上海二中院和徐汇法院的这个吃相已经很难看了 作者:司马3忌

今天同时收到二份民事裁定书。分别来自于上海二中院和上海徐汇法院,对本人起诉上海萌芽杂志社以及上海世纪出版集团涉嫌虚假宣传韩寒获得首届新概念大赛一等奖的民事诉讼作出了裁定。

  在这里有必要对不熟悉民事法规的网友做个简单的介绍:

  裁定与判决的区别:

  1、适用的事项不同。裁定解决的是诉讼过程中的程序性问题,目的是使人民法院有效地指挥诉讼,清除诉讼中的障碍,推进诉讼进程。判决解决的是当事人双方争执的权利义务问题,即实体法律关系,目的是解决民事权益纠纷,使当事人之间的争议得以解决。
   2、作出的依据不同。裁定根据的事实是程序性事实、依据的法律是民事诉讼法,可以在诉讼过程中的任何阶段作出。判决根据的事实是人民法院认定的民事法律 关系发生、变更和消灭的事实,依据的法律是民法、婚姻法、继承法、经济法等实体法,判决只能在案件审理的最后阶段作出。
  3、形式、上诉范 围、上诉期限和法律效力不同,裁定可以采取口头形式或者书面形式,而判决必须采取书面形式。裁定只有不予受理、对管辖权有异议的和驳回起诉的裁定,根据民 事诉讼法的规定,准许当事人在裁定后10日内上诉,其他裁定一经作出,立即生效;而判决允许上诉的范围比较广泛,地方各级人民法院作出的第一审判决,在判 决作出后15日内准许上诉。裁定的效力可以相应改变,如对中止诉讼的裁定,在中止诉讼的原因消除后,应作出恢复诉讼程序的新裁定;而判决的效力及于实体, 非经法定程序不得改变。

  上海二中院和上海徐汇法院的裁定理由很简单,综合起来就是一句话:

  原告虽然持有被告出版的出版物,但是没有发票,无法证明与被告形成买卖合同关系,所以没有诉权。至于被告出版物上是否涉及虚假宣传韩寒的获奖问题,也就不在审理范围之内了。

  这二家法院在裁定书后面附上的民事法条款,却有意回避了《出版管理条例2011》第二十七条:
  出版物的内容不真实或者不公正,致使公民、法人或者其他组织的合法权益受到侵害的,其出版单位应当公开更正,消除影响,并依法承担其他民事责任。
  报纸、期刊发表的作品内容不真实或者不公正,致使公民、法人或者其他组织的合法权益受到侵害的,当事人有权要求有关出版单位更正或者答辩,有关出版单位应当在其近期出版的报纸、期刊上予以发表;拒绝发表的,当事人可以向人民法院提起诉讼。
  至于裁定书中根据购书发票判定出版物消费者与出版单位构成买卖合同关系的依据,显然也是站不住脚的:消费者的购书发票,只能证明与出售该书的书店构成买卖合同关系。依然无法证明出版物消费者与出版社形成买卖合同关系。

  上海徐汇法院和上海二中院的这二份裁定书,事实上剥夺了出版物消费者依法追究出版社责任的权利。

  本人将对上海徐汇法院的裁定书提起上诉。

  上海二中院和上海徐汇法院的吃相已经相当的难看了。

 

原文地址:http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_5edf2c940102v7v5.html

分类: 

参与评分: 

平均评分: 4.6 (10个评价)

评论

jianbin0830

jianbin0830的头像

jianbin0830

canada goose jackets

coach outlet clearance

polo outlet

longchamp bags

ugg outlet online

burberry outlet store

lebron shoes

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet

adidas shoes

canada goose jackets

cheap ray ban sunglasses

basketball shoes,basketball sneakers,lebron james shoes,sports shoes,kobe bryant shoes,kobe sneakers,nike basketball shoes,running shoes,mens sport shoes,nike shoes

coach factory outlet

christian louboutin sale

ugg outlet store

polo ralph lauren outlet

mbt shoes

coach outlet online

true religion outlet uk

tods outlet online

burberry canada

uggs outlet

christian louboutin outlet

uggs outlet

ugg boots clearance

cheap oakley sunglasses

michael kors uk

ray ban sunglasses wholesale

oakley sunglasses wholesale

kobe bryants shoes

ugg boots for women,ugg boots,ugg boots outlet,ugg boots on sale,ugg boots clearance,ugg boots for men,ugg boots for kids,ugg boots clearance sale women,ugg boots clearance outlet

