韩寒视频分析(三) 关于“思想价值” 作者: 安芃



  韩寒在访谈中极少谈文学。

 

但在何东的非常道节目访谈中,韩寒破天荒地开始谈文学了(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xsM0ODtH2OA 2340秒)。

 

难得,我洗耳恭听,想瞧瞧这位知名作家对文学究竟有什么样的高见。

 

我下面引用韩寒谈文学的原话:

 

 

“很多人都把所,所谓的那些思想价值摆在第一位。其实有什么思想,思想价值可以在那里谈论的呢?所以...我我我...我并不这么想,我觉得什么东西都有它的思想价值的,所以它们都是平等的。”

 

接下来我就来考察一下韩寒这一段关于文学作品的高见吧。

 

首先声明一下,本人只是个IT人,对文学是外行,但就在我这个外行人看起来,也觉得韩寒发表的高见十二分离谱。

 

先看第一句,“很多人都把所谓的那些思想价值摆在第一位”。

 

我 不知道为什么韩寒会在这里突出“思想价值”这个词,尽管我不在文化圈内,但就我的印象,现在的文学评论很少用到“思想价值”这个词,对文学作品,论者似乎 更多地看重其文学艺术价值,创作方法上创新,是否能提供阅读快感,是否具备社会教化功能这些方面,很少人会去深究作品的思想价值。

 

但既然韩寒一定要谈“思想价值”,那我们先谈谈“思想价值”吧。

 

什 么是文学作品的思想价值呢?我不知道“思想价值”这个词是否有官方定义。以我这个文学门外汉的看法,一部文学作品的思想价值,应该指的是这部作品表达出来 的对人类,对社会,对宇宙,对大自然,以及对地球上所有生命个体(包括人,动物和植物)的一种悲天悯人的终极关怀和基于这种关怀下的独特的思考。

 

思想价值,才是一部作品的核心价值,也是我们中文文学作品中最缺乏的东西。把思想价值摆在第一位的做法并没有错,只是我们现在并没有这样做。如果真的把思想价值摆在第一位,那我们很多的文学作品,尤其是象《三重门》这样虚假阴暗毫无思想价值的东西根本就没有资格出版。

 

再看韩寒的第二句话,“其实有什么思想价值可以在那里谈论的呢?”

 

韩寒这句话语焉不详,如果他的这句话只是指以他的名字出版的《三重门》,那我没有意见。不过,他的这句话并没有指定某一部文学作品,应该说的是所有的文学作品,这样他等于否定了所有文学作品的思想价值,对此,我只能用四个字评价:胡说八道。

 

最后一句,“我觉得什么东西都有它的思想价值的,所以它们都是平等的。”

 

这 一句更搞,上半句“我觉得什么东西都有它的思想价值的”,直接硬生生地否定了前一句他自己说的“其实有什么思想价值可以在那里谈论的呢?”,前后矛盾,出 尔反尔,见过自己打自己嘴巴的,但没见过抽得这么猛的。韩少啊,不但文学观念方面是白痴水平,逻辑思维方面也是白痴水平。

 

下半句,“所以它们都是平等的”,又是语焉不详。我的理解,既然说的是思想价值,他的意思应该指的是所有的文学作品在思想价值上都是平等的。

 

那么我想问韩少一句,你的《三重门》跟多年前流行的手抄文学作品《少女之心》在思想价值上是平等的吗?

 

如果你回答是,我对这一点没有异议。

 

那我再问你,你的《三重门》跟奥威尔的《1984》,跟雨果的《九三年》,《悲惨世界》,跟托尔斯泰的《战争与和平》,《复活》,跟陀思妥耶夫斯基的《罪与罚》,《被侮辱与被损害的》等世界经典名著在思想价值上也是平等的吗?

