韩寒视频分析(一) 不知为不知 作者:安芃

土豆网就新概念作文大赛获奖事采访韩寒(http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XMzcwNDQxNDE2.html 2630秒左右),记者在电脑上出示韩寒获奖作文《杯里窥人》的手稿图像,说是从网上得到的,应该不存在PS

 

 

记者向韩寒显示《杯里窥人》手稿

 

韩寒说:“对,是我写的。”这个不奇怪,韩寒再傻,也不敢说不是他写的,那样的话,会有很多人进班房的。

 

行,既然韩寒说这篇文章是自己写的,那么,现在面对记者,机会来了,韩寒应该抓住这个机会好好地表现一下,以证明这篇文章是自己写的。

 

其实一个作家要自证并不难,如果这篇文章真是你自己写的,那你应该可以好好谈一下你的写作思路,比如当时看到水杯中一张纸,究竟是怎么想的,为什么一下就 想到人性,而不是一只狗或者一头猪,不是宇宙或者大自然。为什么杯中明明是纸,却要冒着跑题的危险写成布,作为作者,一定会有很靠谱很有说服力的理由(这 理由本来在文章中就应该出现的,但是没有出现),现在机会来了,应该好好说明一下吧。不管说什么,关于你自己写的这篇文章,多多少少总应该说出一点道道来 吧。

 

看到这里,其实我也很期待,希望韩寒这时能够说出点让人信服的东西来。但韩寒这时是怎么做的呢?

 

面对这么好的自证机会,韩寒居然没能陈述任何写作思路,只是开始照着电脑屏幕念稿子:“我想到的是人性,尤其是中国的民族劣根性。鲁迅先生阐之未尽,我有我的看法”。

 

 

 

 

 

韩寒对着电脑屏幕念稿子

 

如果这篇文章真是韩寒自己写的,如果他想自证,这里也有很好的机会。你说鲁迅先生阐之未尽,你为什么会这么认为?鲁迅先生有过什么样的阐述,哪个方面是鲁迅先生没有讲到的,这些文章中都没有提到,你既然写到这点,应该有自己的想法,何不说来听听?

 

但是韩寒并没有提供任何这方面的思路,而是继续往下念稿子:“然后开始写《三字经》,‘人之初,性本善’,说明人刚出生好比这团干干后面有一个字。”

 

 

韩寒《杯里窥人》手稿,“干”字后面划掉一个字

 

这时记者问:“对,这个你是划的什么呀?”

 

 

记者问:“对,这个你是划的什么呀?”

 

这次采访的关键点就在这里,韩寒对这个问题的回答是:“我也不知道。”

 

韩寒的回答:“我也不知道”

 

这个很搞,如果这篇文章真的是你写的,你对这个问题的回答是“我也不知道”吗?这可能吗?绝对不可能!

 

想想看,如果这篇文章真是你自己写的,你对这个问题的回答,只有两种可能。一种是你仍然记得那是个什么字,你可以侃侃而谈你当初写的是个什么字,为什么开 始写了这个字,为什么觉得这个字不妥又划掉了,后来为什么改成布,你尽可以说出你的思路,这是自证的最好的办法,也是自证最好的机会。另一种是你的确不记 得那是个什么字,如果是不记得,你会试图回忆,实在想不起来,也只能说“想不起来了”,“我忘了”,而绝对不会说“我也不知道”。

 

韩寒回答“我也不知道”,那是他不假思索的第一反应,是下意识的真情流露,因为他真的是不知道(而不是忘记了)那个被划掉的是个什么字,因为这篇文章根本就不是他自己写的。

 

这次采访本来是韩寒用来自证的最好机会,但他不但没能证明这篇文章是他自己写的,反而证明了这篇文章根本就不是他写的。

原文地址:http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_13b61999f0102v6ur.html

分类: 

参与评分: 

平均评分: 4.9 (8个评价)

评论

要坚决追究韩骗一伙的刑事责任!

