韩寒作品被诉虚假宣传 是否获新概念一等奖引争议

央广网北京10月8日消息 据中国之声《新闻晚高峰》报道,1998年,《萌芽》杂志社和全国7所著名大学共同发起“新概念作文大赛”,新概念作文没有题材限制,30岁以下均可报名参加。这个作文比赛自创建之日起,就一直引人关注。新概念作文比赛捧红了很多年轻作家,比如韩寒、郭敬明等。

“首届新概念大赛社会组一等奖”,这个头衔成为青年作家韩寒早期被社会所认知的标签之一,近年来,关于韩寒是否找人“代笔”成为很多人津津乐道的话题,这些人质疑他的成功是通过作弊、别人代笔、团队包装等不正常手段取得的。

今天下午,一起有关的案件在沈阳和平区法院开庭——因为沈阳万卷出版公司2010年7月出版的《像少年啦飞驰》在封面介绍中对作者韩寒的描述中写有“1999年首届新概念作文比赛一等奖”,网名为“司马三忌”的网友 杨宏伟 提起诉讼,认为这一宣传语“涉嫌虚构事实侵害消费者利益”。

早在去年,杨宏伟就申请上海市政府依法公开《萌芽杂志社》首届新概念作文大赛参赛者韩寒获奖的评奖信息,以期证明韩寒涉嫌抄袭,当时,上海市政府驳回了杨宏伟的申请,理由是相关信息不在公开范围之内。杨宏伟不服,便把上海市政府告上了法庭。上海市第二中级人民法院当庭作出判决,驳回了原告杨宏伟的诉讼请求。

事情并没有画上句号,今年8月19日,杨宏伟起诉出版文集《零下一度》的上海世纪出版集团案开庭;同时,他起诉《萌芽》杂志社一案也正在等待开庭通知。

由于今天的庭审不允许录音,记者找到了原告杨宏伟。在他看来,关于是否涉及虚假宣传,是确认韩寒是否获奖的关键。对于他起诉的《萌芽》杂志社一案,杨宏伟认为,《萌芽》杂志社应该拿出完整的那一届比赛的评审记录:

杨宏伟:能够证明韩寒是否得奖的两处资料保存单位,一个是公证处,一个是萌芽杂志社,那从公证处看肯定没有韩寒了。我们要求通过法律途径,要求萌芽提供(证据),韩寒获奖,破格不要紧,补考也不要紧,但是你必须拿出大赛评委会的评审记录。

今年3月,杨宏伟曾向公证处查阅那一年的新概念作文比赛的获奖名单,却发现经过公证的名单和组委会公布的名单并不一样——经过公证的获奖名单里,并没有韩寒。

当时,一名《萌芽》杂志社负责人在接受中国之声采访时曾承认,当年由于人手不足,存在疏忽。但强调参加补考最终获奖的韩寒,名字的确是补进了获奖名单中并经过公证:

《萌芽》杂志社负责人:当时因为我们萌芽的人手也非常少,当时大家也疏忽了这件事情,只关注了大会的事情。因为我们的党组书记在宣布名单的时候把这个都宣布了,就说有这么一个情况,B组是5名(获奖)。所以在给他的第一份材料里面,是4名,就是这么一个疏漏。

记者:5名(获奖)的名单有没有经过公证呢?

《萌芽》杂志社负责人:当然经过公证了,当时就去公证了。

按照《萌芽》杂志社的说法——韩寒补获奖也是经过公证的,那么在全部的公证材料中,是否存在一份后来补上的公证材料呢?当时黄浦公证处的负责人予以否认:

记者:《萌芽》杂志社,他说韩寒是后来公布之前后补上去的一个名单,也是公证过了。

公证处负责人:这个没有,我们公证书里没找到,没这个名字的。

此前《萌芽》方面曾表示,不会就此事主动与质疑者联系、回应。目前,杨宏伟诉沈阳万卷出版公司一案的庭审正在进行中,据了解,沈阳和平区法院已经向《萌芽》杂志社以及上海黄埔公证处依法调取了1999年首届新概念作文大赛的相关档案证据,在本次庭审过程中公开质证。有关这起事件的最新进展,中国之声将持续关注。

原文地址:http://news.sina.com.cn/o/2014-10-08/173730958887.shtml?bsh_bid=50657976...

 

分类: 

参与评分: 

平均评分: 5 (10个评价)

评论

韩二,  出来骗是要还的.

访客的头像

韩二,  出来骗是要还的.

韩二这个文学白痴披着民主自由的画皮,  冒充作家和80后的代表,  大肆骗钱.

 

韩寒骗子团伙最大的硬伤是什么呢 ?   韩二胸无点墨,  韩二掌握的文史哲方面的知识少得可怜,  韩二就是文学白痴.

骗子团伙非要把韩二当作民主自由革命的传声筒和意见代表,  这不可笑么 ?!

假如韩二敢举行读者见面交流会,  和读者当面谈论文学历史哲学,  倒寒网友必定不再倒寒.

韩二,  你该展示你的知识才华了 !