lacoste polo

ugg boots clearance

ugg boots clearance,ugg boots,ugg boots outlet,ugg boots for women,ugg boots on sale,ugg boots for men,ugg boots for kids,ugg boots clearance sale women,ugg boots clearance outlet

coach outlet store online

canada goose jackets

pandora outlet

ralph lauren outlet

roshe run

ralph lauren outlet

ralph lauren uk

coach outlet store online

coach outlet

ecco outlet

tory burch outlet online

michael kors outlet clearance

ray ban sunglasses uk

cheap jordan shoes

swarovski jewelry

coach outlet clearance

michael kors outlet clearance

christian louboutin shoes

coach outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

nike store uk

michael kors outlet online

mulberry bags

mulberry outlet

michael kors outlet online

nba jerseys

ralph?lauren

uggs outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

lebron shoes

nhl jerseys

mulberry handbags sale

coach outlet clearance

cheap ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

canada goose jackets on sale

ray ban sunglasses outlet

cheap jordans

michael kors outlet stores

mac outlet

cheap jordan shoes

pandora outlet

ralph lauren outlet

salomon outlet

polo ralph lauren

nike air huarache

kate spade uk

nike air max 90

oakley sunglasses wholesale

christian louboutin

oakley sunglasses sale

coach outlet store online

ferragamo shoes

coach outlet online

valentino shoes

nike outlet online

true religion outlet store

converse shoes sale

swarovski crystal

mulberry outlet,mulberry handbags outlet

kate spade

canada goose jackets

fitflops

michael kors handbags

ray ban sunglasses

cheap oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin shoes

ralph lauren

pandora outlet

uggs outlet

asics,asics israel,asics shoes,asics running shoes,asics israel,asics gel,asics running,asics gel nimbus,asics gel kayano

coach outlet

coach outlet store online

ferragamo outlet

ugg outlet online

burberry outlet store

michael kors bags

mulberry handbags

cheap ray ban sunglasses

polo ralph lauren outlet

soccer jerseys wholesale

swarovski jewelry

los angeles lakers

michael kors outlet

birkenstock shoes

air max 90

birkenstock shoes

coach outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

ed hardy outlet

canada goose jackets for women

polo outlet stores

coach outlet

coach factory outlet

 

ugg boots clearance

ray ban sunglasses

oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin sale

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet

ferragamo outlet

uggs outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

cheap ray bans

cheap michael kors handbags

michael kors outlet online

oakley sunglasses sale

canada goose jackets outlet

ugg boots outlet

coach factory outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

oakley sunglasses

herve leger dresses

true religion uk

cheap oakley sunglasses

kate spade handbags

ugg boots clearance

nike outlet store online

michael kors outlet online

reebok shoes

canada goose jackets

true religion outlet

canada goose jackets

ugg outlet store

tory burch outlet online

nike shoes

air max trainers

fitflops

ysl outlet online

michael kors outlet

christian louboutin outlet

true religion jeans sale

michael kors outlet clearance

coach outlet

cheap jordans free shipping

coach outlet online

ugg clearance

christian louboutin shoes

ray ban sunglasses outlet

michael kors outlet online

polo ralph lauren

michael kors handbags

coach outlet online

swarovski uk

tory burch handbags

adidas nmd

longchamp handbags

uggs outlet

bottega veneta outlet online

oakley sunglasses wholesale

nfl jerseys

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap oakley sunglasses

canada goose outlet

michael kors outlet online

mbt shoes outlet

true religion jeans

christian louboutin sale

michael kors outlet

ferragamo outlet

tory burch outlet online

chrome hearts outlet

cheap jordan shoes

michael kors uk

polo pas cher

polo ralph lauren

ugg outlet clearance,ugg outlet online clearance,ugg outlet,uggs outlet,ugg outlet store,ugg outlet coupons,ugg outlet boots,ugg outlet online store,ugg outlet sale

nike air huarache

coach outlet online

christian louboutin shoes

yeezy boost

coach outlet

ugg outlet,ugg outlet clearance,uggs outlet,ugg outlet online clearance,ugg outlet store,ugg outlet online store,ugg outlet sale,ugg outlet coupons,ugg outlet boots

cheap uggs outlet,cheap uggs for sale,cheap ugg boots,cheap uggs for kids,cheap uggs for women,cheap uggs bailey bow,cheap uggs china,cheap uggs for men,cheap uggs for girls,cheap uggs boots for women

