[立此存照]藏在你我心中的韩寒/方舟子 作者:赵查理

方韩代笔之争,最初方舟子和韩寒二人,你来我往,你用张良计,我搭过墙梯,好不热闹。因为短期内没有分出高下,方舟子和韩寒慢慢淡出代笔的争论。但是,无休止的舆论却开始了,支持韩寒的人被称为方黑、韩粉,这是广泛意义上的拥韩派,支持方舟子的人被称为韩黑、方粉,这是广泛意义上的倒韩派。你今天索隐一个证据,我明日考证你的错误,白热化的时候,围观者在千里之外的电脑屏幕前也会溅一身血,一言不合就会被打入对方阵营,结下了不共戴天的仇和恨。毫不夸张地说,有关韩寒代笔的争论,导致网友对骂、兄弟成仇、夫妻反目、专家站队,也佐证了争论的影响范围之大。

仔细分析,双方基本围绕三个层面进行攻防战。对倒韩派来说,首先从文学艺术创作方面来质疑韩寒,包括韩寒名字的由来、父亲代笔的可能性、手稿中离谱的错误、访谈时不了解自己作品的窘迫,以及博客发表时间和发表顺序等。对一个作家而言,这种质疑很致命,创作能力是作家赖以生存的饭碗,韩寒又是依靠超出同龄人的写作能力成为作家的。其次,还质疑“韩三篇”,这也是韩寒的软肋之所在。韩寒的学业成绩大红灯笼高高挂,无论他愿不愿意,舆论赋予了一个新形象,即以他的成功影射现行教育体制的弊端和害处。或者说,韩寒这两个字,在民众心里面,天然就是反体制的。而“韩三篇”让不少人大失所望,因为表现出来的思考能力,没有达到民众预设的及格线。甚至,有人觉得这是他准备投身体制温暖怀抱的自白书。再次,韩寒代笔可谓文坛丑闻,而他是瞩目的公众人物,必须对公众有一个交代,所以有人呼吁司法介入,由法院调查代笔的最后真相。

毫无疑问,拥韩派自然兵来将挡水来土掩,有针对性地进行了反击。对于代笔一说,他们认为,有一份证据说一分话,不能用推理的方式逼着韩寒自证,同样的逻辑也可以用在任何作家身上。即便韩寒自证,也会因这个逻辑落入“怀疑-自证-怀疑-自证”的陷阱中,永远无法结束质疑。再反讽一点,假设韩粉要求方粉证明,他提出的质疑是自己写的,也符合这个逻辑。所以,这种质疑是不靠谱的,是无休止的怀疑主义,因此在逻辑上不成立。而对“韩三篇”来说,韩寒并不是天才,对于政治理论和社会进步不可能无师自通,但他也有言论自由,有说话的权利,哪怕说得对错参半,这是公民的权利空间,不应该被指责。也不能借此判断韩寒和体制的关系。也有围观者认为,“韩三篇”抛开宏大叙事,从身边生活开始做起,看似鸡毛蒜皮的小事,却是民主训练的基础,说明思考深度已从口号走向行动。而对于舆论质疑和司法介入一事,一是谁主张谁举证,如没有确实的代笔证据,就不能以此为假设前提质疑韩寒,二是作家写作属于私域,就像著名的磨坊故事,风可进雨可进国王不可进,司法不能随便介入公民私域,哪怕他是让渡了一部分私域的公众人物。可以恶猜公权,不能恶猜私域。

双方之后的持久战,大体上都沿着文艺创作、社会形象、司法介入等方面起起伏伏。现在,韩寒成了《后会无期》的导演,与郭敬明的对比也发生变化,从恶俗的身高、性别、思想,转到受众和票房等经济层面。2014年8月19日,以“反智”为武器的倒韩派战将、清华大学教授肖鹰发表了《“天才韩寒”是当代文坛的最大丑闻》一文,这篇文章的副题是“《后会无期》与韩寒现象”,文章在评价韩寒导演的电影时,将其和韩寒代笔的争论放在一起,并称之为“最大丑闻”。一石激起千层浪,这篇文章被其他媒体称为“大字报”,尤其是发表此文的《中国青年报》是俗称的“中央五大报”之一,甚至被认为在为文章背书。肖鹰先生不认可“大字报”的说法,并与《新京报》、《南方周末》等媒体的评论员交恶,继而在微博展开论战,据称向报社举报当事人,甚至向中纪委举报了。也因此,拥韩派和倒韩派又掀起了一次辩论高潮,但还是谁也没有说服谁。

作为围观者,我们加入或者退出“战斗”,都不会改变双方的对峙局面,也不会真的花时间参与其中。可是,当我们围观双方的争论时,会在心里面作出一个判断,即认可拥韩派或者倒韩派的说法。也就是说,在你我的心中,藏着一个韩寒,或者是方舟子,具体是谁,得依赖于知识结构的选择。这意味着,我们的思维方式,是拥韩派或者倒韩派的,亦或者混合了两者,概莫能外。我们几无可能找到证据辨明真相,但这场争论就像一面镜子,让我们从思维的变化中,去审视一个渐渐清晰的自己。以此为镜鉴,无法正衣冠,但可以正思维。