magnificent. nfl jerseys the

wty123的头像

magnificent. nfl jerseys the nfl redskins boy pandora bracelets fell adidas sneakers to adidas shoes his michael kors bags knees, ralph lauren uk crying up. prada sunglasses he levis outlet store thanked bos jersey God toms outlet that kobe bryant jersey he polo ralph lauren believed coach factory outlet online his coach factory online destiny, minnesota timberwolves so iphone 4s cases that nfl steelers one nike outlet day air jordan he swarovski crystal met portland trail blazers a michael kors outlet online sale sage, nfl broncos a hermes birkin crystal michael kors handbags shop tommy hilfiger owner, northface an prada outlet Englishman, prada and beats by dre an oakley black friday alchemist, nba jerseys especially pandora the ray ban black friday desert ray ban sunglasses met cheap basketball shoes a woman, coach factory outlet online this michael kors bags woman converse shoes made pandora jewellery him barbour mens jackets understand converse outlet that air max 2015 love rolex never nike air max 2014 let oakley sunglasses a nike free shoes person ralph lauren away burberry handbags from dre beats their watches destiny. longchamp experienced timberland homme many oakley outlet centuries new balance store of air max shoes Egyptian occhiali oakley pyramid nfl raiders have.Thank nike outlet you, prada handbags little rolex replica horse!If ed hardy clothing you, adidas shoes outlet like wedding dresses uk a tory burch shoes deep new balance and salomon schuhe passionate feelings, polo ralph lauren I roshes can nfl falcons not nba jerseys understand. A cheap michael kors person in bottega such juicy couture warm bottega veneta years, knicks jerseys is ralph lauren a christian louboutin shoes gift katespade outlet given nike air max to mcm handbags me nfl lions the best hermes outlet gift.That burberry outlet online sentence at cheap true religion the beginning kate spade of toms outlet a polo ralph lauren outlet online year ray ban sunglasses ago, salvatore ferragamo looks nike store like nfl buccaneers you adidas superstar said. michael kors purses A cheap jerseys few days mcm bags ago, nike.de you toronto raptors asked toms shoes me babyliss which juicy couture clothings one calvin klein you longchamp handbags belong jordans for sale to, toms.com you michael kors outlet online should nfl browns know ferragamo shoes it ray ban sunglasses outlet now. hollister online shop deutschland If beats by dre you true religion jeans women do abercrombie not baseball jerseys know, coach bags I long champ tell burberry uk you, soccer shoes "small louboutin outlet horse, orlando magic a louboutin shoes warm rayban sunglasses man nike huarache in nike outlet my cheap jerseys life." celine black friday Such pandora an coach outlet online encounter michael kors outlet online very nike air grateful, roshe run because burberry you have dsquared2 jeans such scarpe hogan an replica watches experience mia jersey and michael kors outlet online sale alerted the p90x workout schedule world nfl vikings to lunette oakley pas cher have nike air max a hilfiger outlet feeling michael kors like kate spade outlet online that. swarovski jewelry If replica watches you new balance can air jordan retro not puma outlet store appreciate nike roshe such air jordan shoes a air max 90 warm hollister clothing store and nfl packers happy michael kors outlet and mbt shoes outlet happy ralph lauren shirts for coach outlet my michael kors handbags people, nfl titans warm nfl chiefs the nike free run Love swarovski and instyler ionic styler make www.tommyhilfiger.nl life more the north face of polo ralph lauren outlet a cheap jerseys gorgeous womens hoodies color. polo ralph lauren outlet Is the north face set toms shoes to longchamp outlet have, ray-ban sunglasses it designer handbags is tommy hilfiger perfect.Accompanied jordan shoes by michael kors two true religion decades coach outlet later, cheap glasses you burberry are polo ralph lauren perfectly tory burch sale done, oakley I mcm outlet am celine handbags very coach outlet sale happy, burberry sale thank montre pas cher you!So, supra footwear you air max are hermes bags happy!2013.3.20"Six" of nfl eagles time coach black friday and pistons jersey space gsw jerseys - nike air force a ferragamo visionary.Surging ray ban wayfarer crowd, coach handbags outlet and michael kors outlet online from cheap jerseys intensive, mont blanc pens only swarovski fantasy adidas.de and bcbg dresses lost, kate spade outlet there ray ban outlet is ray ban no ray ban sunglasses reason, longchamp outlet no huaraches signs, washington wizards but russell westbrook jersey also vans outlet intimate with, to nike air hug and cheap nike shoes smile.Time uhren mob wholesale handbags can nfl giants not cheap oakley sunglasses be the north face outlet shared, beats audio because michael kors v?skor only this givenchy bags outlet time in swarovski australia their asics gel own dallas mavericks jersey and burberry online shop in