七、对韩寒博客的质疑 ---- 作者:sleepwhile

韩寒早期的博客文章,尤其是2005年2月开博到2006年2月的博文,大都是一些记录日常生活的流水账,不仅毫无思想、文采可言,而且语无伦次、文笔很差,比普通中学生的水平尚有不如(这些博文已从新浪删除)。而他后期的时评类博文却受到广泛欢迎,为他赢得了“意见领袖”的盛名。

根据之前介绍的代笔证据,我们现在已经很清楚韩寒不具备基本的写作能力。他博文前后期的巨大反差和割裂正是其博客存在代笔的直观反映。尽管如此,为了彻底揭开韩寒骗局的内幕,质疑者自始至终在孜孜不倦地挖掘线索、分析材料,力求获得更有说服力的证据。

 

代笔事件爆发之初,麦田的第一篇文章《人造韩寒:一场关于“公民”的闹剧》就详述了韩寒的博客代笔疑云。他判断韩寒的博客成名是出版商路金波一手策划的。据麦田推测,2008年左右路金波对韩寒作出包装定位,让韩寒走上时政分析的道路,一步步打造出“一个受到政府迫害的天才的帅哥”的形象。

麦田的这一推测并不是纯粹凭空臆想,而是根据公开资料进行推论。他首先列出韩寒2005至2011年博客文章时政类占比数据,论证韩寒博客文章从2008年开始发生“突变”:时政内容占比突然从百分之十几激增到百分之五十左右,并且前后文风相差极大。接着又列出韩寒赛车和博客时间比对表,论证韩寒有13篇文章的发表时间与其赛车比赛日程重叠,从而质疑韩寒博客存在代笔。他还注意到路金波曾自豪地对记者说过:“我希望饶雪漫走商业化的路线,韩寒就去竖牌坊做知识分子。他们俩绝不是女生版、男生版的划分,而是一个经济一个政治”。

麦田的这一论证(写作与比赛日程冲突)在论战初始阶段被韩寒的“你做不到,我却做到了”顶了回去。但麦田关于韩寒“一边是宅男模式,一边是竞技状态,在比赛周怎么能被统一?”的立论依然有相当的逻辑合理性:问题不在于韩寒能否立刻写出几千字,而是在比赛期如何极度关注网络时事,广泛浏览资料,快速反应。

 

方舟子起初也只是指出韩寒早期博文文笔拙劣,不过后来他发现韩寒博客文章《写给张国荣》中的蹊跷,打开了质疑的另一个缺口。2012年4月1日,韩寒在新浪微博转了其博客文章《写给张国荣》,方舟子意识到这篇文章其实在此前10天左右早已登在京东网《光明与磊落》(韩寒《三重门》手稿集)的介绍上,并且发现先前的版本(京东版)与韩寒在微博和博客上发布的版本(微博版)相比有很多改动,改正了很多病句、错字和标点符号,是一个修改完善版。

这就让人感到奇怪了。既然已经有了一个经过润色的“京东版”,韩寒为什么却发布了一个存在较多错误的“微博版”呢?如果我们排除《光明与磊落》的出版社编辑进行修改的可能性(编辑作出如此众多改动的话,通常都会取得作者的确认),那么最大的可能就是《写给张国荣》是某人代笔,而韩寒发表博客时不知道文章已经作过修改,误发了较早的版本。

除了方舟子的研究,韩寒发布的几乎每一篇博文都会被网友放在放大镜下细细观察,博文中各类穿帮和胡编乱造也被一一指出。网友“五岭山人”发现一个代笔证据:韩寒的博文《儿童的节》发表于2012年6月1日上午9点,而当时韩寒正在参加CTCC中国房车锦标赛珠海站比赛试车。

 

最惊心动魄的质疑证据出现在2012年11月16日。在“勤劳十点”、“eprom”等大量网友的辛勤努力下,发现了韩寒博文《谈革命》为代笔之作的“终极铁证”。

这条证据是这样的:《谈革命》是韩寒发表于2011年12月23日06:09:34的一篇论政博文,曾引起强烈反响。但是网友发现在韩仁均的博客上(该博客ID是fjfh6602,此前没有人知道是韩仁均的博客)《谈革命》一文发表于2011年12月23日05:28,竟然比韩寒还早41分钟!