 

如果你的回答依然是是,那么我也依然是四个字的评价:胡说八道。

 

算了,对一个叫嚣“文坛算个屁,谁也别装逼”的混混,对一个洋洋自得地声称从来不读世界名著并且不以为耻反以为荣的无知半文盲,我们能期望什么呢?要指望他懂得文学作品的思想价值,太难为他了。

 

这就是韩少,好容易谈一次文学,就说了三句话,还说得颠三倒四,前后矛盾,结结巴巴,语无伦次的,这就是韩寒真实的文学水平,说白了就俩字:白痴。

 

原文地址: http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_13b61999f0102v7i6.html

分类: 

参与评分: 

平均评分: 4.7 (12个评价)

评论

20170715lck

liuchunkai的头像

20170715lck

kate spade handbags

 

air max 90

 

mbt shoes outlet

 

true religion jeans

 

rolex outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

hermes outlet

 

polo ralph lauren

 

coach outlet store

 

michael kors uk

 

jordan shoes

 

birkenstock shoes

 

polo ralph lauren

 

ferragamo shoes sale

 

juicy couture tracksuit

 

longchamp outlet

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

nike free running

 

true religion jeans

 

adidas wings shoes

 

cheap jerseys wholesale

 

puma shoes

 

swarovski jewellery

 

christian louboutin

 

mont blanc outlet

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

coach outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

louis vuitton outlet stores

 

cheap jerseys wholesale

 

pandora charms

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

rolex watches,rolex replica watches,replica rolex watches,replica watches

 

gucci outlet online

 

canada goose outlet

 

coach outlet

 

kate spade handbags

 

burberry outlet store

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

polo pas cher

 

michael kors outlet

 

tory burch outlet online

 

true religion jeans outlet

 

cazal outlet

 

burberry canada

 

yeezy boost

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

herve leger dresses

 

lacoste outlet

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

pandora charms sale clearance

 

louis vuitton

 

oakley sunglasses

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

air max 90

 

pandora jewellery

 

coach outlet clearance

 

nba jerseys

 

michael kors outlet

 

true religion outlet

 

snapbacks wholesale

 

mcm backpacks

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

michael kors outlet stores

 

oakley sunglasses sale

 

mulberry handbags

 

true religion jeans

 

gucci outlet

 

pandora outlet

 

soccer cleats

 

longchamp

 

swarovski uk

 

gucci outlet online

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

nike air max

 

coach factory outlet

 

roshe run

 

michael kors outlet online

 

pandora outlet

 

kate spade uk

 

nfl jersey wholesale

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

cheap jordan shoes

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

true religion jeans sale

 

ralph lauren

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

michael kors handbags

 

michael kors outlet online

 

adidas shoes

 

louis vuitton bags

 

nike outle

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

tory burch outlet stores

 

ralph lauren shirts

 

coach outlet online

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

cheap nike shoes

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

coach outlet clearance

 

polo outlet stores

 

ralph lauren uk

 

ralph lauren

 

ray-ban sunglasses

 

swarovski jewelry

 

air max trainers

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet store online

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

adidas nmd

 

nba jerseys wholesale

 

nike shoes

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

adidas outlet

 

new balance outlet

 

louis vuitton handbags

 

mont blanc pens

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

michael kors factory outlet

 

michael kors outlet store

 

birkenstock shoes

 

longchamp

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

michael kors uk

 

louis vuitton outlet store

 

louis vuitton

 

adidas outlet

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

true religion jeans sale

 

lacoste shirts

 

ralph lauren uk

 

salomon outlet

 

canada goose coats

 

oakley sunglasses sale

 

nfl jerseys

 

michael kors outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

uggs outlet

 

true religion uk

 

nike shoes for women

 

cheap jordan shoes

 

michael kors outlet online

 

coach outlet store online

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

cheap jordans free shipping

 

nike air huarache

 

adidas shoes

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

ecco outlet

 

michael kors handbags

 

michael kors uk

 

coach outlet online

 

max 1

 

nike outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses outlet

 

nike outlet store online

 

pandora bracelet

 

instyler

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

supra shoes sale

 

cheap mlb jerseys

 

swarovski jewelry

 

marc jacobs sale

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

christian louboutin sale

 

coach outlet

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

ferragamo outlet

 

coach factory outlet

 

prada outlet

 

oakley sunglasses sale

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

ugg outlet,ugg outlet clearance,uggs outlet,ugg outlet online clearance,ugg outlet store,ugg outlet online store,ugg outlet sale,ugg outlet coupons,ugg outlet boots