哈哈哈

电影虽然属于娱乐范畴,  但是也算艺术领域的东西.  如果以后韩二骗子团伙还涉足文学艺术领域,  让韩二挂名,  必定会招致更猛烈的倒寒浪潮,   韩二只会自取其辱.  不信走着瞧 !

 

倒寒应当再接再厉.  不能懈怠.

http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_a2bdd38301012ou3.html

请广泛传播.

chenlina20170719

chenlina的头像

chenlina20170719

michael kors

ralph lauren

gucci shoes

prada outlet online

rolex datejust

tory burch outlet

michael kors taschen

celine outlet

true religion jeans

yeezy 350

chelsea jersey

ralph lauren outlet

polo ralph lauren

yeezy 350

coach outlet

louis vuitton outlet stores

cheap ray ban sunglasses

toms wedges

polo ralph lauren outlet

michael kors uk

retro jordans

toms outlet

supra shoes

mac cosmetics outlet

miami heat jerseys

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

cheap jerseys

yeezy boost 350 v2

ray ban sunglasses

ralph lauren outlet

vibram fivefingers

ray ban sunglasses

kate spade outlet online

coach outlet

the north face

borse louis vuitton

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors handbags

vans shoes

air jordan

kate spade handbags

jordan 4

michael kors outlet

bulls jerseys

rolex watches

michael kors canada

pandora jewelry

oakley sunglasses

oakley sunglasses

oakley sunglasses

timberland boots uk

ralph lauren uk

louboutin outlet

vikings jerseys

louboutin pas cher

louis vuitton outlet stores

salomon shoes

michael kors handbags

nike running

prada sunglasses

oakley canada

christian louboutin outlet

jordan 8

ed hardy clothing

patriots jerseys

ray ban sunglasses

nfl jerseys cheap

snapbacks hats

fred perry outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

the north face

adidas yeezy

hermes outlet

mcm outlet

fitflops sandals

christian louboutin uk

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet canada

rolex datejust

ray ban zonnebril

michael kors

nike outlet store

ralph lauren

burberry outlet

louis vuitton outlet

clippers jerseys

salvatore ferragamo

polo outlet

kate spade outlet

toms shoes

christian louboutin outlet

giuseppe zanotti

ray-ban sunglasses

fitflops outlet

ralph lauren uk

coach factory outlet

yeezy 350

oakley sunglasses

wizards jerseys

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

cheap jordan shoes

polo ralph lauren

michael kors handbags

cleveland cavaliers jerseys

coach handbags

manchester united jersey

michael kors taschen

louboutin shoes

oakley sunglasses

coach outlet

kate spade

gucci handbags

ray ban canada

ralph lauren polo

pandora charms

adidas outlet

christian louboutin

louis vuitton handbags

lebron shoes

adidas nmd

pandora jewelry

michael kors outlet

louis vuitton outlet

michael kors tote

chaussures christian louboutin

burberry sale

vans shoes

louis vuitton belt

oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet

louis vuitton outlet

clarks shoes

michael kors

birkenstock outlet

michael kors handbags

hermes handbags

clarks shoes

ralph lauren

mavericks jerseys

ray ban sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

celine handbags

gucci outlet online

kate spade outlet

montre rolex

hermes uk

tory burch outlet

pittsburgh steelers jerseys

longchamp outlet

coach factory outlet

columbia sportswear

moncler jacke

christian louboutin

columbia outlet

coach outlet

michael kors outlet online

adidas stan smith

nike outlet

gafas ray ban

boston celtics jerseys

nfl jerseys cheap

nike outlet

cheap jordans

mbt shoes

instyler max

adidas yeezy

ferragamo shoes

jordan 6

louis vuitton outlet

oakley store

michael kors uk

true religion sale

coach factory outlet

coach outlet

louis vuitton outlet

coach factory outlet

cheap nfl jerseys

occhiali ray ban

michael kors outlet

michael kors handbags

replica rolex watches

polo ralph lauren

michael kors uk

timberland boots

asics shoes

toms outlet

kobe shoes

michael kors outlet

bengals jerseys

jordan femme pas cher

coach purses

ray ban solglasögon

thunder jerseys

polo ralph lauren outlet

christian louboutin uk

ugg outlet

under armour outlet

polo ralph lauren

kate spade outlet store

pandora rings

oakley sunglasses

oakley sunglasses

nike outlet

burberry handbags

adidas yeezy boost 350 v2

true religion outlet

christian louboutin outlet

ray ban sunglasses

fitflop sandals

pandora jewelry

burberry outlet online

jordan 3

adidas yeezy

polo ralph lauren

adidas yeezy boost 350

the north face jackets

adidas nmd r1

kobe shoes

michael kors handbags

mont blanc pens

the north face

michael kors outlet

ray ban eyeglasses

new balance shoes

christian louboutin sale

christian louboutin

louis vuitton outlet

polo ralph lauren

rolex submariner

louboutin pas cher

nike football boots

ray ban sunglasses

warriors jerseys

wholesale ray ban sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