确认这个事实以后,留给韩寒狡辩的余地就很小了。韩寒可能存在的辩解包括:一、误用韩仁均的电脑,发错了博客;二、韩寒拜托父亲代发博客,而韩仁均误操作发到自己博客上。但这两个辩驳都难以成立。原因如下:关于第一条,韩仁均fjfh6602博客比韩寒博客先发博文的事前后出现过三次,除了《谈革命》还有另外两篇(博文《2012年01月08日》和一句话博文“这我也没办法,手快有,手慢无”),所以不太可能是偶然事故;关于第二条,韩仁均曾经说起他在韩寒发表《谈革命》以后打电话给韩寒询问为什么该文取了一个很大的名字,说明他事先并不知情。

结合其他一些旁证,我们可以进一步确定这确实是一条有力的代笔证据。

第一、两个版本的《谈革命》有多处不同(即文章被改动过),fjfh6602版有一句话“历史曾经给过中国机会,如今的局面则是我们父辈的选择”中“父辈”两个字被改成“爷辈”,正说明《谈革命》的原作者和韩寒差了一辈。这就叫欲盖弥彰。

第二、上述三篇首发于韩仁均博客的“韩寒博文”发表时间分别为2011年11月、12月和2012年1月。而韩寒博客在2011年10月16日出现了一篇奇怪的博文,只有两个字:测试。到底在测试什么?一个合理的推测是:韩寒博客的作者换了人,而这个人对使用韩寒博客还不熟悉,所以先发了个测试帖。这就解释了为什么fjfh6602博客和韩寒博客穿帮的问题全部出现在2011年10月以后。

 

fjfh6602博客穿帮被发现以后,网友顺藤摸瓜,发现了一个吊诡的“人人爱人杰”事件。

所谓的“人杰”是指2006年上海卫视《加油!好男儿》中的选手沈人杰(上海赛区第三名),他的粉丝叫做“戒指”。沈人杰和韩寒在2006年曾经发生了一场骂战。

2006年的11月8日,ID为“人人爱人杰”的网友在天涯发了一个帖子:

『娱乐八卦』[灰常点评]韩寒这个小人要借沈人杰提高自己的名气,戒指们要团结起来

他凭什么这么说我们人杰,还不是吸引人去看他的博克,他的粉丝有我们戒指多吗,这个可怜的小人,写的东西没有人看,要借我们家人杰上位。说到底还不是妒忌吗,看不得别人红吗。戒指们一定要相信人杰。我们粉丝也要理智,不要再给他添麻烦了!!!

就是说沈人杰的粉丝为了支持自己的偶像发帖骂韩寒。当然,真实的情况没有那么简单。由于一次“天涯论坛用户资料密码泄露”事件,现在网上有一个专门的网站可以查询天涯用户资料是否丢失。打开这个网站,输入“fjfh6602”——我们看到的是“人人爱人杰”的天涯用户资料,其邮箱是fjfh6602@sina.com(韩仁均的邮箱)。这个事实说明,韩寒的父亲韩仁均在天涯论坛注册了马甲账号“人人爱人杰”,惟妙惟肖地模仿歌星粉丝的语气,骂韩寒是“这个可怜的小人”。

这一事件的曝光,不仅暴露了韩仁均低下的人品,而且让我们知道了他熟悉网络语言和文化,善于变换自己的文风模拟青年人,绝不是韩寒口中所谓“我的父亲在我们当地出了名的清高迂腐混不开”。那么如果说韩仁均的另一个身份是韩寒背后的傀儡操纵者,就不是那样让人难以理解的事情了。

 

韩寒博客的真正作者到底是谁?

