pens

polo outlet factory store

birkenstock shoes

ugg boots for women

cleveland cavaliers jerseys

cheap oakley sunglasses

soccer jerseys wholesale

tory burch outlet online

christian louboutin sale

birkenstock sandals

coach outlet

canada goose outlet

ugg outlet online

canada goose outlet

coach outlet

christian louboutin shoes

michael kors outlet

coach outlet online

longchamp outlet online

ralph lauren polo

michael kors outlet clearance

ed hardy clothing

canada goose

ugg outlet

air max 90

lakers jerseys

michael kors uk

basketball sneakers

kate spade sale

michael kors outlet clearance

kobe shoes

ugg boots

coach outlet online

true religion jeans

canada goose uk

pandora jewelry

prada shoes on sale

swarovski crystal

canada goose outlet store

blackhawks jerseys

ugg outlet

coach outlet

cheap basketball shoes

uggs outlet

ugg outlet

coach factory outlet

uggs outlet

uggs outlet

salomon outlet

ray ban sunglasses

ysl outlet

coach factory outlet

pandora outlet

oakley sunglasses

canada goose outlet sale

pandora jewelry

polo ralph lauren outlet

michael kors uk

ugg outlet

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

cheap jerseys

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap oakley sunglasses

ugg boots outlet

canada goose outlet online

canada goose uk

uggs outlet

air jordan 4

polo ralph lauren

true religion jeans sale

canada goose outlet online

swarovski crystal

adidas wings shoes

cheap nfl jerseys

longchamp handbags

uggs outlet

ugg boots clearance

longchamp pas cher

ugg outlet online clearance

oakley sunglasses wholesale

michael kors online

michael kors outlet clearance

canada goose outlet

supra shoes sale

tory burch outlet

canada goose outlet

coach outlet

supreme clothing

cheap ugg boots

prada outlet

longchamp pliage

nike shoes uk

christian louboutin sale

coach factory outlet

ugg boots

ugg outlet

ysl outlet online

moncler outlet

polo outlet

nfl jerseys

christian louboutin shoes

christian louboutin shoes

canada goose outlet

pandora jewelry outlet

cheap michael kors handbags

tods outlet online

canada goose outlet online

longchamp handbags sale

michael kors uk

pandora outlet

polo ralph lauren

fitflops sale clearance

canada goose jackets

canada goose outlet

true religion jeans

michael kors outlet online

coach factory outlet

ugg outlet

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet online

mulberry bags

ralph lauren pas cher

coach outlet online

ugg boots

christian louboutin shoes

michael kors handbags outlet

canada goose outlet online

adidas store

pandora outlet

nike outlet

ferragamo shoes

mulberry outlet

asics shoes

pandora outlet

polo ralph lauren

mulberry bags

ugg outlet逗号ugg outlet stores

longchamp bags

barbour outlet store

coach outlet store online

ugg outlet online

coach outlet

uggs outlet

cazal outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

true religion jeans

coach outlet store online

burberry outlet

louboutin shoes

ferragamo outlet

canada goose jackets

ray ban sunglasses outlet

nike shoes

coach outlet store online

coach outlet

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors

coach outlet online

uggs outlet

christian louboutin

coach outlet store online

kobe shoes

canada goose

canada goose outlet

christian louboutin outlet

ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet online

longchamp outlet

ray ban sunglasses outlet

canada goose outlet

uggs outlet

mont blanc pens

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet online

hermes outlet store

nike factory store

jordan shoes

tory burch handbags

oakley sunglasses

canada goose coats

ugg outlet online

coach factory outlet

burberry outlet sale

yeezy boost

canada goose jackets

cheap nhl jerseys

supreme clothing

christian louboutin online

air max 90

polo ralph lauren

michael kors outlet clearance

pandora charms

michael kors outlet

cheap jordans

fitflops shoes

longchamp handbags

canada goose outlet

cheap football shirts

michael kors outlet

michael kors

nike outlet online

michael kors outlet clearance

uggs

canada goose outlet

tory burch outlet store

cheap jordan shoes

coach factory outlet

pandora outlet

canada goose outlet

ray ban sunglasses outlet

ralph lauren polo shirts

ray ban sunglasses

thomas sabo

polo outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap jordan shoes

oakley sunglasses

pandora charms sale clearance

michael kors outlet online

lebron james shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

coach outlet

polo ralph lauren shirts

cheap jordan shoes

coach outlet online

ugg outlet

ferragamo outlet

ugg boots on sale

chrome hearts outlet

coach outlet store online

coach outlet

polo outlets factory store

ugg boots

canada goose coats

canada goose outlet store

christian louboutin outlet

uggs outlet

nike nba jerseys

nfl jerseys

cheap oakley sunglasses

soccer cleats

mulberry outlet逗号mulberry handbags outlet

nike factory shoes

kobe 9 elite

michael kors outlet online

canada goose jackets

christian louboutin outlet

canada goose jackets

nfl jersey wholesale

tory burch outlet stores

canada goose jackets

ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet store online clearances

cheap nfl jerseys

canada goose outlet

michael kors outlet online

michael kors outlet online

cheap ugg boots

true religion outlet uk

ugg boots clearance

ugg boots clearance

coach outlet

nike roshe run

ugg boots

hermes outlet store

snapbacks wholesale

michael kors handbags

michael kors outlet

ray ban sunglasses

christian louboutin outlet

burberry outlet online

true religion outlet

coach outlet online

christian louboutin

nike blazer pas cher

mulberry uk

michael kors outlet online

uggs outlet

swarovski crystal

canada goose outlet

michael kors outlet

canada goose outlet

coach factory outlet

pandora charms

nike trainers uk

true religion jeans

longchamp pliage

futbol baratas

jordan shoes

michael kors outlet online

true religion jeans

uggs outlet

swarovski outlet store

polo ralph lauren factory store

coach outlet online

true religion jeans for men

michael kors outlet online

michael kors outlet

true religion uk

lebron shoes

coach outlet

oakley sunglasses

oakley sunglasses wholesale

canada goose outlet

mulberry handbags

20180201lck

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。