yeezy boost 350

polo ralph lauren

asics shoes

longchamp pas cher

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors canada

ugg boots

ralph lauren uk

michael kors taschen

nfl jerseys wholesale

michael kors väska

nike roshe run pas cher

coach factory outlet

north face

broncos jerseys

kevin durant shoes

nike outlet store

nike air max pas cher

seahawks jerseys

michael kors outlet

coach factory outlet

timberland boots

adidas stan smith shoes

rolex watch

louis vuitton

adidas yeezy

tory burch outlet

louis vuitton handbags

air max

louis vuitton purses

louis vuitton outlet

rolex watches

christian louboutin outlet

yeezy boost 350

louis vuitton outlet

beats by dre

louis vuitton handbags

polo ralph lauren

nhl jerseys

polo ralph lauren

knicks jerseys

louis vuitton handbags

burberry outlet

kate spade outlet

air jordan 14

nike roshe run

coach outlet

coach factory outlet

coach factory outlet

replica watches

ferragamo belt

sac louis vuitton

michael kors taschen

clarks outlet

ugg boots

nike soccer shoes

louis vuitton outlet online

louis vuitton outlet

cheap mlb jerseys

calvin klein jeans

michael kors handbags

manolo blahnik

ralph lauren outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

converse shoes

polo ralph lauren uk

converse shoes

adidas shoes

coach outlet

timberland outlet

louis vuitton outlet

jordan 13

michael kors

polo ralph lauren

michael kors outlet

ralph lauren polo

ralph lauren polo

michael kors handbags

mlb jerseys

sac longchamp

ray ban wayfarer

retro jordan shoes

jordan retro

adidas yeezy boost 350

timberland boots

retro jordans

coach outlet

michael kors väska

kate spade outlet

ray ban uk

beats by dr dre

adidas stan smith

adidas football boots

prada bags

lunettes ray ban

christian louboutin uk

ugg boots

coach outlet

tory burch

seahawks jerseys

tory burch outlet

rolex watches for sale

oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin shoes

vans store

michael kors handbags

burberry outlet

adidas soccer shoes

adidas neo

tommy hilfiger outlet

mcm outlet

fitflop sale

michael kors taschen

polo ralph lauren outlet

michael kors bags

coach factory outlet

oakley vault

michael kors outlet

christian louboutin shoes

cheap basketball shoes

coach outlet

giuseppe zanotti shoes

louis vuitton handbags

lauren ralph lauren

michael kors outlet

canada goose sale

louis vuitton outlet

michael kors canada

longchamp handbags

columbia sportswear

hermes belt

coach factory outlet

tory burch sandals

prada outlet

michael jordan shoes

oakley sunglasses

spurs jerseys

chenlina20170719

Dreamland Jewelry - Official

lzm的头像

Dreamland Jewelry - Official

burberry outlet

The Retail Compliance Association

pandora jewelry sale

citizen watches

north face sale

Nike Air Jordan Enfants

louis vuitton

kate spade handbags

omega watches

michael kors

prada purses

pandora uk

nike jordan shoes

prada outlet online

michael kors outlet

ugg boots

diesel watches

Air Max 90 Femme

tiffany co

nike air max 95

Nike Air Force 1 Homme

pandora charms sale clearance

Nike Air Max 90 pas cher france

Nike Air Jordan enfants

birkenstock canada

kate spade outlet store

hermes belt

coach bags

sunglasses

canada goose sale online

Nike Boots

coach outlet store

Air Jordan Retro 3

oakley holbrook.

moncler us

balenciaga outlet

puma suede outlet

pandora jewelry

Nike Schuhe Herren

michael kors

Nike Air Max 1

louis vuitton australia

boulder shoes sew repair

coach outlet

under armour stock

Nike Free

yeezy shoes

nike huarache shoes

michael kors outlet

Nike Air Max Enfant

Jimmy Choo Shoes

fake sunglasses

Jordan Flight 45 Femme

Nike Zoom

coach outlet online sale

puma outlet

pandora deutschland

Abercrombie Fitch

pandora sale

burberry outlet

ray ban outlet

Nike Jordans

rayban prescription glasses

chrome store

Prada bags

louis vuitton outlet online

birkenstock outlet

rayban prescription sunglasses

Dreamland Jewelry - Official

nike shoes

ray ban sunglasses sale

louboutin shoes

yeezy boost 350 shoes

michael kors outlet online

michael kors outlet online

Air Jordan Homme

michael kors watches

ray ban wayfarer

Pharmacy Discount Network

Nike Free

prada outlet online

nike shox

coach carter

Adamson

michael kors

official michael kors

michael kors outlet online

chrome store

wayfarer sunglasses

under armour

homepage keywords

tiffany co

michael kors bags

hermes bag

Nike Air Max

coach factory outlet

birkenstock sandals

coach outlet

coach outlet

lzm8.5

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。
Type the characters you see in this picture. (使用语音验证)
填入上图所示的数字或者单词;如果你看不清,点击保存按钮,系统会为您重新生成您新的图片。不区分大小写。