东风还是西风?——与@中青报曹林 谈@肖鹰 的批韩文章 by 司马3忌

昨天刊登在中国青年报的肖鹰教授批韩文章,引起了舆论界的剧烈争论,反对意见不少,主要观点在于批评肖文的“文革遗风、大字报”。同样是在中青报,今天刊发储殷的文章“不要用大字报的方式倒韩”。也许年轻的同学们对于文革时期的所谓“大字报”并不熟悉,需要做个简单的解释,大概的意思就是:“吃相太猛”。暗示的寓意后面再谈。

 

反对肖文的尤以曹林为代表,便有了和“评论名人”曹林聊聊的想法。聊天角度多种多样,入乡随俗,选个官媒著名评论人曹林同志最为擅长的政治角度吧。 

 

首先谈谈批韩的“严谨”。 

 

众所周知,始于2012年初的方韩大战,至今未曾脱离公众的视线和关注,参与者不计其数,所有署名“韩寒”的作品和公开信息均被网友分析得一丝不挂,仅方舟子在倒韩初期的短短一个多月内,就撰写文本分析文章四十余篇。反观韩寒的反应,从最初的声言悬赏2000万,继而搭桥“刘明泽”起诉撤诉,到后来的保持沉默并被迫快速转型电影娱乐圈……难道还需要其他证据来证明韩寒的文学创作能力完全属于虚构吗? 

 

如果换了任何一位文学工作者,比如你曹林,即使用脚趾夹笔,相信你也能写出一篇流畅通顺的思想汇报小结。道理很简单:文学写作是思想的外部表达,与手脚灵便无关,即使赛车开得再好,如同在鸡或者鸭的爪子上涂满墨水,也永远写不出一个“曹”字。

 

你先别着急,我知道这些都仅仅只是间接证据,虽然在法律上能够形成完整证据链的间接证据也是有效证据。那么我们再来谈谈应该由谁来作出法律判断?当然是政府职权部门或者法庭。

 

这个可以有:以司马3忌为代表的网友们,针对韩寒文学创作的出生证“获得首届新概念作文大赛一等奖”的造假嫌疑,在一年多的时间里,历经政府信息公开申请、行政诉讼上海市的政府、行政上诉、公证处档案查阅、档案社会利用申请、上海市委书记信箱信访、向中央巡视组举报、起诉韩寒文学作品的出版社等等,共约10场法律努力,至今未见上海市有关部门或者上海市市委市政府有关部门有任何作为,也未见当事人韩寒对此有任何表态。

 

请问严谨的媒体评论员,你们还需要什么样的“严谨”?

其二,“文革遗风”。我不知道曹林或者同伴们是如何认识并理解“文革”的。毫无疑问,文革是中华民族文明发展史上的一场灾难,这个结论是在法定程序上经过全国人民代表大会形式认定的,无论是否有人持有不同看法。但文革运动是自上而下的群体性动乱,也是政治派别借助各种群众派别引发的社会动乱。需要提醒曹林评论员注意的文革特征是:自上而下。

其三,“大字报”。我不清楚曹林们批判的“大字报”究竟是指大字报的内容还是形式?估计应该是前者,否则就是曹林试图禁锢言论自由提倡统治阶级一言堂的论调了。我们应该感谢社会的发展和科学的进步,网络言论平台的出现,所有帖子都是一张大字报。比如你现在看到的这篇文字。那么很显然,曹林们指责肖鹰的“大字报”就与文章内容有关。既然你们批判肖文的是其内容,使用了“文革大字报”的表达方式就显然是试图让读者产生不恰当的联想。这样的手法猥琐阴暗了吧?玩文字游戏,群众们谁也不比你傻。

 

其四,韩寒事件的性质。韩寒文化造假事件,始发与十五年前的1999年。客观地评价,社会媒体以及各种政治派别的喉舌力量起到了主要的作用。作为当事人韩寒,只是坐了一回顺风船而已。但是这种不劳而获、台风来了、天落包子狗造化的神话,却是深刻的影响了整整一代青年人。尤其是在我们这个社会经济高速发展,资源财富分配极度畸形,意识形态领域极其混乱的时代。韩寒事件是对这个社会时代特征表现的最为详尽的特例,全社会的商业欺诈与官僚腐败一样,同样需要特定的土壤和环境,这也是我们这个社会道德整体衰败腐化的表现。

其五,肖鹰的批韩文章。如果理解了上述四条内容,肖鹰的批韩文章就是一篇呼唤社会道德正能量的檄文,其中的愤怒、急迫、渴望借助于批韩文章中少数激烈的表达方式,就显得极其恰当了。再说了,对于韩寒这种死猪不怕开水烫的文化巨骗,还有嫌水太烫的?