回过头去看韩寒代笔之争。我对韩寒并无特殊的好感和恶意,也不认同他被塑造出来的公众形象,最开始觉得代笔之争可以把韩寒拉下神坛。倒韩派用大量推理的方式,堵死韩寒没有代笔的途径,只剩下韩寒自证有无代笔的工作。韩寒除了晒手稿,并没接受用公开写作的方式自证清白。因为,按照倒韩派的质疑逻辑,这场“考试”也会被质疑——与组织方有利益关系、韩寒是有备而来等等,这些很难自证。在这个过程中,倒韩派要证明的就一件事,韩寒的作品代笔了。只是,有无代笔只有韩寒与所谓的“代笔者”知道,这是天知地知你知我知的事情,其他人拿不到“打倒”韩寒的确凿证据。据说,倒韩派写下了上千万字的推理过程,论证韩寒必然代笔,言之凿凿。不过按照常识思考,假设倒韩派有一个字能证明韩寒代笔,那么这一场论战就结束了,韩寒早输得灰头土脸了。显然,现实并非如此。这个质疑是以结论倒推过程,并以此论证和组织证据,这样就有一种可能,因为知识的不足,或者利益的考量,只选择有利于结论的证据,而轻视甚至故意无视与结论相反的证据。为了结果正义,无视程序正义,可没有程序正义,又如何获得结果正义呢,这是一个解不开的死疙瘩,就像戈尔迪乌姆之结,我们不能像亚历山大那样挥剑,这是在回避问题,而非解决问题。我并不是说不能质疑韩寒,而是应当用证据说话,否则就是一种猜测,甚至是阴谋论,无法实事求是。那么,在证据不足或没有证据的情况下,能不能质疑韩寒呢?我觉得,这种质疑必然存在,可必须限制在一定的范围,比如自己闲暇时想想,或者好友聊天说说,都不算过分,但不能在大庭广众之下进行,因为一分证据说一分话,尤其是涉及他人的饭碗时。大家都知道,生命诚可贵,爱情价更高,若为自由故,二者皆可抛。我个人觉得,胡适先生的“容忍比自由更重要”更适合国情,这告诉我们在没有说服力的证据之前,容忍他人,才有自由,哪怕未来他会因自己的错误身败名裂。纵然韩寒在文章、访谈中有一千个一万个瑕疵,但都不能彻底否定他没有代笔的可能。这方面,倒韩派只能自说自话下去。

再说说争论极大的“韩三篇”。“韩三篇”包括《谈革命》、《说民主》、《要自由》。《谈革命》没有遮掩,认为民众素质不高,革命后可能陷入多数人暴政,因此不提倡革命。可是,改革能否解决民众素质问题,韩寒对此基本避而不谈。他给出的办法是静候国民素质和教育水平的提高,我们这一代种树下一代乘凉。《说民主》仍旧是担忧民众素质,所以提出利用法治、教育、文化“改变人民”的办法。同时,也展现了立场,即鸡蛋和石头选择,总是站在鸡蛋那边,做一棵反向墙头草。《要自由》则提出了诉求,即两个“××自由”,并表示“但是如果两三年以后,情况一直没有改善,在每一届的作协或者文联全国大会时,我将都亲临现场或门口,进行旁听和抗议”。尽管标题有所区别,但三篇文章意思差不多,民众素质低,不能革命,暂缓民主,莫说自由。说实话,韩寒文章“的地得”基本分不清楚,“权利”和“权力”也常搞混了,而且给我的主观感受是,作者对政治理论不太熟悉,是依赖生活的经验来讨论政治话题,显得少年老成。韩寒有言论自由,如果发表在博客等公共场所,其他人有评论的自由,但评论不能超过观点之争的范围。“韩三篇”认为民众应该从改变身边的生活开始,我认为这是一个有效的通向理想目标的途径。很多年前蔡定剑先生就曾著书立说反驳对革命、民主、自由的偏见,已经给出了恰当的答案,在此不再赘述。我国历来把作家等知识分子当成社会精英,并希望他们能对社会问题提出公正客观的建议。可是,如今作家更喜欢待在书斋里,他们只愿做锦上添的花。韩寒尝试介入政治生活,尽管只有昙花一现,但也算是勇气可嘉。如果和后来获得国际巨奖的“我只是一个讲故事的人”相比,后者用睚眦必报的字眼公开指责要求他借助声望干预社会问题的同行,韩寒“我是差生我怕谁”的腔调反倒多了些率性。关于这三方面,激进者有之,温和者有之,保守者有之,反对者有之,我以为可以通过改造社会,让各方的利益博弈能有一个更大的平台,取得更多的共识。