 

air max shoes

 

adidas uk store

 

coach outlet clearance

 

pandora jewelry

 

los angeles lakers

 

mulberry handbags

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

coach outlet

 

kate spade

 

coach outlet online

 

true religion outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet online

 

mulberry outlet,mulberry handbags outlet

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

nike outlet store online

 

cheap jordan shoes

 

nike trainers

 

nfl jersey wholesale

 

christian louboutin sale

 

true religion canada

 

cheap jordans

 

michael kors handbags

 

prada outlet

 

true religion outlet store

 

ralph lauren outlet stores

 

coach outlet online

 

michael kors outlet

 

snapbacks wholesale

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

coach outlet online

 

christian louboutin uk

 

ray bans

 

mizuno shoes

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

cheap ray bans

 

lacoste pas cher

 

ugg outlet,uggs outlet,ugg outlet online clearance,ugg outlet store,ugg outlet coupons,ugg outlet boots,ugg outlet online store,ugg outlet sale

 

polo outlet

 

mac cosmetics sale

 

rolex watches outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

louis vuitton handbags

 

louis vuitton uk

 

tory burch outlet

 

louis vuitton

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

lacoste polo

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

canada goose jackets

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

swarovski crystal

 

adidas nmd runner

 

pandora jewelery

 

coach factory outlet

 

polo ralph lauren

 

cheap nba jerseys

 

Nike Free shoes

 

coach outlet store online

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

coach outlet store online

 

kobe 9 elite

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

polo outlet

 

yeezy boost 350

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

max 90

 

snapback hats

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

bottega veneta outlet online

 

hermes outlet store

 

coach outlet

 

longchamp handbags

 

polo outlet online

 

nike store uk

 

ray ban wayfarer

 

hermes belts

 

coach outlet clearance

 

coach outlet

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

christian louboutin

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

ferragamo shoes

 

mbt shoes outlet

 

sac louis vuitton pas cher

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

polo ralph lauren

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

coach outlet

 

longchamp outlet online

 

michael kors outlet

 

swarovski outlet

 

canada goose jackets

 

ray ban sunglasses uk

 

rolex watches

 

nfl jerseys

 

canada goose

 

tory burch handbags

 

asics,asics israel,asics shoes,asics running shoes,asics israel,asics gel,asics running,asics gel nimbus,asics gel kayano

 

vans outlet

 

uggs outlet

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

ferragamo shoes

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

oakley sunglasses

 

canada goose jackets

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

coach outlet

 

giuseppe zanotti shoes

 

cheap nfl jerseys

 

nike air huarache

 

links of london jewellery

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

louis vuitton

 

nike air max 1

 

louis vuitton

 

cleveland cavaliers jerseys

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

polo outlet

 

coach factory outlet

 

nhl jerseys wholesale

 

fitflops

 

hollister clothing store

 

gucci outlet online

 

fitflops

 

jordan 4

 

ralph?lauren

 

cartier outlet

 

polo ralph lauren

 

jerseys wholesale

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

polo ralph lauren

 

coach factory outlet

 

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

 

rolex watches,rolex watches,swiss watches,watches for men,watches for women,omega watches,replica watches,rolex watches for sale,rolex replica,rolex watch,cartier watches,rolex submariner,fake rolex,rolex replica watches,replica rolex

 

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

 

coach factory outlet

 

longchamp handbags

 

Basketball Shoes

 

coach outlet store online

 

ralph lauren

 

cartier watches for women

 

ferragamo outlet

 

chrome hearts outlet

 

air max 90

 

burberry outlet sale

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

rolex watches for sale

 

cheap football shirts

 

ed hardy outlet

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

tory burch outlet online

 

ferragamo shoes

 

coach outlet store online

 

nike air max 90

 

rolex uk

 

pandora outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

oakley sunglasses

 

nike shoes

 

coach factory outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

oakley sunglasses sale

 

rolex orologi

 

ysl outlet online

 

coach factory outlet

 

coach factory outlet

 

thomas sabo charms

 

christian louboutin sale

 

michael kors wallets for women

 

air force 1 shoes

 

coach factory outlet

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

cheap jordans for sale

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

mulberry handbags sale

 

michael kors outlet

 

adidas shoes

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

ralph lauren

 

nfl jersey

 

pandora outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet online

 

mulberry handbags sale

 

christian louboutin outlet

 

gucci borse

 

michael kors canada

 

coach outlet online

 

polo ralph lauren

 

ferragamo outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

longchamp handbags

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

soccer jerseys wholesale

 

mulberry outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

ralph lauren?uk

 

true religion outlet

 

longchamp outlet

 

cheap soccer jerseys

 

valentino shoes

 

mlb jerseys

 

true religion outlet

 

swarovski crystal

 