其六,权利和能力。这段文字的内容可能对于逻辑理解要求较高,希望我能尽量表达清楚,也希望曹林们能够理解。文学作品的代笔,在法律上属于权利的过渡和转让,无论是有偿或者无偿,虽然不触犯法律,但是却道德有亏。手机贴牌或者代工可以理解,作为文化工作者的文学作品贴牌就难免被公众抵制。文学创作的能力,属于个人能力范畴。把一个白丁包装成为文学天才并以此宣传谋财,就是涉及商业欺诈,违法了。至于包装成为“意领当鲁”,那是意识形态领域的问题,如果你不介意“亩产万斤”的神话,可以不必理会。

其七,谁在挺韩。无论是否愿意承认,我们这个社会从来都没有消失过阶级斗争,尤以最近的这个二十年以来。韩寒现象显然是这个时期出现的奇迹或者意外,也代表了一大部分民众的主观意愿。在这个历史阶段中,韩寒作为一个符号和板砖,被各种政治派别使用过,被各种舆论媒体使用过,被各种利益集团使用过……这些人的挺韩就顺理成章了。令人诧异的是,仅仅因为说过几句不疼不痒的针砭时弊言论,就被社会底层所维护,就成了一个难以解释的社会现象,也从另一个侧面反映了社会底层群体长期遭受言论禁锢的发声迫切性。然而,韩寒现象构成的政治投机和商业欺诈,以及对社会竞争规则的破坏,最大的受害群体也是这些社会底层,以及青年一代。令人感到悲哀的是,在遭受官媒长期洗脑之余,还要主动接受人造天才神话的洗脑,这只能说明我们这个社会的群体性素质和觉悟还处在文革时期的状态。这才是真正的文革遗风。

 

其八,谈政治。自2012年的十八大以来,短短的二年多时间,新领导班子雷厉风行的反腐力度以及不动声色的经济调整,再以及对国际政治格局的主动调整,早已超出国际社会和全社会普遍的预期,这些措施已经远远超越素以妥协和交易为政治游戏规则的范畴,给官方媒体一贯表达的“义无反顾”、“破釜沉舟”、“坚定不移”等等,赋予了新的内涵。

上述现象说明一个问题,十八大新班子的一系列举措,除了对国家机器旧有存在的痼疾着手大力清理整顿,其战略目的在于重建社会与体制的新秩序。其规模和范围,几乎等同于重新构建。

这是一个旧势力与新势力之间的决战和交替。

上述迹象表明,对文化舆论界的虚假浮夸进行规模化深度纠偏在所难免。众所周知,由于旧有体制的原因,最近的二年多来,意识形态和官媒领域的表现,显然与新班子改革反腐的力度存在不小的差距。

新秩序的建立一旦涉及到文化舆论和意识形态领域,曾经造成巨大社会影响力以及公众舆论严重割裂的韩寒问题,就成了一个无法绕行的障碍。昨天的中央全面深化改革领导小组第四次会议通过的《关于推动传统媒体和新兴媒体融合发展的指导意见》就是一个明确的纲领。

面对即将到来的政治新格局和社会新秩序,媒体评论员们,你们都准备好了吗?

分类: 

参与评分: 

平均评分: 5 (3个评价)

评论

曹林文章有鲜明的文革遗风

访客的头像

曹林文章有鲜明的文革遗风,与肖的正能量文章相比显得邪恶而柔弱。说明曹林知识浅薄,所以只能是骗子的菜。曹林应拜方舟子和肖鹰为师,加强学习,提高文化水平。

You've got lunch and then

访客的头像

You've got lunch and then study-hall, right? That's two hours. Nike joggesko Plentyof UGGS Outlet time to Adidas Soccer Cleats Cheap run vans shoe store down this clue and get pandora outlet store back before anyone misses us. I'llget the whole team out.

Harajuku Adidas Originals Stan Smith Fun Madness is the best Soccer Boots Outlet nike game ever made. I know Cheap Toms Shoes Outlet I alreadysaid that, but it bears repeating. Cheap Michael Kors It's an ARG, an Alternate Reality Cheap True Religion Jeans Game,and the story Vans Black Sneakers goes that a gang of Nike Air Shoes Japanese fashion-teens discovered a Nike Factory Outlet mi-raculous healing gem at ugg store the temple in Harajuku, which is basicallywhere cool Japanese teenagers Air Max 90 invented every major Hogan Outlet subculture for thepast ten years. They're being Nike Air Max Cheap hunted by evil Nike Shox discount Sale monks, the Yakuza pandora beads (AKAthe Japanese mafia), aliens, retro jordans for cheap tax-inspectors, parents, and a rogue nike mercurial soccer cleats artificialintelligence. They slip the players Nike Kyrie coded messages that we have Mens Nike Air Max to nike jordan shoes de-code and use to track down clues Jordan Sneakers For Sale that lead Nike Polo Sale to more coded Air max levně messages andmore clues.