再说说政府调查或司法介入。很多人以为,韩寒是公众人物,他的作品具有公共性质,而一旦代笔就涉嫌侵害读者和粉丝的利益,所以必须由政府出面或者司法介入。以前我曾认为,可以由专业第三方进行判断,这么说并非无稽之谈,假设真的有政府或司法介入此事,结果也必然是二选一,代笔或者没代笔,如果代笔了,那么韩寒就无话可说,如果没代笔,那么韩寒就能获得清白。问题在于,事情并非这么简单。法律不能要求民众自证其罪,倒韩派对自己的质疑也得承担举证责任,所以在没有爆炸性的直接证据之前,人们很难就代笔一事进行起诉,而政府和司法也没有任何介入的理由,所以这种呼吁不存在任何意义。而且,这还涉及到公共空间和私人空间的问题。我们生活在大大小小的空间里,与他人、政府、社会产生关系的地方,就是公共空间,关起门来谁都别来碍事的地方,就是私人空间。用脚趾头想都能明白,公共空间是个“巨人”,私人空间是个“瘦子”,古今中外的历史和现实都说明,“巨人”必然欺负“瘦子”,即便无意识的时候,也会把“瘦子”挤得无处可去。因此,为了保护私人空间,政治和法律都会要求,只要私人空间不侵犯公共空间,就得受到最严格的保护,这也是迫不得已的保护,再后退一步,“瘦子”就会被“巨人”彻底挤死了,人们就再也没有空间释放自己的隐私了。这意味着,在私人空间里,个人的行为只要没有侵害公共空间的利益的风险,任何行为都不应该被追究责任。个人和他人基于自愿,可以互相勾结,可以自我伤害,可以做公共空间禁止的事情,比如通过电脑窥探武藤兰、苍井空等“才艺双馨”老师的爱情动作片,这在公共场合属于违法行为,在私人空间也有损个人的身体和思维,可即便如此,包括公权在内的外力也不能破门而入。也就是说,在私人空间里,人们可以行使一些消极的自由,展现人性中恶魔的一面,这是最后的隐私。对韩寒来说,他可以是一个人,也可以是一个名字,也可以是一个公司,也可以是写作团队,具有多种可能性,但他们的行为发生在私人空间,包括只是有可能的代笔,应当得到尊重。而且,即便存在父子代笔,但父为子隐,子为父隐,这种所谓的欺骗发生在门的那一边,门外只有一个韩寒,人们即便有所怀疑,越界也会侵犯自由。除非韩寒自证代笔,这根本是不可能的。

我的观点可能有利于拥韩派,但我仍无意在这场争论中站队。辩论有规矩,议事有规则,如果双方的辩论能够恪守这些原则,不是诉诸感情,不是诉诸阴谋,那么围观的人可能看得会更清晰一些。就像西西弗斯一样,这是一场只有开始没有结束的论证,双方都会寻找更多的蛛丝马迹来巩固自己的判断,并自以为用其就能将对方驳得体无完肤。有的人出于偏见,有的人出于利益,有的人出于无知,这样的人拥韩派有,倒韩派也有,尤其是走牛角尖的韩黑和韩粉。旷日持久的辩论,是巨大的思维镜子,我们谨慎走上前去,就会看到心中隐藏着的影子,不是韩寒,就是方舟子。但一个人最大的自由,是用自己的思维和眼睛看世界,心里面应该是完整的自己,意识到这一点并为之努力,围观者才会有所得。

原文地址:http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_616ebd870102v2jx.html

分类: 

参与评分: 

平均评分: 3 (2个评价)

评论

建议作者先学习一下智人不久前发表的刑警眼中的韩寒代笔门

记的粉丝,。的头像

建议作者先学习一下智人不久前发表的刑警眼中的韩寒代笔门。一个思想上不讲是非的人,不是一个坏人,肯定也是一个庸人,。你是一个没有是非的人吗?如果是,现实中没有人愿意与你交朋友,。这样的人还是默默的自慰罢了,不要出来丢人现眼了,。这是一个打假的战场,不是一个愚腐的乐园,。

尊敬的作者,你真是太有才了!!!把问题巧妙地搅混了

访客的头像

尊敬的作者,你真是太有才了!!!把问题巧妙地搅混了,达到了拥韩的目的。可是,韩寒事件现在已经不再是在他的私人空间,而已经涉及了千千万万青少年成长的公共空间,产生的社会影响也不言而喻,难道司法机构、国家法律仍然听之任之,欺骗、愚弄他人?照此逻辑,天下哪里还有公理所在?哪里还有清明可言?

作者看似关注方韩之争,持客观立场

访客的头像

作者看似关注方韩之争,持客观立场,其实根本没有看倒韩者的文章,也没有看到显然存在的事实。拿韩寒早前写的低劣的初中生般水平的博客就是明证。他却不知道,写下“据说,倒韩派写下了上千万字的推理过程,论证韩寒必然代笔,言之凿凿。不过按照常识思考,假设倒韩派有一个字能证明韩寒代笔,那么这一场论战就结束了,韩寒早输得灰头土脸了”等自以为是的话。

