不获胜利,不能收兵  作者:纪旭

 新语丝网2012年3月26日发布了胡矢先生的文章《谁有资格质疑?谁有资格下结论?》,对攻击方舟子博士的人和事进行了批评和评判,对方舟子的打假给予了支持和声援。文章总体上写得较好,我是比较赞同的。但对文章最后向方舟子所提的见好就收,打韩寒之假可以收兵的建议,却有不同看法。现提出来供方舟子和大家参考。

  第一,打韩寒之假目前并未胜利,怎能收兵。韩寒只是在见起诉方舟子胜诉无望的情况下暂时撤诉了。一旦他得到高人指点,认为有机可乘,便又会起诉的。故需防患于未然。第二,韩寒(方)仍在反攻,他们在赔本的情况下出版他的《三重门》韩寒手稿(影印本),就是要证明《三重门》等文学作品是他自己写的创作的(实际上只能证明他手抄了一遍),继续欺骗群众,继续反诬方舟子乱打一气。

       第三,韩寒只是不敢与方舟子当面对质辩论(因为他感到自己的素质、文化、阅历、知识结构、反应、记忆、表达能力等都不如方舟子,心虚胆怯,担心当面辩论不会赢,很可能输),但在其他公开场合,仍在坚持谩骂诋毁方舟子。

      第四,挺韩方纠集一批人,炮制了一封攻击方舟子妻硕士论文抄袭的公开信,企图混淆视听,转移当前打假斗争方向。公开信的发起者与韩寒父子有无协同暂不知晓,但公开信实际上起了这样的作用。

      第五,现在如果“不(要)把手上的牌都亮出来,留下剩勇(用在其他方面更效)”,不把韩寒造假彻底揭露,不把挺韩方完全击败,寒韩方便会乘势反攻,对打假方很不利。

第六,虽然“时间和实践迟早会把他(韩寒)的伪装剥去”。(我)“不信再过二十年,这个天才少年还能写出几本像样的作品来?还能继续凭借少年作家的光环在文坛厮混?”,但韩寒才三十来岁,其父小作家韩仁均(代写的最大嫌疑人)才五十多岁。正常情况下韩仁均还能再写二十多年。那还要误导、祸害多少青少年、儿童。所以,不把韩寒彻底批倒将贻害无穷。

第七,方舟子肯定还有揭露韩寒造假的底牌和钢鞭材料。并已为此花费了很多精力。如果不陆续公布,对方舟子耗费的心血必然造成浪费。这样对提高打假的效率来说,也不利。

第八,如果风云变幻,将来再揭批,许多人人也许会说方舟子翻历史旧账,得理不饶人。这样对方舟子和挺方方也不太好。

  一个区区高中肄业生,门门考试都不及格(包括语文),却能成为所谓“少年文学天才”、“少年作家”、社会公众人物,出大名,发大财,有钱有势。这对广大小学生、初中生、高中生、大学生,对广大青少年儿童将起多么巨大的误导欺骗作用。这实际上在大肆宣扬(“文革”中长期盛行的)“读书无用论”,“考试无用论”。这将对中国的基础教育造成多大的冲击,带来多大的危害。所以,无论从社会正义来说,还是从方舟子学术打假的战略策略来看,都应该把揭露批判韩寒文学创作造假的斗争进行到底,不获胜利,不能收兵。

(XYS20120330)

◇◇新语丝(www.xys.org)(xys6.dxiong.com)(xys.ebookdiy.com)(xys2.dropin.org)◇◇

分类: 

参与评分: 

平均评分: 5 (6个评价)

评论

倒韩网友应当采取以逸待劳的策略,  

访客的头像

倒韩网友应当采取以逸待劳的策略,   一旦发现猿人君和韩二龟冒头,  倒韩网友应当立即给予其沉重的打击.  只要长期坚持下去,  韩二龟必处于尴尬的境地,  韩二龟也就难以露脸装逼.
可以说,  倒韩是挺惬意的 !

倒韩持续的时间越长越好 !

如果明年蒙丫还举办新概念作文比赛,  倒韩网友一定要去砸场子 !

 

看到诸多网站上''韩寒''这个共用ID的微博以及百度百科现在还如此介绍: ''作家、赛车手'',  咱不由得笑了.