coach outlet online

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

reebok shoes

 

polo outlet store

 

coach outlet online

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

cartier watches for sale

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

ray ban sunglasses wholesale

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

louis vuitton outlet stores

 

ray ban sunglasses outlet

 

gucci outlet store

 

lebron shoes

 

polo outlet

 

omega outlet

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

nike uk store

 

coach outlet store online

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

nhl jerseys

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

louis vuitton

 

air max 90

 

ralph lauren polo

 

mbt shoes

 

ralph lauren outlet

 

ray-ban sunglasses

 

michael kors outlet

 

louis vuitton

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

fitflops sale clearance

 

coach outlet

 

polo ralph lauren

 

fitflops

 

michael kors uk

 

coach factory outlet

 

coach outlet

 

cheap nfl jerseys

 

tods outlet online

 

fred perry polo

 

cartier watches

 

michael kors outlet online

 

hermes birkin bag

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

cheap replica watches

 

michael kors outlet store

 

cheap jordan shoes

 

kate spade uk

 

mulberry outlet

 

canada goose outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

coach outlet store online

 

nike shoes uk

 

michael kors outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

louis vuitton borse

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

nike air max 90

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

hollister shirts

 

adidas shoes

 

michael kors handbags

 

tory burch outlet online

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

nike shoes outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

canada goose outlet store

 

coach outlet

 

gucci outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

coach outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

michael kors outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

michael kors outlet

 

kd shoes

 

true religion outlet

 

cartier watches

 

converse shoes sale

 

oakley sunglasses

 

chrome hearts online store

 

polo ralph lauren

 

louis vuitton outlet online

 

canada goose outlet store

 

prada sunglasses for women

 

kobe bryants shoes

 

louis vuitton

 

cheap ray ban sunglasses

 

polo outlet stores

 

true religion outlet uk

 

christian louboutin sale

 

gucci bags

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

nike trainers

 

canada goose uk

 

lebron shoes

 

louis vuitton

 

nike blazer pas cher

 

coach outlet

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

ralph lauren polo

 

ray ban sunglasses uk

 

michael kors outlet clearance

 

coach outlet store online

 

coach outlet online

 

kate spade outlet online

 

coach outlet

 

cheap jordans

 

ralph?lauren?polo?shirts

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

prada outlet online

 

michael kors outlet

 

ugg outlet

 

fitflops uk

 

tory burch sandals

 

michael kors outlet online

 

cheap oakley sunglasses

 

burberry outlet store

 

nike outlet online

 

coach factory outlet

 

ugg boots,ugg boots outlet,cheap uggs boots,ugg boots for women,ugg boots on sale,ugg boots clearance,ugg boots clearance sale women,ugg boots clearance outlet,ugg boots for men,ugg boots for kids

 

michael kors outlet online

 

nike trainers uk

 

ugg boots,ugg boots outlet,ugg boots for women,ugg boots on sale,ugg boots clearance,ugg boots for men,ugg boots for kids,ugg boots clearance sale women,ugg boots clearance outlet

 

mulberry handbags

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

michael kors outlet online

 

michael kors outlet online

 

michael kors outlet online

 

tory burch outlet online

 

camisetas futbol baratas

 

fitflops uk

 

coach outlet store online

 

christian louboutin shoes

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

true religion jeans

 

louis vuitton outlet stores

 

kobe shoes

 

polo ralph lauren outlet

 

nike roshe run

 

oakley sunglasses wholesale

 

air max 2015

 

cheap ray bans

 

mlb jerseys

 

rolex watches

 

ralph lauren uk

 

nike roshe run

 

mulberry uk

 

ray ban sunglasses

 

ralph lauren polo

 

reebok shoes

 

michael kors handbags

 

mulberry bags

 

basketball shoes,basketball sneakers,lebron james shoes,sports shoes,kobe bryant shoes,kobe sneakers,nike basketball shoes,running shoes,mens sport shoes,nike shoes

 

louis vuitton

 

coach outlet

 

coach handbags outlet

 

michael kors outlet online

 

foamposite shoes

 

coach outlet online

 

louis vuitton outlet

 

michael kors outlet clearance

20170715lck

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。
Type the characters you see in this picture. (使用语音验证)
填入上图所示的数字或者单词;如果你看不清,点击保存按钮,系统会为您重新生成您新的图片。不区分大小写。