大公与小私——谈@梁文道 的巧言令色 by 司马3忌

梁文道身上的标签很多,大大小小十多个,看上去像极了浑身贴满品牌的运动员。不过,最为引人注目估计就是时政评论员和访谈节目主持人了。

因此,当梁文道在最近的签售新书见面会上,对韩寒事件的表态,着实让我们吓了一跳:

“对于韩寒是否存在代笔,我的看法是这样的,我对韩寒的称赞,是对一个作者的称赞,不是因为他长得有点帅、又会赛车,只是觉得他杂文写得好,我很喜欢。至于是韩寒本人在写,或者背后有一个团队在写,又或者是他的爸爸在写,我觉得并不是太重要。”

历时二年多的韩寒事件过程中,类似的观点相当具有代表性,也是韩寒粉丝最为喜欢的盾牌:“韩寒是否代笔无关紧要,如同只要鸡蛋好吃,没有必要去过问母鸡是谁。”还有著名画家陈丹青的豪言:“当然我非常喜欢韩寒,我一点不关心他抄袭不抄袭,我根本不相信他会抄袭。如果有一天说这个文章是他爸爸写的,我连他爸爸一起喜欢。”

这些逻辑混乱的观点原本不值一驳,原因在于,前者多为先天性脑残,如同前些日子愿为柯震东卖淫赎身的偶像粉丝。后者是画家,有成就艺术家嘛,天生具有精神分裂和神经质,不奇怪的。

而梁文道是指点江山、剖析社会的时政评论家,能公开说出这样小私的言论,还是令人感到吃惊。

因为梁文道偷换了概念:所谓文学作品,不外乎是作者以语言为工具来反映社会和生活,表达作者对人生、社会的认识和情感,并且始终伴随着作者强烈的感情活动。文字作品的主要作用,是让读者透过作者的观察和理解,去间接的了解故事或社会事件或者政治主张。由此可见,文字作品与鸡蛋之类的物质商品在抽象性延展价值上具有显著的区别。

其次,文学作品创作署名权的不可让渡,决定了文学作品内容和质量与作者社会名誉的不可分割性,也具有赋予作者社会影响力和公信力的巨大影响。虽然这对于具体的读者个体来说,影响并不显著,然而对于社会整体,就赋予了作者高度的经济溢价。

第三,文学代笔,且不谈难以量化的道德问题,但确是实实在在的破坏了社会活动的公序良俗。“韩寒是不是一个骗子,我并不太关心”。你当然有权毫不关心,如同目睹地铁巴士上剪络的窃贼,不阻止不报警佯装不知哪怕做个范跑跑,但你总不至于冠冕堂皇、理直气壮的以此自我标榜?更何况你梁文道还是以时政评论家著称。

评论时政的时候,你从环球到两岸,大公至正如龙在天;评论自我的时候,却巧言令色与己无关,小私毕露如芥入地。显见的如同王朔描述的“嗷嗷乱叫和闷头刨食”。

梁文道最后提到了红楼梦的作者是谁也不影响这部优秀文学作品问题,连我这个文学外行都哭笑不得:如果脱离了作者曹雪芹的时代烙印和社会背景,别说是否优秀,恐怕你梁文道连是否能够读懂都是一个问题。

至于文字作品的作者究竟是否值得关注,至少我不会相信梁文道会为自己的儿子代写情书,尽管梁文道的某个未来媳妇也许并不关注这封情书的作者究竟是谁?

虽然我们都相信梁文道的情书想必也一定是写得极好的。


 

附:梁文道谈韩寒 2014/08/23

链接:http://chuansongme.com/n/646663

 

一问关键词“韩寒”

你能谈一下对韩寒的看法吗?