方舟子在分析了韩寒的博客以后,认为该博客存在几个不同的写作阶段,每个阶段的作者不同:2005年10月~2006年11月这段最早的一批博文,语句不通、文笔拙劣、内容粗鄙,可确定是韩寒本人手笔;2006年11月之后博客开始逐步出现出彩的时评类博文,是团队(可能是路金波组织的)写作的产物;2010年7月起博文发表频率突然明显减少,可能是其写作团队此时解散;2011年10月16日出现了一个奇怪的帖子,只有两个字“测试”,此后文风也随之改变,这段时间的作者可推测为韩仁均。

不过,关于韩寒的代笔者,网友“聪明的一叔”有不同见解。他确信为韩寒代笔的只有一人,是盲人歌手周云蓬。他首先分析了韩寒的小说,发现其中许多人生经历和文字痕迹与周云蓬发生密切联系,例如作者不会开车、隐含的地道东北话,韩寒作品与周云蓬小传《歌者夜行》的内在联系等。此外,他认为“咱”这个词的使用习惯和“不注意标点符号”的习惯是周云蓬为韩寒代笔的标志性特征。根据这些特征,再结合其他语言习惯,“聪明的一叔”提出“韩三篇”实为“周三篇”,韩寒博客的代笔者也是周云蓬。

 

这个分歧暂时还无法得到完满解答,可以存疑。但韩寒代笔骗局的事实是没有疑问的,韩寒本人写不出像样的文章,他的几乎所有作品和博客上有一定文采的博文,都是代笔之作。而他在一片质疑声中仍旧穿着看不见的新衣大摇大摆地前行,拖着美丽下摆的大臣和奴仆也亦步亦趋。这是我们正在面对的艰难现状。我们要追问到底,质疑到底。

 

韩寒早期博客文章:

韩寒博客备份2005年~2010年(韩寒)

韩寒2006~2007博客选(韩寒)

 

麦田对韩寒博客文章的质疑:

人造韩寒:一场关于“公民”的闹剧 (麦田)

三重疑——兼答韩仁均韩寒路金波诸君,喔,还有范冰冰 (麦田)

 

韩寒博客文章穿帮:

韩寒《写给张国荣》版本分析 (方舟子)

为什么《儿童的节》自己删了 (五岭山人)

 

fjfh6602博客事件和“人人爱人杰”事件:

“韩三篇”为韩仁均所写的铁证(方舟子)

韩仁均fjfh6602博客,要圆谎,只有三种情况,全是死路 (诗人小郑)

韩寒父亲韩仁均冒充沈人杰粉丝去号召粉丝们去韩寒的博客骂他 (eprom)

韩仁均怎样“戴戒指”弄韩寒(倍魄)

 

韩寒博客代笔者探究:

韩寒博客文章的真实作者是谁?(方舟子)

署名韩寒的作品到底是谁代笔的  (聪明的一叔)

 
 
 
 
 

分类: 

参与评分: 

平均评分: 5 (3个评价)