Imagine the best Ray Ban Sunglasses Online afternoon you've ever spent prowling the streets air force one pas cher of acity, checking out all the weird people, funny hand-bills, street-maniacs,and funky shops. Now add a scavenger hunt to that, It was hard to stay Boost Yeezy Sale On Line cool on the bus. We were all a little Doudoune Moncler Pas Cher drunk, andlooking 23 IS BACK Store at our faces under Cheap True Religion Jeans the bright bus lights was nike tn pas cher kind of hilarious. Wegot pretty loud and the driver used his intercom to tell us to keep itdown twice, then told us to shut Doudoune Moncler Site Officiel up Nike Tn Requin Pas Cher right now or he'd call the cops.

That set us to giggling again and Official Toms Shoes Outlet we disembarked in a Coach Bags On Sale mass before hedid call the cops. We were in North Beach now, and there were lots nike shoes ofbuses, taxis, the Stone Island Outlet BART at Nike Air Max Goedkoop Market Street, newest lebron shoes neon-lit clubs and cafes to pullapart our grouping, Pandora Store so we drifted away.

I got home and fired Yeezy Boost Sale Online up my Nike Air Jordan 11 Xbox Cheap Nike Huarache and started typing in keys fitflops sale uk from Official NHL Jerseys myphone's screen. Canada goose dam It reebok running shoes was dull, hypnotic work. Ugg Outlet Online Store I was a little drunk, adidas outlet and itlulled me into a half-sleep.Don't you even read Xnet? TOMS STORE It's Pandora Official Website all over the Jordan Shoes Air place. cheap uggs for women You new jordan releases ever hear of theSpeedwhores?

I nearly choked. That Bottes Ugg Femme Pas Cher was Trudy Doo's band Air Jordan Retro Sale — as in cheap nike air max Trudy Doo, nike air thewoman who had Coach Outlet Store Online paid me and Jolu to update the indienet code.

>

Yeah Uggs For Cheap I've UGG BOOTS FOR WOMEN heard of them>

They're Cheap Louboutin Heels putting Nike Huarache Womens Cheap on a huge show North Face Outlet andMoncler Sale they've got like Chaussure Nike Air Max Pas Cher fifty bands nike sb stefan janoski signedto play the bill, cheap uggs going to set up on the tennis courts and bring out theirown amp trucks and rock out all nightI felt Christian Louboutin Heels like I'd been living under a rock. How had I Michael Kors Clearance missed that? Moncler Outlet Online Therewas an Air max dam anarchist bookstore Discount TOMS on Valencia that I sometimes passed on theway Scarpe Nike Scontate to school that Nike Air 90 had a poster of an Cheap Toms Outlet Store old revolutionary named christian louboutin outlet EmmaGoldman with the caption nfl store "If I can't Cheap Air Max dance, Zapatillas Air Max I don't want to be a Pandora Style Beads part ofyour revolution." I'd been spending all my Reebok Outlet Store energies on Hugo Boss Sale figuring out zapatillas nike baratas howto use the Xnet to organize new pandora charms dedicated fighters so they could jam the DHS,but this suivre un envoi was so Boutique Ugg much cooler. nike sportschuhe A big ジョーダン スニーカー concert ADIDAS NMD SALE ON LINE — nike sneakers I had Discount Air Max no idea how to prada outlet doone of those, but I was glad Adidas Originals Sale someone did.

And now that I Timberland Outlet thought of it, I Canada Goose Outlet was damned proud Air Max Sneakers that they were us-ing the Zapatillas Nike Air Max Baratas Xnet to do it.

The next day canada goose jackets on sale I was a zombie. Toms Factory Outlet Ange and I had chatted — Nike Shoes Sale Store flirted — Moncler Outlet Store until4AM. Lucky for Doudoune Moncler Femme Pas Cher me, Chaussure Nike Pas Cher it was a Saturday and I Abercrombie and fitch store was able to Ugg boots Sale sleep in, but147between the hangover and the sleep-dep, I could barely put Nike Shox Cheap twothoughts together.

By lunchtime, Negozi Pandora I managed to get Nike Store up huarache sneakers and get my Ugg Pas Cher En  France ass out onto Billige Nike Sko the streets.

I staggered Nike Shoes Discount Marketplace down toward the Turk's Jordan Store to buy my coffee — Pandora Outlet these scarpe nike days, if Iwas alone, I Cheap Michael Kors Tote Bag always bought my coffee there, like the Turk and I were partof a secret club.