梁文道我觉得韩寒是一个非常聪明、杂文写得很漂亮的年轻人,在年轻人中间很有影响力,因为他的那些写作语言、写作方式说出了他们(年轻人)的世界,这是非常难得的一件事情。

虽然韩寒的杂文写得很漂亮,但小说我觉得就比较普通了,当然这也不是他一个人的问题,杂文写得好的人普遍有这个问题。因为杂文写作很强调语言上面的戏剧效果,杂文作家在写文章、写时事评论的时候,你会觉得他每句话都在翻跟头、踩高跷,我觉得韩寒也是这样,其实这并不是一个很坏的问题,但问题是韩寒在写小说的时候也把这个带进去了,就让我觉得整个小说“穿”掉了,因为每个角色说话都是那么“聪明”。

韩寒这几年面对的那些争论,说实话,我一直都没有搞懂过。也有朋友骂过我,因为我夸过韩寒,而他们认为他是一个骗子,甚至还有一句话说“韩寒的成功是中国知识分子的堕落,而我们(中国知识分子)的堕落是国耻,所以(韩寒的成功)是中国的堕落”。

对于韩寒是否存在代笔,我的看法是这样的,我对韩寒的称赞,是对一个作者的称赞,不是因为他长得有点帅、又会赛车,只是觉得他杂文写得好,我很喜欢。至于是韩寒本人在写,或者背后有一个团队在写,又或者是他的爸爸在写,我觉得并不是太重要。譬如,有一天红楼梦的作者被考证出来是一个,两个或者三个,那又怎么样呢,它不会影响红楼梦是一本优秀的著作这件事本身。

所以,我不太关心韩寒这个人背后的事情,我只在乎写杂文的这个叫韩寒的人写得怎么样,这个写作的人是不是一个好人,是不是一个骗子,我并不太关心。

分类: 

参与评分: 

平均评分: 5 (9个评价)

评论

某日,梁文道替还是处男的儿子写了一封求爱信

访客的头像

某日,梁文道替还是处男的儿子写了一封求爱信,信中言尽床上之能事这可是梁大师几十年之宝贵经验。该女看罢直呼:“哇塞!此乃天下第一淫信,能得此之性福非神仙也”。有闺密提醒,一小屁孩怎能写出如此经验之谈,怕是其父代笔的吧,女曰:代笔又何妨,只要写的符合我已就行,小的不行老的可以代替上来,只要性福管他是谁呢。

梁文道只是一开始误以为韩寒是文学天才

夜雨心灯的头像

梁文道只是一开始误以为韩寒是文学天才,他就屁颠屁地捧了韩寒是当代鲁迅,为了分假天才既得利益的一杯羹,不惜混淆黑白,舐痣吮痈,好不肉麻恶心。现在梁氏得知韩寒是代笔的文学白痴,但他也不好打自己的脸啊,骑虎难下啊。只好给自己找这么勉强的辩解理由。梁还身为时事评论员,向以社会公知的身份示人,为一个已经现形的骗子如此牵强地狡辩,真是节操碎了一地。令人大跌眼镜!而陈蛋青,为韩骗子的辩解,只能理解为艺术家精神分裂,胡言乱语了。呜呼,中国人对造假的包容,真可谓空前绝后!

文章不写半句空

20170412lck

lcklck16的头像

20170412lck

pandora jewelry

 

nike trainers

 

coach outlet online

 

michael kors outlet

 

converse shoes

 

coach outlet online

 

louis vuitton

 

louis vuitton

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

coach factory outlet

 

polo outlet online

 

tory burch outlet

 

louis vuitton online

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

nike air max

 

beats by dr dre

 

oakley sunglasses sale

 

mac cosmetics sale

 

nike store

 

coach outlet store online

 

michael kors handbags sale

 

gucci outlet

 

coach factory outlet

 

michael kors

 

nike blazer pas cher

 

oakley sunglasses

 

swarovski outlet

 

roshe run

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

longchamp handbags

 

louis vuitton handbags

 

nike trainers

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

vans shoes

 

gucci bags

 

tory burch outlet

 

yeezy boost 350

 

polo ralph lauren

 

reebok trainers

 

air max 90

 

reebok outlet store

 

oakley sunglasses sale

 

oakley sunglasses

 

swarovski crystal

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

adidas trainers

 

michael kors factory outlet

 

gucci borse

 

michael kors outlet

 

gucci outlet

 

michael kors outlet

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

polo ralph lauren

 