既然,  赛车手韩寒声称自己就是作家韩寒.
那么,  咱们应当衷心祝愿: 赛车手韩寒与<<三重门>>作者的老婆夜夜激情.
既然,  作家韩寒声称自己就是赛车手韩寒.
那么,  咱们应当衷心祝愿: <<三重门>>的作者与赛车手韩寒的老婆夜夜激情.

polo ralph lauren

Andada的头像

polo ralph lauren

kate spade outlet

coach factory outlet

mbt shoes outlet

nike store

coach outlet online

clippers jersey

polo outlet

chicago bulls

asics outlet

saics running shoes

miami dolphins jerseys

indianapolis colts jerseys

mont blanc outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

polo ralph lauren

jordan shoes

christian louboutin outlet

michael kors handbags sale

falcons jersey

cheap nfl jerseys

michael kors canada

jordan 8

new orleans saints jerseys

hermes belts

nike huarache

air jordan uk

coach outlet

nike trainers

pandora jewelry

salomon boots

nike huarache

kansas city chiefs jerseys

coach outlet store online

jaguars jersey

coach factory outlet

true religion outlet

coach factory outlet

seahawks jersey

jimmy choo shoes

cheap nba jerseys

nike tn pas cher

nike factory store

cheap mlb jerseys

coach bags

cheap ray bans

replica rolex

coach factory outlet

nike outlet store

dolphins jerseys

cheap jordans

oakley sunglasses

lions jerseys

raiders jerseys

skechers shoes

coach factory outlet

minnesota vikings jerseys

christian louboutin outlet

soccer shoes

chicago bears jerseys

oklahoma city thunder jerseys

coach outlet online

miami heat jersey

cheap oakley sunglasses

nike tn

asics shoes

coach outlet online

saints jerseys

ray ban sunglasses outlet

carolina panthers jersey

coach outlet

prada outlet

ecco shoes

canada goose sale

jordan shoes

colts jerseys

cleveland browns jerseys

nike outlet

nike shoes

pandora outlet

pandora outlet

ed hardy

browns jerseys

coach outlet online

nike outlet

michael kors handbags

ralph lauren polo

michael kors outlet

gucci borse

cheap ray bans

true religion outlet

canada goose

san francisco 49ers jerseys

miami heat

coach handbags

ray ban sunglasses

abercrombie and fitch

texans jerseys

true religion outlet store

cardinals jersey

prada shoes

reebok outlet

cheap jordan shoes

nba jerseys

yeezy boost 350 v2

coach outlet

oakley sunglasses

fitflops sale clearance

oakland raiders jerseys

asics shoes

rolex watches

cheap oakley sunglasses

kate spade sale

true religion outlet

broncos jerseys

rolex replica watches

true religion jeans

polo ralph lauren

cheap ray bans

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors outlet

coach outlet store

hugo boss outlet

replica watches

titans jersey

replica watches

oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin shoes

cleveland cavaliers

nfl jerseys wholesale

ray ban sunglasses

nike shoes

fitflops sale clearance

christian louboutin outlet

oklahoma city thunder

armani outlet

nike trainers

cowboys jerseys

cheap ray ban sunglasses

true religion jeans

ferragamo shoes

kate spade outlet

michael kors handbags

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet online

christian louboutin shoes

seattle seahawks jerseys

michael kors uk

polo ralph lauren

ferragamo outlet

michael kors uk

moncler jackets

michael kors handbags

coach outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

burberry outlet

cheap ray bans

ralph lauren outlet

los angeles lakers

gucci shoes

clippers jersey for sale

fitflops sale

patriots jerseys

coach factory outlet

yeezy boost 350

ray ban sunglasses outlet

coach outlet

san diego chargers jerseys

mlb jerseys

vikings jerseys

michael kors outlet online

denver broncos jerseys

ray ban sunglasses

nike huarache

air jordan 8

air huarache

mont blanc pens

kate spade outlet

coach outlet

michael kors handbags

birkenstock outlet

christian louboutin uk

christian louboutin outlet

reebok shoes

buffalo bills jerseys

adidas yeezy

ed hardy uk

snapbacks wholesale

gucci sito ufficiale

dolce and gabbana outlet

michael kors handbags

ray ban sunglasses outlet

fitflops sale clearance

nike shoes

mbt shoes

polo ralph lauren

washington redskins jerseys

coach outlet

coach factory outlet

nike air huarache

cheap ray bans

dolce and gabbana shoes

salomon shoes

nike outlet

ray ban sunglasses

oakley sunglasses

omega watches

michael kors uk