评论

Air Max 90 pas cher Fitflop

Follow Shoes Studies Adidas

Darlene Goodwin的头像

Follow Shoes Studies Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 white about up-dates seeing that both ones approaching DT o96s are typically timetabled to show up out of thest district with upcoming economic calendar year; let you be aware that you Adidas Yeezy Boost 750 merely would like getting found further of your selected Volt-accented difference as soon as the particular rebound listed below.A variety of ones sneaker Air Griffey Potential Yeezy Boost 750 colour indicates released within the earlier Four several years are already with each other together with GS types.The machine washable canvas exterior is usually hand-crafted along with beads and checked to Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 help keep the bigger penetration of workmanship through an antiskid outside singular to avoid glides along with falls. Your punctured leather Dryz? sole obtaining the Latex Polyurethane foam? assimilates Adidas Yeezy Boost 950 respiration switching them directly into Yeezy Boost 550 teeth whitening gel as well as the healthful realtors within the memory foam affect smell resulting in bacteria. The actual innovative breathing method which usually Adidas Yeezy 350 Boost includes this kind of sole with all the simplicity of breathing pockets allows enables a launch of air flow that draws away perspiring. All these respiration gaps aren't coming in contact with the earth exactly the outside fresh air to Yeezy Boost promote air movement.One entire world well-known man or woman Automatic Guevara moreover aid running shoe shoe atmosphere Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 zebra utmost Tennessee, shoe Air Max Tennessee shoes photo simply would not let him end up being still did not try to remember. Car Guevara can be Argentine Marxist Yeezy 750 Boost innovative, politician, writer, health care professional, affiliate marketer theorist and also guerrilla director.When Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 cream your dish-washing unit pattern is carried out, take away the shoes immediately. If your sneakers possess any variety of scum Adidas Yeezy Boost in it, cautiously sweep them back together with the electric toothbrush. Or no type of areas won't be as clean as you would definitely just like Yeezy Boost 350 v2 kids clean the place while using toothbrush.While the particular images regarding furniture, home appliances, and various other residence add-ons to the Annabelle american girl doll homes retaining wall surface area graphics are generally definitely lovely, some customers mention they can be well not Yeezy Boost 350 v2 required. For instance, the top place retaining wall decal incorporates a metal base photograph once the employee home furniture set up provides a Adidas Yeezy Boost 550 canopied mattress.The as soon as easy boot possesses innovative about periods winding up currently being considerably more extraordinary. Yeezy Boost 350 v2 cream And also gifted creative designers possess basically viewed its inventive fashion sense into your modern Ugg boot Nightfall. Founded in Adidas Yeezy 750 Boost reasons for training large, this particular higher diploma boot design and style is usually portrayed that has a fringe of tempting parallel confronted Yeezy Boost 350 v2 zebra degree together with the appealing but sensible shoelaces for extra layout. Accessible in an assortment of colors in addition to sizes, these are excellent to establish Adidas Yeezy Boost your current clothes alight. And the appearance of your range of Ugg boot nightfall using smaller green tea outfit or perhaps with thin skinny jeans will likely be preferred this coming year. Decide on http://www.yeezyboost350v2zebras.com/ a set in ones perfect measurement and also favorite cover Yeezy Boost 950 from the sun and you'll manifest as a brain turner making about green with envy in addition to admiring little brown eyes.The Michael went bonkers pattern seemed to be the original to offer Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 black the absolutely apparent rearfoot Fresh air gadget that was evident within the back bone together with around the attributes, plus the '95 unit appeared to be Yeezy Boost 350 v2 white your initial to feature seen forefoot Atmosphere.This sneaker is undoubtedly one of the most renowned jogging shoes from the Nike jordan http://www.yeezyboost750shoes950.com/ set. It attained the following status any time Michael recorded this 10 rating headline and also very Yeezy 350 v2 first ever twin three-peat. He or she did this specific all over their Other common period of time while wearing these sneakers.

MYY

访客的头像

MYY

 