文章说的没错,没有直接证据很难进入司法程序

010的头像

文章说的没错,没有直接证据很难进入司法程序,因此就不能说倒韩成功。人们只有耐心地等。其实也不要等,除了新概念作文大赛怀疑其父有代笔嫌疑,韩寒博文怀疑代笔有其人。如果后者有一定把握,那么代笔事就不再是“只有其父子两个知道,两人都不说谁也没办法”,这个僵局或可能一朝打破,变成“若要人不知,除非己莫”了。那时这惊天丑闻他们不愿意接受,也没办法推脱了。韩寒父子厉害,今天一下变得可怜起来,龟缩不动,守关不出,是否仍然想着翻身的事?法律不能制裁他,他还是原来的人见人爱的韩寒,写书签售拍电影赚钱,还会被他的粉丝尊为意见领袖,民主斗士?继续过一以贯之的名利双收的好日子?想继续做一以贯之的美梦很难,名誉坏了,是坏在他们自己手里,他们不愿意出来自证清白,粉丝们叛变的肯定不是少数。一个人名誉坏了,有再多的钱,也买不来了

如今老韩家陷入困顿的两难境地

010的头像

如今老韩家陷入困顿的两难境地。若自证清白又怕编的故事说不圆露馅,编故事说谎当中假如有人问这问那,答错了怎么办?若不自证清白,这么龟缩着那天是个头?这名誉在一天天的坏下去,给了人们非议的口舌。看起来不自证清白是一着妙棋,实则是顾头不顾尾。鸵鸟战术。你不自证清白是你的权利,可行使这权利也让你变得更加被动。

也许他们是铁打的,不在乎人们的骂。而在我的想象当中

010的头像

也许他们是铁打的,不在乎人们的骂。而在我的想象当中,他们的日子已惨不忍睹,出门时怕被人们认出,得把脸遮起来或者化妆。基本上大门不出二门不迈,不敢上网,不能写文章,不敢与人争辩。一切得忍,得等。在我的想象当中,他们的日子及其黑暗,看不到曙光和尽头,以至于整天以泪洗面而不能自拔。这事情即使不深追究,代价也是巨大了。也足可以警示后人千万不能走他们的老路,那样会很不值,太不值了。聪明的把不聪明的毁了。人还是不要太聪明的好。或能够大红大紫,但是付了这致命的代价得不偿失啊。

赵查理先生,如果韩寒作品确属代笔

访客的头像

赵查理先生,如果韩寒作品确属代笔,韩寒写出的东西只是给自已看的吗?你所说的私人空间完全是一派胡言。照你说的,莫言先生要想赚更多的钱,他是不是也可以让张三、李四写的书贴上莫言这个商标出售而收取商标费呢?如果这样,这世上还有多少写书人,值得读者去信赖?你是不是也该给自己画上个问号。

楼上无语中

访客的头像

楼上无语中,如果这个红枣指的是道德和法律规范了的文化创作空间,那个瓜指的是无限制的个人创作自由,可以大胆造假,可以宣扬丑、恶,可以违反道德、违反人性。那么,那个枣即使是很小很小,本人也会去摘那个枣而不看那个瓜一眼,因为那是个烂瓜,再大也一文不值。把别人看作武大郎,别人可能把你看作侏儒,比武大郎还矮半截。但这两个名词残疾人较忌讳,在公共空间还是不用为好,免得别人说你素质不高。

20170715lck

liuchunkai的头像

20170715lck

kate spade handbags

 

air max 90

 

mbt shoes outlet

 

true religion jeans

 

rolex outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

hermes outlet

 

polo ralph lauren

 

coach outlet store

 

michael kors uk

 

jordan shoes

 

birkenstock shoes

 

polo ralph lauren

 

ferragamo shoes sale

 

juicy couture tracksuit

 

longchamp outlet

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

nike free running

 

true religion jeans

 

adidas wings shoes

 

cheap jerseys wholesale

 

puma shoes

 

swarovski jewellery

 

christian louboutin

 

mont blanc outlet

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

coach outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

louis vuitton outlet stores

 

cheap jerseys wholesale

 

pandora charms

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

rolex watches,rolex replica watches,replica rolex watches,replica watches

 

gucci outlet online

 

canada goose outlet

 

coach outlet

 

kate spade handbags

 

burberry outlet store

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

polo pas cher

 

michael kors outlet

 

tory burch outlet online

 

true religion jeans outlet

 

cazal outlet

 

burberry canada

 

yeezy boost

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

herve leger dresses

 

lacoste outlet

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

pandora charms sale clearance

 

louis vuitton

 

oakley sunglasses

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

air max 90

 

pandora jewellery

 

coach outlet clearance

 

nba jerseys

 

michael kors outlet

 

true religion outlet

 

snapbacks wholesale

 

mcm backpacks

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

michael kors outlet stores

 

oakley sunglasses sale

 

mulberry handbags

 

true religion jeans

 

gucci outlet

 

pandora outlet

 

soccer cleats

 

longchamp

 

swarovski uk

 

gucci outlet online

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

nike air max

 

coach factory outlet

 

roshe run

 

michael kors outlet online

 

pandora outlet

 

kate spade uk

 

nfl jersey wholesale

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

cheap jordan shoes

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

true religion jeans sale

 

ralph lauren

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

michael kors handbags

 

michael kors outlet online

 

adidas shoes

 

louis vuitton bags

 

nike outle

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

tory burch outlet stores

 

ralph lauren shirts

 

coach outlet online

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

cheap nike shoes

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

coach outlet clearance

 

polo outlet stores

 

ralph lauren uk

 

ralph lauren

 