jordan 4

eagles jerseys

cheap jordans

tods shoes

michael kors outlet

jacksonville jaguars jersey

houston texans jerseys

chargers jerseys

coach outlet online

coach handbags

nike blazer

cheap ray bans

nike huarache

nike air max 90

nike factory outlet

new balance outlet

coach outlet online

oakley sunglasses

jets jersey

ray ban sunglasses outlet

abercrombie and fitch kids

nike outlet store

coach outlet

coach outlet

coach outlet store online

kate spade handbags

nike factory outlet

oakley sunglasses

coach outlet

canada goose

cleveland cavaliers jerseys

nike shoes

air max 90

nike outlet

ralph lauren outlet

nike outlet

ecco shoes uk

philadelphia eagles jerseys

true religion outlet store

ralph lauren outlet

replica rolex

pandora outlet

new balance shoes

instyler max

oakley sunglasses wholesale

golden state warriors jerseys

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet

rolex replica

jordan shoes

cheap jordan shoes

ray ban sunglasses outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet

coach outlet store online

basketball shoes

nike roshe run

rolex replica

cheap nike shoes

hugo boss sale

michael kors outlet

discount oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren uk

canada goose outlet

cheap nhl jerseys

armani exchange

gucci outlet

nike air huarache

49ers jersey

baltimore ravens jerseys

air max 2015

pandora jewelry

carolina jerseys

polo ralph lauren

pandora outlet

fitflops sale

michael kors

ecco shoes

ralph lauren outlet

ralph lauren uk

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors outlet

cincinnati bengals jerseys

chiefs jersey

skechers outlet

pandora jewelry

dallas cowboys jerseys

coach outlet online

ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet

golden state warriors

new york knicks

ray ban sunglasses

fitflops shoes

bengals jersey

christian louboutin shoes

michael kors handbags

packers jerseys

pandora charms

cheap oakley sunglasses

los angeles lakers jerseys

nike soccer shoes

oakley sunglasses

boston celtics

polo ralph lauren outlet

michael kors handbags

ed hardy clothing

jordan shoes

detroit lions jerseys

coach outlet store online

tennessee titans jersey

louboutin shoes

oakley sunglasses

jimmy choo outlet

mont blanc outlet

ray ban sunglasses

redskins jerseys

cheap snapbacks

ralph lauren outlet

nike trainers

michael kors handbags

coach outlet online

replica watches

new england patriots jerseys

kate spade handbags

kate spade outlet

polo ralph lauren

oakley sunglasses wholesale

nike trainers shoes

yeezy shoes

michael kors uk

moncler outlet

christian louboutin shoes

valentino outlet

michael kors handbags

pittsburgh steelers jersey

birkenstock sandals

oakley sunglasses wholesale

nike shoes

boston celtics jersey

san antonio spurs jerseys

coach outlet online

ecco sandals

longchamp handbags

green bay packers jerseys

christian louboutin outlet

polo ralph lauren

ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet

steelers jerseys

kate spade handbags

ralph lauren outlet

ed hardy outlet

bills jerseys

ralph lauren outlet

nike blazer pas cher

fitflops sale clearance

bears jerseys

coach outlet

arizona cardinals jerseys

new york knicks jersey

kate spade sale

christian louboutin shoes

cheap ray ban sunglasses

true religion outlet

tods outlet

longchamp outlet

valentino shoes

ray ban sunglasses

chicago bulls jersey

nhl jerseys

giants jersey

cheap jordan shoes

christian louboutin shoes

converse trainers

new york giants jerseys

nike air huarache

ravens jerseys

mont blanc pens

nike roshe

nike outlet

converse shoes

michael kors handbags

hermes belt

oakley sunglasses wholesale

nike air max

atlanta falcons jerseys

kate spade sale

cheap basketball shoes

ralph lauren outlet

san antonio spurs

christian louboutin sale

air jordan 4

omega watches sale

fitflops

new york jets jerseys

polo ralph lauren

nike air jordan

coach outlet

bruberry sale

ray ban sunglasses

instyler max 2

jordan shoes

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。
Type the characters you see in this picture. (使用语音验证)
填入上图所示的数字或者单词;如果你看不清,点击保存按钮,系统会为您重新生成您新的图片。不区分大小写。