canada goose

ugg boots clearance

adidas uk store

polo outlet

coach factory outlet

pandora jewellery

coach outlet clearance

ugg outlet

coach outlet online

coach outlet online

coach factory outlet

coach outlet online

oakley sunglasses wholesale

nike free running

michael kors handbags outlet

longchamp outlet

tory burch outlet online

mulberry outlet

coach handbags outlet

michael kors outlet

soccer cleats

coach outlet

canada goose jackets

ralph lauren

coach factory outlet

ralph lauren?uk

cheap nfl jerseys

supra shoes sale

true religion jeans outlet

polo outlet store

ralph?lauren?polo?shirts

jordan shoes

coach outlet

ray-ban sunglasses

canada goose outlet store

michael kors outlet online

coach factory outlet

fitflops sale clearance

nike blazer pas cher

michael kors outlet online

michael kors outlet online

swarovski outlet

coach outlet online

ray ban wayfarer

canada goose outlet

michael kors handbags clearance

oakley sunglasses wholesale

cheap jordan shoes

oakley sunglasses wholesale

nike trainers

ralph lauren uk

ugg outlet

canada goose jackets

ugg boots clearance

nike trainers

michael kors handbags

pandora charms sale clearance

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors outlet online

michael kors outlet online

kobe 9 elite

moncler coats

coach factory outlet

Nike Free shoes

coach outlet

michael kors outlet online

uggs outlet

canada goose coats

cheap uggs

mcm backpacks

mac tools

oakley sunglasses wholesale

air max shoes

adidas nmd runner

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors handbags

oakley sunglasses wholesale

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet store

pandora bracelet

ugg boots outlet

nhl jerseys wholesale

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors wallets for women

Basketball Shoes

michael kors uk

adidas shoes

cheap oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren outlet

nba jerseys wholesale

cheap oakley sunglasses

snapbacks wholesale

new balance outlet

coach outlet online

nike roshe run

snapback hats

canada goose parka

ugg boots,ugg boots outlet,ugg boots for women,ugg boots on sale,ugg boots clearance,ugg boots for men,ugg boots for kids,ugg boots clearance sale women,ugg boots clearance outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

giuseppe zanotti shoes

coach factory outlet

cheap jerseys wholesale

polo outlet

fitflops

kobe shoes

oakley sunglasses sale

adidas outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

mbt shoes outlet

ugg outlet stores

adidas shoes

christian louboutin sale

fitflops sale clearance

tory burch sandals

michael kors canada

cheap oakley sunglasses

cheap jerseys wholesale

canada goose coats

cheap oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet clearance

ugg boots outlet

true religion outlet

ralph lauren polo

swarovski jewellery

puma shoes

ferragamo shoes sale

nike outle

uggs outlet

ralph lauren outlet stores

ralph lauren outlet

mulberry handbags

cheap oakley sunglasses

true religion jeans

moncler sale

canada goose outlet

ray ban sunglasses uk

cheap ray ban sunglasses

thomas sabo charms

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach outlet store online

nike air max 1

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap oakley sunglasses

longchamp outlet online

polo ralph lauren

fitflops sale clearance

canada goose outlet store

links of london jewellery

ferragamo shoes

christian louboutin

polo ralph lauren

ugg outlet store

coach outlet online

nike outlet

michael kors outlet online

cheap oakley sunglasses

true religion jeans sale

coach outlet

air max 90

longchamp outlet

prada sunglasses for women

mlb jerseys

coach outlet online

christian louboutin shoes

kate spade outlet online

true religion outlet

polo ralph lauren

christian louboutin uk

canada goose outlet

michael kors handbags

coach outlet online

adidas shoes

coach outlet store online

ugg outlet

mont blanc pens

ralph lauren polo

michael kors outlet clearance

nfl jersey

canada goose jackets men

michael kors factory outlet

pandora jewelery

ugg boots outlet

christian louboutin shoes

ugg outlet clearance

canada goose coats

coach factory outlet

burberry outlet sale

jerseys wholesale

pandora jewelry

michael kors outlet

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

chrome hearts online store

nike shoes outlet

hermes outlet store

fitflops sale clearance

marc jacobs sale

michael kors outlet online

mulberry uk

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。
Type the characters you see in this picture. (使用语音验证)
填入上图所示的数字或者单词;如果你看不清,点击保存按钮,系统会为您重新生成您新的图片。不区分大小写。