adidas nmd runner

 

michael kors handbags

 

true religion jeans

 

michael kors outlet

 

lebron james shoes

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

cartier watches

 

ralph lauren uk

 

coach factory outlet online

 

cheap jordans

 

ray bans

 

pandora jewellery

 

christian louboutin

 

hermes outlet

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

polo outlet

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

giuseppe zanotti outlet

 

cheap ray bans

 

beats by dre

 

nike store uk

 

hermes birkin

 

polo ralph lauren

 

longchamp handbags

 

michael kors outlet

 

christian louboutin

 

polo ralph lauren

 

mulberry handbags

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

michael kors handbags

 

michael kors outlet

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

lacoste polo shirts

 

nike foamposite

 

los angeles lakers

 

rolex watches

 

michael kors outlet online

 

louis vuitton outlet clearance

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

coach outlet online

 

louis vuitton

 

ralph lauren

 

cheap jordans

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet online

 

polo ralph lauren

 

hollister sale

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

adidas outlet store

 

tory burch outlet online store

 

kobe bryant shoes

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

michael kors uk

 

air max uk

 

michael kors outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

louis vuitton

 

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

ferragamo shoes

 

coach factory outlet

 

louis vuitton uk

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

louis vuitton handbags

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

rolex watches

 

coach outlet online

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

michael kors handbags clearance

 

burberry canada

 

kobe 9

 

mulberry handbags

 

salomon outlet

 

ysl outlet

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

rolex watches,rolex watches,swiss watches,watches for men,watches for women,omega watches,replica watches,rolex watches for sale,rolex replica,rolex watch,cartier watches,rolex submariner,fake rolex,rolex replica watches,replica rolex

 

beats headphones

 

fitflops shoes

 

cheap jordans

 

michael kors uk

 

hermes belt

 

polo ralph lauren

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

cazal sunglasses

 

kate spade handbags

 

michael kors handbags outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

michael kors outlet

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

swarovski crystal

 

swarovski jewelry

 

coach outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

jordan shoes

 

air max 90

 

air max 90

 

nike blazer pas cher

 

gucci outlet online

 

nike shoes for women

 

thomas sabo charms

 

swarovski jewellery

 

kate spade outlet

 

nike free 5

 

swarovski jewelry

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

true religion jeans

 

adidas shoes

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

oakley sunglasses

 

fitflops outlet

 

louis vuitton

 

coach outlet

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

polo outlet

 

cartier watches for women

 

ralph lauren

 

coach outlet

 

prada outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

pandora charms

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

hermes belts

 

burberry outlet

 

tory burch outlet

 

true religion jeans

 

nike roshe run

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

louis vuitton

 

louis vuitton handbags

 

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

kate spade handbags

 

mont blanc pens

 

mizuno running shoes

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

louis vuitton outlet clearance

 

true religion uk

 

polo ralph lauren

 

coach outlet

 

ray-ban sunglasses

 

ralph lauren polo shirts

 

michael kors handbags

 

coach outlet clearance

 

louis vuitton

 

swarovski outlet

 

ralph lauren

 

nike mercurial

 

gucci site ufficiale

 

ralph lauren polo

 

true religion outlet

 

polo outlet stores

 

replica watches

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

michael kors outlet

 

borse gucci

 

hollister clothing

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

polo outlet

 

kevin durant shoes

 

gucci outlet online

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

ray bans

 

gucci outlet

 

nike outlet store

 

nike shoes

 

ray bans

 

oakley sunglasses

 

prada sunglasses

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

cheap nhl jerseys

 

instyler ionic styler

 

beats by dr dre

 

louis vuitton outlet stores

 

asics

 

coach factory outlet

 

nba jerseys

 

coach outlet

 

mulberry handbags sale

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

michael kors wallets for women

 

coach outlet online

 

cheap nfl jerseys

 

swarovski crystal

 

gucci outlet online

 

ralph lauren uk

 

borse louis vuitton

 

mulberry handbags

 

cheap mlb jerseys

 

louis vuitton outlet store

 

soccer jerseys

 

swarovski outlet

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

ferragamo outlet

 

michael kors

 

marc jacobs outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

nike shoes uk

 

michael kors factory outlet

 

longchamp handbags

 

adidas nmd runner

 

dior sunglasses

 

gucci outlet

 

chrome hearts

 

ralph lauren

 

michael kors outlet online

 

puma outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

coach outlet

 

michael kors handbags

 

tory burch outlet

 

ralph lauren uk

 

coach outlet online

 

football shirts

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

christian louboutin uk

 

coach factory outlet

 

louis vuitton

 

fitflops

 

air jordan 4

 

omega watches

 