ray-ban sunglasses

 

swarovski jewelry

 

air max trainers

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet store online

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

adidas nmd

 

nba jerseys wholesale

 

nike shoes

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

adidas outlet

 

new balance outlet

 

louis vuitton handbags

 

mont blanc pens

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

michael kors factory outlet

 

michael kors outlet store

 

birkenstock shoes

 

longchamp

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

michael kors uk

 

louis vuitton outlet store

 

louis vuitton

 

adidas outlet

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

true religion jeans sale

 

lacoste shirts

 

ralph lauren uk

 

salomon outlet

 

canada goose coats

 

oakley sunglasses sale

 

nfl jerseys

 

michael kors outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

uggs outlet

 

true religion uk

 

nike shoes for women

 

cheap jordan shoes

 

michael kors outlet online

 

coach outlet store online

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

cheap jordans free shipping

 

nike air huarache

 

adidas shoes

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

ecco outlet

 

michael kors handbags

 

michael kors uk

 

coach outlet online

 

max 1

 

nike outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses outlet

 

nike outlet store online

 

pandora bracelet

 

instyler

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

supra shoes sale

 

cheap mlb jerseys

 

swarovski jewelry

 

marc jacobs sale

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

christian louboutin sale

 

coach outlet

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

ferragamo outlet

 

coach factory outlet

 

prada outlet

 

oakley sunglasses sale

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

ugg outlet,ugg outlet clearance,uggs outlet,ugg outlet online clearance,ugg outlet store,ugg outlet online store,ugg outlet sale,ugg outlet coupons,ugg outlet boots

 

air max shoes

 

adidas uk store

 

coach outlet clearance

 

pandora jewelry

 

los angeles lakers

 

mulberry handbags

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

coach outlet

 

kate spade

 

coach outlet online

 

true religion outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet online

 

mulberry outlet,mulberry handbags outlet

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

nike outlet store online

 

cheap jordan shoes

 

nike trainers

 

nfl jersey wholesale

 

christian louboutin sale

 

true religion canada

 

cheap jordans

 

michael kors handbags

 

prada outlet

 

true religion outlet store

 

ralph lauren outlet stores

 

coach outlet online

 

michael kors outlet

 

snapbacks wholesale

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

coach outlet online

 

christian louboutin uk

 

ray bans

 

mizuno shoes

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

cheap ray bans

 

lacoste pas cher

 

ugg outlet,uggs outlet,ugg outlet online clearance,ugg outlet store,ugg outlet coupons,ugg outlet boots,ugg outlet online store,ugg outlet sale

 

polo outlet

 

mac cosmetics sale

 

rolex watches outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

louis vuitton handbags

 

louis vuitton uk

 

tory burch outlet

 

louis vuitton

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

lacoste polo

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

canada goose jackets

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

swarovski crystal

 

adidas nmd runner

 

pandora jewelery

 

coach factory outlet

 

polo ralph lauren

 

cheap nba jerseys

 

Nike Free shoes

 

coach outlet store online

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

coach outlet store online

 

kobe 9 elite

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

polo outlet

 

yeezy boost 350

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

max 90

 

snapback hats

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

bottega veneta outlet online

 

hermes outlet store

 

coach outlet

 

longchamp handbags

 

polo outlet online

 

nike store uk

 

ray ban wayfarer

 

hermes belts

 

coach outlet clearance

 

coach outlet

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

christian louboutin

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

ferragamo shoes

 

mbt shoes outlet

 

sac louis vuitton pas cher

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

polo ralph lauren

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

coach outlet

 

longchamp outlet online

 

michael kors outlet

 

swarovski outlet

 

canada goose jackets

 

ray ban sunglasses uk

 

rolex watches

 

nfl jerseys

 

canada goose

 

tory burch handbags

 

asics,asics israel,asics shoes,asics running shoes,asics israel,asics gel,asics running,asics gel nimbus,asics gel kayano

 

vans outlet

 

uggs outlet

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

ferragamo shoes

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

oakley sunglasses

 

canada goose jackets

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

coach outlet

 

giuseppe zanotti shoes

 

cheap nfl jerseys

 

nike air huarache

 

links of london jewellery

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

louis vuitton

 

nike air max 1

 

louis vuitton

 

cleveland cavaliers jerseys

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

polo outlet

 

coach factory outlet

 

nhl jerseys wholesale

 

fitflops

 

hollister clothing store

 

gucci outlet online

 

fitflops

 

jordan 4

 

ralph?lauren

 

cartier outlet

 

polo ralph lauren

 

jerseys wholesale

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

polo ralph lauren

 

coach factory outlet

 

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

 

rolex watches,rolex watches,swiss watches,watches for men,watches for women,omega watches,replica watches,rolex watches for sale,rolex replica,rolex watch,cartier watches,rolex submariner,fake rolex,rolex replica watches,replica rolex

 

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

 

coach factory outlet

 

longchamp handbags

 