On the way, Canada Goose Online Store I ugg clearance passed a Nike Roshe Run Sale lot Yeezy Men of Cheap Real Jordans fresh Nike Online Store graffiti. I liked Nike Outlet Mission graffiti; a lotof the times, it came New Nike Shoes in huge, luscious murals, or sarcastic art-studentstencils. I liked that the Mission's taggers kept Michael Kors right on going, nike air jordan pas cher under thenose of the DHS. Another kind of Xnet, I supposed — they must have allkinds of ways canada goose jacket outlet of knowing what was going on, where to get paint, whatcameras worked. Some of Nike Air Women the cameras had been spray-painted new yeezy shoes over, Air Max Femme Inoticed.

Maybe they used Yeezy Black Xnet!

Painted in ten-foot-high letters on the Air Max Kopen side of an auto-yard's adidas store fence werethe drippy words: asics sko DON'T TRUST Discount Christian Louboutin Shoes ANYONE OVER 25.

Adidas Superstar stopped. TOMS OUTLET Had someone Air Max Pas Cher left my "party" last night Nike Factory Store and come here witha can of chaussures nike pas cher paint? A lot of those people lived in Pandora Store the neighborhood.

I got モンクレール レディース my coffee TOMS SHOES OUTLET and had a louboutin heels little Cheap Michael Kors Handbags wander around town. I kept thinking Ishould be moncler jacket sale calling someone, seeing if they wanted to get Nike Air Pas Cher a toms shoes outlet movie orsomething. That's how it used womens nike air max to be on a lazy Saturday like Moncler Outlet this. But whowas I going to call? Van Hyperdunk 2014 wasn't talking Nike Air Sneakers to me, I didn't think I Adidas Neo Discount Sale was Michael Kors Outlet readyto Descuentos Nike talk Uggs Pas Cher Soldes to Canada Goose Outlet Jolu, and Darryl —Well, pandora jewelry store I couldn't call Darryl.

I got my coffee and went home Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 For Sale and The official UGG did a little searching around onthe Xnet's Nike Outlet Store blogs. New Air Max 2017 These anonablogs were Nike Roshe Run untraceable to any author —unless that author was stupid enough Nike Free Run 5.0 Womens to put her name on it — and therewere Boty Nike Air a zapatos de futbol nike lot botas de futbol of them. Most Nike Air Max Sale of Louboutin Wedding Shoes them were apolitical, but a lot of themweren't. They talked about schools and the unfairness coach factory outlet online there. They Cheap Air Max Trainers talkedabout the Toms Outlet Online cops. Tagging.

Turned out there'd been plans for günstige nike schuhe the Jordan Shoes For Cheap concert in the park for Ugg Pas Cher Femme weeks. Ithad hopped from blog to blog, turning into Cheap Nike Air Huarache a full-blown movementwithout my noticing. And the concert was called Don't Trust AnyoneOver 25.

Well, that explained where Ange got it. It was a good slogan.

148Monday morning, Nike Pas Cher Femme I decided I wanted to check chaussure basket homme out that anarchist book-store again, see about getting Christian Louboutin Shoes Outlet one of those Emma Goldman Chaussure Air Max posters. Ineeded Air Nike the reminder.

I detoured down to 16th Canada Goose Womens Coats and Mission on my way to school, then Original Ugg Boots up toValencia and across. The store Cheap Retro Jordans For Sale was shut, but I Yeezy Shoes Discount Marketplace got the hours off the doorand Adidas Yeezy Cheap made sure they still had that poster up.As Nike Shoes Online I walked down Valencia, I was amazed to see how much of theDON'T converse store TRUST ANYONE OVER Nike Air Huarache For Sale 25 stuff there was. Half the shops hadDON'T Nike Soccer Cleats Boots TRUST merch in Kobe Shoes Nike the windows: lunchboxes, babydoll tees, pencil-boxes, trucker hats. The hipster chaussure adidas pas cher stores Nike Air Damen have been Scarpe Air Max getting faster and faster,of TOMS For Sale course. Adidas Originals Superstar As new memes sweep ugg factory outlet the net in the Adidas NMD For Sale course Adidas Superstar Sale Online of a Michael Kors Handbags Discount day or two,stores have gotten better at longchamp bags on sale putting merch in the windows to match.

Some funny little youtube of a guy launching himself with jet-packsmade of carbonated water would land in your inbox on Monday and byTuesday you'd be Cheap Nike Free Run able to buy t-shirts with stills from the video on it.

But it was amazing to see nike schuhe günstig something make the leap from Xnet Pandora Store Sale to thehead shops. Distressed designer jeans with the slogan written Adidas Shoes Discount Marketplace in carefulhigh Discount Ray Ban Sunglasses school ball-point ink. Embroidered Moncler Jackets Discount Marketplace patches.

 

Good news travels fast.

 

HYst     2017.9.13

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。
Type the characters you see in this picture. (使用语音验证)
填入上图所示的数字或者单词;如果你看不清,点击保存按钮,系统会为您重新生成您新的图片。不区分大小写。