Nike Free shoes

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

ecco outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

ray ban sunglasses outlet

 

louis vuitton handbags

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

 

fitflops

 

hollister clothing

 

pandora jewelry

 

michael kors handbags

 

jordan shoes

 

gucci handbags

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

louis vuitton handbags

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

louis vuitton

 

swarovski crystal

 

coach factory outlet

 

louis vuitton

 

cartier watches

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

coach handbags

 

mac cosmetics

 

christian louboutin sale

 

longchamp handbags

 

michael kors handbags clearance

 

fred perry polo shirts

 

true religion outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet online

 

cheap jerseys wholesale

 

michael kors outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

oakley sunglasses

 

oakley sunglasses

 

mcm backpack

 

polo outlet stores

 

gucci outlet

 

ralph lauren outlet stores

 

cheap nba jerseys

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

ferragamo outlet

 

adidas uk

 

nike air max

 

polo outlet

 

sac louis vuitton pas cher

 

nike outlet store

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

oakley sunglasses

 

hollister clothing

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

lebron james shoes

 

tory burch outlet stores

 

michael kors outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

ferragamo shoes

 

coach outlet

 

michael kors handbags

 

pandora jewelry

 

coach outlet online

 

louis vuitton

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

michael kors handbags

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

coach factory outlet

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

kobe shoes

 

nike air max

 

rolex watches for sale

 

polo pas cher

 

fitflops shoes

 

rolex outlet

 

michael kors outlet

 

lacoste pas cher

 

nba jerseys wholesale

 

rolex watches

 

hermes bags

 

ferragamo outlet

 

cheap snapbacks

 

polo ralph lauren

 

tods outlet

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

nike huarache

 

hollister uk

 

coach outlet online

 

michael kors bags

 

true religion uk

 

cheap nba jerseys

 

nike air max 2015

 

ray ban sunglasses uk

 

louis vuitton

 

ecco shoes

 

pandora outlet

 

michael kors handbags

 

michael kors handbags

 

coach outlet online

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

ferragamo shoes

 

futbol baratas

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

coach outlet store online

 

michael kors

 

coach outlet canada

 

rolex outlet

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

chrome hearts outlet

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

mulberry outlet

 

ray ban wayfarer

 

yeezy boost

 

oakley sunglasses sale

 

coach factory outlet

 

rolex watches

 

michael kors outlet online

 

ralph lauren pas cher

 

michael kors

 

michael kors handbags outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

fitflops sale

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

cheap jordans for sale

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

polo outlet

 

tory burch outlet

 

louis vuitton pas cher

 

tory burch outlet online

 

adidas nmd

 

cheap mlb jerseys

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

los angeles lakers jerseys

 

nfl jerseys wholesale

 

rolex uk

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

true religion jeans

 

replica watches

 

oakley sunglasses

 

cartier outlet

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

coach outlet

 

polo ralph lauren

 

thomas sabo

 

nike outlet

 

michael kors handbags

 

mulberry handbags

 

gucci handbags

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

new balance shoes

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

cheap nfl jerseys

 

michael kors outlet

 

coach outlet

 