Basketball Shoes

 

coach outlet store online

 

ralph lauren

 

cartier watches for women

 

ferragamo outlet

 

chrome hearts outlet

 

air max 90

 

burberry outlet sale

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

rolex watches for sale

 

cheap football shirts

 

ed hardy outlet

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

tory burch outlet online

 

ferragamo shoes

 

coach outlet store online

 

nike air max 90

 

rolex uk

 

pandora outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

oakley sunglasses

 

nike shoes

 

coach factory outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

oakley sunglasses sale

 

rolex orologi

 

ysl outlet online

 

coach factory outlet

 

coach factory outlet

 

thomas sabo charms

 

christian louboutin sale

 

michael kors wallets for women

 

air force 1 shoes

 

coach factory outlet

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

cheap jordans for sale

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

mulberry handbags sale

 

michael kors outlet

 

adidas shoes

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

ralph lauren

 

nfl jersey

 

pandora outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet online

 

mulberry handbags sale

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

gucci borse

 

michael kors canada

 

coach outlet online

 

polo ralph lauren

 

ferragamo outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

longchamp handbags

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

soccer jerseys wholesale

 

mulberry outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

ralph lauren?uk

 

true religion outlet

 

longchamp outlet

 

cheap soccer jerseys

 

valentino shoes

 

mlb jerseys

 

true religion outlet

 

swarovski crystal

 

coach outlet online

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

reebok shoes

 

polo outlet store

 

coach outlet online

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

cartier watches for sale

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses wholesale

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

louis vuitton outlet stores

 

ray ban sunglasses outlet

 

gucci outlet store

 

lebron shoes

 

polo outlet

 

omega outlet

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

nike uk store

 

coach outlet store online

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

nhl jerseys

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

louis vuitton

 

air max 90

 

ralph lauren polo

 

mbt shoes

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

ray-ban sunglasses

 

michael kors outlet

 

louis vuitton

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

coach outlet

 

polo ralph lauren

 

fitflops

 

michael kors uk

 

coach factory outlet

 

coach outlet

 

cheap nfl jerseys

 

tods outlet online

 

fred perry polo

 

cartier watches

 

michael kors outlet online

 

hermes birkin bag

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

cheap replica watches

 

michael kors outlet store

 

cheap jordan shoes

 

kate spade uk

 

mulberry outlet

 

canada goose outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

coach outlet store online

 

nike shoes uk

 

michael kors outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

louis vuitton borse

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

nike air max 90

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

hollister shirts

 

adidas shoes

 

michael kors handbags

 

tory burch outlet online

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

nike shoes outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

canada goose outlet store

 

coach outlet

 

gucci outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

michael kors outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

michael kors outlet

 

kd shoes

 

true religion outlet

 

cartier watches

 

converse shoes sale

 

oakley sunglasses

 

chrome hearts online store

 

polo ralph lauren

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

canada goose outlet store

 

prada sunglasses for women

 

kobe bryants shoes

 

louis vuitton

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

polo outlet stores

 

true religion outlet uk

 

christian louboutin sale

 

gucci bags

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

nike trainers

 

canada goose uk

 

lebron shoes

 

louis vuitton

 

nike blazer pas cher

 

coach outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

ralph lauren polo

 

ray ban sunglasses uk

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

coach outlet store online

 

coach outlet online

 

kate spade outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

cheap jordans

 

ralph?lauren?polo?shirts

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

prada outlet online

 

michael kors outlet

 

ugg outlet

 

fitflops uk

 

tory burch sandals

 

michael kors outlet online

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

burberry outlet store

 

nike outlet online

 

coach factory outlet

 

ugg boots,ugg boots outlet,cheap uggs boots,ugg boots for women,ugg boots on sale,ugg boots clearance,ugg boots clearance sale women,ugg boots clearance outlet,ugg boots for men,ugg boots for kids

 

michael kors outlet online

 

nike trainers uk

 

ugg boots,ugg boots outlet,ugg boots for women,ugg boots on sale,ugg boots clearance,ugg boots for men,ugg boots for kids,ugg boots clearance sale women,ugg boots clearance outlet

 

mulberry handbags

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

michael kors outlet online

 

michael kors outlet online

 

michael kors outlet online

 

tory burch outlet online

 

camisetas futbol baratas

 

fitflops uk

 

coach outlet store online

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

true religion jeans

 

louis vuitton outlet stores

 

kobe shoes

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

nike roshe run

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

air max 2015

 

cheap ray bans

 

mlb jerseys

 

rolex watches

 

ralph lauren uk

 

nike roshe run

 

mulberry uk

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

ralph lauren polo

 

reebok shoes

 

michael kors handbags

 

mulberry bags

 

basketball shoes,basketball sneakers,lebron james shoes,sports shoes,kobe bryant shoes,kobe sneakers,nike basketball shoes,running shoes,mens sport shoes,nike shoes