only nike schoenen at air max one golden state warriors jersey point hermes bags in polo ralph lauren outlet online the ed hardy clothing world.Heart stephen curry shoes level, the bears jerseys world air jordan retro will be coach factory shop flat. new balance Learn asics to lunette ray ban give ray ban wayfarer others the air max opportunity. knockoff handbags Rank memphis grizzlies jersey and ralph lauren polo honor, air huarache like valentino outlet a nike air max cloud adidas superstar in the adidas sky, louboutin shoes can not adidas.se lie in, hollister clothing store lie texans jerseys down michael kors bags and prada outlet overhauled air max 2015 fell oakley sunglasses down. pandora canada When rolex watches you speak, birkenstock shoes you barbour outlet say, michael kors canada we must be more valuable north face than ray ban sunglasses outlet silence. indoor soccer shoes Be north face sad wise, it christian louboutin shoes is air max better air jordan shoes to tommy hilfiger be ralph lauren a michael kors uk happy cowboys jerseys fool! I nike roshe want mcm backpack to be marc by marc jacobs God burberry outlet in ralph lauren outlet online order dansko outlet to christian louboutin have, cheap michael kors but azcardinals jerseys I oklahoma city thunder jersey can only michael kors taschen give buccaneers jerseys up saints jerseys to become washington wizards jersey God. boots on sale No free running matter how brooklyn nets jerseys hard it ralph lauren outlet seems to skechers pursue, fred perry outlet there air max is vans outlet always something mcm bags you coach outlet online have barbour jackets outlet to give nike shoes up, the north face outlet there is longchamp handbags always chicago bulls jersey something jordans you can true religion jeans only miss, nike air max there are air yeezy shoes always longchamp taschen only a giuseppe zanotti sneakers dream. michael kors outlet online sale There is cheap oakley no dsquared2 absolute nike air max justice, beats headphones equity nike outlet only bottega veneta at one point tommy hilfiger in converse outlet the world. pandora bracelet Heart jordan retro level, the glasses frames world jaguars jerseys will iphone case be roshe run flat. soccer shoes Learn cheap michael kors to celine bags give coach outlet online others san antonio spurs jerseys the timberland shoes opportunity. Rank mcm backpack outlet and ralph lauren outlet honor, soccer shoes outlet like nike air max 90 a watches canada cloud in the replica watches sky, red bottoms can not hollister online lie marc by marc jacobs in, polo outlet store lie fossil uhren down burberry outlet and coach factory overhauled new balance fell down. swarovski australia When jimmy choo shoes you handbags outlet speak, burberry outlet you hogan outlet say, we must mcm handbags be more michael kors purses valuable adidas online than cheap nfl jerseys silence. Be sad redskins jerseys wise, nike free 5.0 it woolrich outlet is better converse shoes to minnesota timberwolves jersey be nike shoes a rolex watch happy birkenstock deutschland fool!Men prada outlet are most roshe run afraid katespade of fivefingers doubt, women beats by dre are most nike.se afraid of givenchy outlet suspicion. Something burberry handbags was swarovski online wrong oakley sungalsses outlet not gafas oakley bumpy ferragamo shoes road, ray-ban sunglasses but the huarache heart of chargers jerseys the packers jerseys doubt; some love new balance outlet to chiefs jerseys go, not oakley sunglasses outlet the rayban face oakley of tommy hilfiger outlet beauty oakley sunglasses cheap and puma online ugliness, north face jackets but ralph lauren the converse sneakers heart michael kors bags of michael kors outlet the fidget spinner outlet do oakley vault other longchamp outlet things skechers outlet to nike roshe do. milwaukee bucks jersey Women nike tn complain to nike air force each other reebok too northface little, barbour factory just ray bans because nfl jerseys you hoodies give him los angeles clippers jersey too louboutin much. bcbg max So, nba jerseys you hollister kids do wholesale clothing not dallas mavericks jerseys always feel katespade that cheap oakley he tory burch too ray ban sunglasses lightly. atlanta hawks jerseys Maybe burberry sale you michael jordan just oakley outlet always nike shoes put veneta him north face backpacks too seriously.The cause of indiana pacers jersey the coach outlet online pain is pandora charms that nike shoes outlet the hollister clothing differences juicy couture handbags become larger, compatible portland trail blazers jersey with coach factory outlet each burberry online shop other michael kors in kate spade outlet online two broncos jerseys stages giuseppe shoes to michael kors outlet online sale meet birkenstock outlet people swarovski jewelry over nike schuhe time, nike shoes is not found giants jerseys each nike shop other hollister kids towards lacoste shoes the christian louboutin shoes same longchamp outlet direction, adidas superstar only michael kors one vans shoes stage nike mercurial vapor is rolex compatible on a wide ferragamo shoes crossroad denver nuggets jerseys accidentally mont blanc superimposed michael kors outlet online together. lakers jerseys - longchamp Alain juicy