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

 

michael kors handbags

 

ralph lauren polo

 

cheap ray bans

 

yeezy boost 350

 

montblanc pens

 

ralph lauren polo

 

true religion jeans

 

hollister clothing

 

cheap nfl jerseys

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

chrome hearts outlet

 

tory burch outlet online

 

nike trainers

 

ralph lauren polo

 

burberry outlet

 

longchamp handbags

 

cleveland cavaliers jersey

 

louis vuitton borse

 

polo outlet

 

cheap jordans free shipping

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

coach factory outlet

 

fitflops

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

ray-ban sunglasses

 

chrome hearts

 

louis vuitton

 

longchamp outlet

 

christian louboutin sale

 

true religion sale

 

coach outlet online

 

mulberry bags

 

michael kors outlet online

 

nike shoes

 

oakley sunglasses

 

true religion jeans

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

cheap jordans

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

burberry outlet

 

louis vuitton

 

mulberry handbags

 

polo ralph lauren

 

ferragamo shoes

 

michael kors canada

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

oakley sunglasses

 

coach outlet

 

mbt shoes

 

coach outlet

 

oakley sunglasses

 

coach factory outlet

 

mulberry bags

 

longchamp

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

cheap ray bans

 

longchamp

 

michael kors outlet

 

coach factory outlet

 

nike store uk

 

louis vuitton outlet stores

 

air max 90

 

burberry outlet

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

cartier watches

 

true religion outlet

 

true religion jeans

 

pandora outlet

 

coach outlet

 

Basketball Shoes

 

christian louboutin

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

 

juicy couture outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

mulberry sale

 

coach outlet

 

nike roshe

 

coach outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

christian louboutin online

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

cleveland cavaliers jerseys

 

salomon shoes

 

michael kors outlet store

 

polo ralph lauren

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

swarovski uk

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

swarovski crystal

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

ed hardy clothing

 

nike shoes

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

coach outlet clearance

 

supra shoes

 

coach outlet

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

rolex watches

 

oakley sunglasses

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

hollister clothing

 

oakley sunglasses

 

nike shoes

 

hollister clothing

 

ralph lauren polo

 

cheap football shirts

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

louis vuitton handbags

 

oakley sunglasses

 

cheap nike shoes

 

adidas wings

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses uk

 

louis vuitton outlet stores

 

air max 90

 

louis vuitton uk

 

michael kors outlet stores

 

nike roshe run

 

michael kors handbags

 

longchamp outlet

 

oakley sunglasses

 

pandora outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

coach factory outlet

 

cheap ray bans

 

louis vuitton handbags

 

kd shoes

 

iphone case

 

polo ralph lauren

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

basketball shoes

 

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

air max uk

 

adidas shoes

 

true religion jeans

 

michael kors handbags

 

pandora charms sale clearance

 

oakley sunglasses

 

nike roshe one

 

michael kors factory outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

true religion jeans

 

michael kors outlet

 

nike huarache

 

oakley sunglasses

 

hollister

 

bottega veneta outlet

 

coach outlet store online

 

herve leger outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

nike trainers

 

ralph lauren shirts

 

coach outlet clearance

 

jerseys wholesale

 

louis vuitton handbags

 

fitflops

 

christian louboutin

 

michael kors outlet

 

cartier watches

 

versace sunglasses

 

cartier outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

oakley sunglasses

 

kate spade

 

tory burch outlet online

 

true religion jeans

 

ray ban sunglasses wholesale

 

coach outlet store online

 

oakley sunglasses

 

prada shoes

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

coach outlet online

 

oakley sunglasses

 

longchamp outlet

 

polo outlet store

 

rolex watches

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

valentino outlet

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

soccer jerseys

 

hollister shirts

 

coach outlet

 

nike air force 1

 

oakley sunglasses sale

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

mcm outlet

 

michael kors

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

prada handbags

 

louis vuitton

 

coach factory outlet

 

ray-ban sunglasses

 

coach factory outlet

 

yeezy boost

 

rolex watches

 

ralph lauren

 

tory burch shoes

 

oakley sunglasses

 

michael kors wallets

 

links of london

 

fitflops

 

cartier watches for sale

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

michael kors handbags outlet

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

louis vuitton outlet stores

 

swarovski crystal

 

true religion jeans

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

20170412lck

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。
Type the characters you see in this picture. (使用语音验证)
填入上图所示的数字或者单词;如果你看不清,点击保存按钮,系统会为您重新生成您新的图片。不区分大小写。