free run the relojes especiales same giuseppe shoes time. oakley prescription The replica handbags witness nike online is soccer outlet online not tory burch sandals being clothing websites pulled converse chucks out of barbour outlet the michaelkors.com eyes indiana pacers of nop jerseys others.If coach black friday you red bottoms gratitude, ralph lauren tracksuits is nike mercurial vapor set kanye west shoes to nike free 5.0 have timberland shoes such los angeles clippers a nike huaraches definition, the north face and marc jacobs outlet bravery tory burch shoes persisted nfl bears forward.Only I, philipp plein clothes at converse this polo ralph time toms outlet there. philadelphia 76ers jersey Wander jerseys from china alone, michael kors with ray ban zonnebril lonely mcm bags and omega watches isolated michael kors outlet I softball bats think free running particularly emotional, thomas sabo hang shoes on sale some true religion jeans outlet old, christian louboutin still louboutin young.There thomas sabo uk is such ralph lauren factory store a, reebok you tommy hilfiger outlet stores must hogan adhere nike mercurial to louboutin the polo outlet online harvest, nfl colts freedom burberry bags outlet and nike air max lonely burberry outlet days.There bcbg max azria is sac jerseys such toms shoes outlet a, north face jackets fantasy, cheap oakley continuing oakley outlet online the search michael kors australia for jimmy choo and kevin durant shoeskobe bryant shoes proud ray ban of burberry outlet online the nike outlet store time.Dawn hollister is jerseys from china beautiful, marc jacobs handbags the adidas only nets jersey time coach outlet in ralph lauren polo the nfl chargers rotation nfl cowboys of ua stephen curry their north face backpacks own, vans shoes there michael kors black friday is charlotte hornets jersey narcissistic ralph lauren black friday and san antonio spurs indifferent north face outlet to cheap oakley sunglasses pull oakley off.Sunset timberland outlet in lunette ray ban pas cher good, gafas oakley if nfl bills woke cheap true religion up, coach factory outlet online everything chicago bulls changed, flat iron we can nfl rams return prada outlet to roshe run the milwaukee bucks original giuseppe zanotti dream.Sit suns jerseys on new balance the 11th nike tn requin floor air max 95 of puma the coach purses balcony, rayban the timberland boots sun barbour women jackets shines michael kors bags in pandora rings a michael kors good nfl azcardinals smell adidas.se taste, coach outlet online warm, true religion outlet with roche run shares barbour mens jackets irresistible jerseys from china breath, and asics slowly spread ray ban sunglasses in longchamp black friday the oakley sunglasses air.Named shop coach factory to nfl saints a hollister co cup nike free shoes of nfl 49ers "Love ray ban in vans schuhe the nfl dolphins time", but oakley sunglasses outlet is longchamp taschen against cheap oakley the nfl bengals strawberry jimmy choo shoes and nike air max 2015 juice ralph lauren out ray bans pretty coach factory outlet online pink, oakley sunglasses outlet in air jordans a glass, nike.com but iphone 5 cases a plein outlet kind houston rockets of ralph lauren online fragmented tommy hilfiger online shop feeling.Walking time, mcm backpack outlet intermittent replica watches time, nfl patriots every armani clothing day michael kors bags walking, cheap michael kors I toms outlet walk cheap oakley sunglasses every chrome hearts jewelry day michael kors handbags more utah jazz and baseball bats more michael kors bags long burberry handbags time. oakley sunglasses cheap Some nike air max stubborn zapatillas nike factor michael kors within chi hair the louboutins body, nfl panthers try fendi outlet online to burberry handbags be north face pas cher brave ralph lauren outlet online is air max 2014 becoming jordan release dates increasingly designer handbags apparent.This ralph lauren uk time, ecco women shoes the fake rolex window versace shoes outlet of ray ban outlet the valentino shoes outlet King, barbour women jackets is nfl seahawks a hilfiger green, ralph lauren outlet because michael kors purses under denver nuggets the nike.dk rain's woolrich outlet online sake. Branches hollister kids full oakley of nfl ravens buds, lacoste polos it memphis grizzlies becomes nfl jets odd hugo boss outlet good pandora mood, rayban as cleveland cavaliers jerseys this nike.se was mizuno running shoes the nike roshe most coach outlet beautiful nfl jaguars seasons replica rolex of cheap eyeglasses spring.A air max person, north face quiet burberry handbags time cheap ray ban alone, nfl texans is adidas neo lonely hollister pondering ralph lauren outlet begin vibram shoes fingertips new balance shoes dolls, dsquared2 shoes but nba jerseys also swarovski against longchamp

burberry outlet online

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。
Type the characters you see in this picture. (使用语音验证)
填入上图所示的数字或者单词;如果你看不清,点击保存按钮,系统会为您重新生成您新的图片。不区分大小写。