couture outlet de Botton "fell michael kors in adidas online love oakley sunglasses outlet with swarovski the oakley sunglasses romantic" burberry outlet just want babyliss pro to have adidas canada personal, I nike free run said toronto raptors jersey nothing prada shoes at prada sunglasses the time, adidas superstar knew puma outlet I ray ban zonnebril was swarovski jewelry not jerseys from china really nfl jerseys right; to abercrombie have barbour jackets personal, replica watches keep coach store a louboutin shoes smile new york knicks when fendi handbags I coach purses outlet online know the north face I'm heat jerseys not nike huarache really oakley outlet happy. I coach outlet store online want ravens jerseys to michael kors outlet online be michael kors God softball bats in skechers order detroit pistons to [b][/b] have, philipp plein outlet but I omega watches can only barbour outlet give polo ralph up chi hair to air max schoenen become hugo boss shop God. michael kors canada No hogan outlet matter nike outlet how oakley vault hard true religion outlet it hermes belt seems hermes to oakley canada pursue, thomas sabo uk there steelers jerseys is utah jazz jersey always pandora something longchamp outlet you polo ralph lauren have ray ban outlet to [b][/b] give ferragamo shoes uk up, michael kors outlet there sacramento kings jersey is new balance always raiders jerseys something michael kors outlet online sale you new balance canada can only colts jerseys miss, mbt shoes outlet there nike air jordan are ray bans always fitflop outlet only seahawks jerseys a dream. supra footwear There philadelphia 76ers jerseys is long champ no ecco outlet absolute justice, equity michael kors concerns. Even thomas sabo the ray ban best burberry sale eyes can glasses online not see where there chi flat iron is bengals jerseys need jerseys from china to observe ponder; ralph lauren outlet even boston celtics jersey the best tracksuits store ear burberry sale has cheap ray ban not cheap true religion heard new orleans pelicans jersey when the houston rockets jerseys need panthers jerseys to cheap oakley sunglasses listen coach outlet to beats by dr dre understand. Suspected ray ban wayfarer heart salvatore ferragamo must rayban not ray ban outlet love ralph lauren beauty, coach factory outlet love is hogan not pandora necessarily sweet. Men eagles jerseys also 49ers jerseys have tory burch outlet fragile will nike.dk cry, need true religion jeans women to nike air max thea understand women; ray ban occhiali women coach outlet online also baseball jerseys have responsibilities falcons jerseys Kulei busy, michael kors needs michael kors outlet a baseball bats man polo ralph lauren outlet to purses and handbags love. plein shoes Mutual true religion jeans outlet understanding red bottom shoes and lunette ray ban considerate, ray ban sonnenbrillen give montre homme peace north face outlet a heart reloj to browns jerseys love rams jerseys a bcbg max azria peaceful. the north face Family, jerseys from china only ralph lauren harmonious; life, only coach outlet canada happiness.People, ferragamo a nike store margin: nike air max shoes heart to heart, under armour shoes that ralph lauren factory store honesty. purses and handbags Do calvin klein underwear not dsquared2 sale test oakley sunglasses the heart, oakley frogskins do not air jordan casually mcm backpack suspicion cheap basketball shoes of burberry outlet online a converse chucks situation. lions jerseys Do tommy hilfiger outlet stores not wait titans jerseys misunderstood, www.tommyhilfiger.nl I realized understand true religion valuable; michael kors outlet online do oakley not timberland boots wait coach black friday to hilfiger online shop regret, coach factory and ralph lauren outlet only ralph lauren outlet know the north face how vans schuhe to cherish supra footwear cute; do prada not instyler ionic styler wait to jets jerseys lose, roshe run to armani outlet recognize own cola. baseball jerseys Some jimmy choo outlet treasure, versace outlet online only the sincere; dolphins jerseys be baseball jerseys understood nike free 5.0 that levis jeans only the salomon schuhe worthy. long champ Most hollisterco people moving timberland femme is jordan release dates 2015 not sweet, omega watches eachother, but dre beats some michael kors v?skor people patriots jerseys believe vikings jerseys you pandora schmuck have been nike air max with bills jerseys you. zapatillas nike Love need jerseys from china to polo ralph understand, charlotte hornets jerseys we need burberry outlet online to nike free 5.0 cherish orlando magic jersey love; tommy hilfiger online life will be colorful, mizuno wave life ray bans outlet will phoenix suns jersey be asics gel pretty ralph lauren polos spectacular.People iphone 5s cases living nike roshe longer and [b][/b] want burberry to ralph lauren outlet online understand. Life cleveland cavaliers in rolex watches for sale the oakley world, fred perry polos whether you nike air max are swarovski crystal civilians, or great timberland outlet nobles, all escape the troubles chrome hearts

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。
Type the characters you see in this picture. (使用语音验证)
填入上图所示的数字或者单词;如果你看不清,点击保存按钮,系统会为您重新生成您新的图片。不区分大小写。