 

louis vuitton

 

coach outlet

 

coach handbags outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

foamposite shoes

 

coach outlet online

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

20170715lck

2017-7-16 xiaozheng6666

xiaozheng6的头像

2017-7-16 xiaozheng6666

pandora outlet store

cheap authentic nba jerseys

nhl jerseys

polo outlet

fitflops sale clearance

ed hardy outlet

polo outlet

fitflops sale clearance

michael kors outlet store

michael kors handbags

michael kors outlet online

ugg boots

uggs outlet

polo ralph lauren

mbt shoes

canada goose outlet

coach outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

polo ralph lauren outlet online

true religion jeans sale

nike shoes

pandora jewelry

michael kors handbags

lacoste polo

michael kors outlet online

nike shoes for men

tory burch outlet stores

fitflop sale

kate spade outlet

mcm outlet

coach outlet

nike shoes

adidas outlet store

ralph lauren outlet

mont blanc pens

coach outlet store online

polo outlet

michael kors outlet online

polo ralph lauren outlet

oakley sunglasses

coach outlet

longchamp handbags

moncler outlet online

polo ralph lauren

mont blanc outlet

polo outlet

nike outlet

ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet

mbt shoes clearance outlet

prada outlet store

ray ban sunglasses

cheap ugg boots

adidas nmd r1

coach factory outlet

coach outlet online

asics running shoes

pandora jewelry

true religion jeans

coach outlet

michael kors handbags

true religion outlet store

adidas yeezy

canada goose outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

ultra boosts

nike shoes outlet

prada outlet store

cheap jerseys

nike outlet store

cheap ray ban sunglasses

christian louboutin shoes

nike factory outlet

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet online

kate spade outlet online store

ralph lauren polo

air jordan 4

michael kors outlet online

cheap ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet

pandora jewelry

michael kors outlet clearance

polo ralph lauren outlet online

nike outlet

ralph lauren

true religion outlet

fred perry outlet

canada goose jackets

michael kors outlet online

mulberry handbags

oakley sunglasses wholesale

michael kors outlet

ralph lauren uk

cheap nhl jerseys

ralph lauren uk

polo ralph lauren outlet

michael kors outlet

canada goose jackets

coach outlet online

yeezy boost 350

michael kors outlet

coach outlet store online

fitflops sale

prada outlet

nfl jerseys

mlb jerseys

mlb jerseys wholesale

cheap jordans for sale

polo ralph lauren

pandora outlet

nike outlet store

coach outlet online

mont blanc outlet

canada goose outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet online

cheap jordan shoes

adidas yeezy shoes

mlb jerseys

hermes birkin

fred perry shirts

moncler outlet

michael kors outlet online

prada outlet stores

ugg outlet online

coach factory outlet

oakley sunglasses for men

oakley sunglasses wholesale

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet clearance

nike shoes on sale

nba jersey

ralph lauren outlet

cheap uggs

fred perry clothing

fitflops outlet

lebron shoes

canada goose outlet

air jordan shoes

coach outlet online

ralph lauren

coach outlet

lacoste outlet

cheap mlb jerseys

moncler sale

kate spade bags

mulberry bags

christian louboutin

longchamp outlet online

ray ban sunglasses outlet

coach outlet online

ray ban sunglasses on sale

michael kors outlet clearance

true religion outlet

longchamp outlet

canada goose jackets

adidas outlet online

cheap jordans

ralph lauren

true religion outlet

coach factory outlet

ralph lauren uk

yeezy boost 350 v2

ralph lauren pas cher

cheap oakley sunglasses

moncler jackets

michael kors handbags clearance

coach outlet

pandora bracelet

coach outlet online

oakley sunglasses wholesale

cheap jordan shoes

ray ban

valentino shoes

oakley sunglasses

hermes belts outlet

fitflops clearance

ugg outlet

asics outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

valentino outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

coach outlet online

coach factory outlet

ralph lauren outlet

christian louboutin outlet

kate spade outlet online

fitflops sale clearance

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

adidas yeezy shoes

coach outlet

adidas yeezy boost

kate spade handbags

polo ralph lauren outlet online

oakley sunglasses

uggs outlet

adidas yeezy

nike outlet store

oakley sunglasses wholesale

canada goose

polo outlet

cheap jordans

ralph lauren uk

michael kors outlet

nike shoes for men

coach factory outlet

mont blanc pens for sale

ugg boots

nike shoes for women

canada goose jackets

michael kors outlet clearance

ugg boots

yeezy shoes

yeezy boost

fred perry polo

adidas yeezy boost

mbt outlet

michael kors outlet online store

coach factory outlet

canada goose jackets

polo outlet

ralph lauren

longchamp outlet

christian louboutin outlet

adidas yeezy shoes

ugg outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

michael kors outlet

oakley sunglasses outlet

polo ralph lauren

kate spade handbags

christian louboutin outlet

michael kors outlet stores

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

cheap ray bans

mont blanc pens

lunette ray ban

polo ralph lauren

ralph lauren

fitflop sandals

coach factory outlet

coach outlet online

coach factory outlet online

mlb jerseys wholesale

oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren

michael kors outlet

canada goose outlet

yeezy boost

lacoste clothing

coach outlet online

kate spade outlet

coach factory outlet

coach outlet

ralph lauren outlet

adidas outlet

puma outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

true religion jeans

ugg outlet

ralph lauren uk

ugg boots

michael kors outlet

coach factory outlet online

michael kors outlet

tory burch outlet

nike outlet store

michael kors outlet clearance

ray ban sunglasses

ralph lauren

nike outlet

christian louboutin shoes

oakley sunglasses

ray ban pas cher

polo ralph lauren

ugg outlet

coach factory outlet

adidas nmd

air jordan retro

prada outlet

coach factory outlet

mont blanc pens

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet online

ralph lauren uk

cheap oakley sunglasses

pandora jewelry

fitflops sale clearance

cheap ugg boots

polo ralph lauren outlet

asics shoes

ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet online

nike shoes outlet

nike shoes

polo ralph lauren

true religion outlet

mbt shoes

coach outlet

ugg boots

fred perry

lebron james shoes

fitflops sandals

cheap mlb jerseys

cheap oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren

longchamp

ugg outlet online

canada goose outlet

polo ralph lauren

michael kors outlet

ralph lauren polo

cheap jerseys wholesale

michael kors outlet online

adidas shoes

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren

michael kors handbags

ralph lauren shirts

ralph lauren outlet

canada goose outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ugg boots

adidas outlet online

valentino outlet store

hermes outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap uggs

mont blanc pens

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet

mont blanc outlet

ray ban sunglasses for men

canada goose jackets

canada goose

polo shirts

coach outlet online

polo ralph lauren outlet online

tory burch outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet online

coach outlet store online

canada goose

adidas yeezy shoes

coach outlet store online

canada goose

ray ban sunglasses

giuseppe zanotti sneakers

coach factory outlet

nike shoes

christian louboutin

jordan retro

oakley sunglasses wholesale

michael kors outlet clearance

true religion outlet online

mont blanc

nike shoes

tory burch outlet

ralph lauren uk

mont blanc outlet

mbt shoes outlet

michael kors outlet online

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet

kate spade purses

nike outlet

coach outlet clearance

tory burch sandals

coach outlet

michael kors outlet online

true religion jeans

oakley sunglasses wholesale

jordan retro shoes

hermes outlet

nike shoes

ed hardy clothing

true religion outlet store

oakley sunglasses

cheap nike shoes

kate spade outlet store

ray ban sunglasses

puma shoes

cheap jordans

cheap mlb jerseys

ray ban sunglasses wholesale

adidas shoes for women

coach factory outlet

nike air jordan 4

air jordan shoes

mlb jerseys

lacoste shoes

cheap ray bans sunglasses

kate spade handbags

christian louboutin outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach factory outlet

canada goose jackets

mont blanc

ed hardy

oakley sunglasses

michael kors

adidas outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet online

oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren polo

canada goose jackets

polo outlet

ralph lauren outlet

cheap ugg boots

polo ralph lauren

canada goose jackets

polo ralph lauren pas cher

michael kors outlet online

ugg outlet

giuseppe zanotti shoes

cheap ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet clearance

michael kors outlet online

mulberry handbags

fred perry polo shirts

michael kors outlet online

ugg boots

valentino outlet store

kate spade outlet store

polo ralph lauren outlet online

ray bans sunglasses outlet

nike shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

polo ralph lauren outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

fred perry clothing

oakley sunglasses

canada goose

oakley sunglasses wholesale

oakley sunglasses wholesale

true religion

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

christian louboutin sale

ralph lauren uk

canada goose outlet

air jordan 4 retro

michael kors outlet online

cheap jordans for sale

air jordan shoes

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

pandora bracelet

nike outlet store

pandora rings

canada goose

cheap nba jersey

michael kors handbags sale

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet

christian louboutin uk

ugg outlet

polo outlet

christian louboutin shoes

kate spade bags

adidas shoes for men

fitflop sandals

fitflops sale

nike trainers

michael kors outlet online

giuseppe zanotti outlet

polo ralph lauren

michael kors outlet store

polo outlet

ralph lauren outlet

polo outlet

michael kors outlet

canada goose outlet

longchamp outlet store

michael kors outlet clearance

yeezy boost 350

kate spade outlet

valentino shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

polo outlet

coach outlet store online

moncler outlet

fred perry polo shirts

pandora jewelry sale

ralph lauren polo shirts

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

valentino outlet

oakley sunglasses

cheap oakley sunglasses

fitflops shoes

christian louboutin sale

prada outlet online

polo outlet

mcm backpack

coach outlet store online

ray ban sunglasses outlet

cheap jordans

adidas outlet store

mcm bag

polo ralph lauren outlet

lacoste shirts

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ralph lauren shirts

jordan shoes

pandora jewelry

pandora outlet

canada goose outlet store

polo outlet

ralph lauren outlet

christian louboutin shoes

michael kors outlet online

ray ban sunglasses

vintage nhl jerseys

polo ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet

cheap nfl jerseys

fred perry polo

pandora outlet online

coach outlet store online

pandora charms

coach outlet store online

polo ralph lauren

longchamp handbags

nike outlet

pandora jewelry outlet

tory burch shoes

canada goose outlet store

polo shirts

cheap uggs

mbt outlet

pandora charms

canada goose outlet

coach outlet

mulberry uk

ralph lauren polo

surgical light operating

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。
Type the characters you see in this picture. (使用语音验证)
填入上图所示的数字或者单词;如果你看不清,点击保存按钮,系统会为您重新生成您新的图片。不区分大小写。